struggling with transition to automatic driving
struggling with transition to automatic driving
Author
Discussion

DrTroy

Original Poster:

10 posts

193 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Hi all, does anyone have any tips on how to enjoy driving an automatic car?

Spent the majority of my driving life with a manual, love the granularity and precision it offers. Now driving an auto and just can not get any enjoyment out of it. Worried electric is going to be the same. Is this the end of enjoyable driving? Although I notice all high end cars are auto, surely they are entertaining ?

thanks

Ice_blue_tvr

3,512 posts

195 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Which car? Some autos are better than others.. Then you have the whole cvt/torque converter/dual clutch variance.

alabbasi

3,257 posts

118 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
A V8 with a supercharger usually helps

Zedboy

888 posts

242 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Lots of positives from electric, but coupled with ever increasing tech it sucks the emotion and real control from driving. Good for some I guess, not for me

gangzoom

9,020 posts

246 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
alabbasi said:
A V8 with a supercharger usually helps
I got really confused by your V8 comment for a while, as last time I checked V3 Superchargers were only been deployed......than I realised you were talking about the old fashioned 'Superchargers' smile.


anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
DrTroy said:
Hi all, does anyone have any tips on how to enjoy driving an automatic car?

Spent the majority of my driving life with a manual, love the granularity and precision it offers. Now driving an auto and just can not get any enjoyment out of it. Worried electric is going to be the same. Is this the end of enjoyable driving? Although I notice all high end cars are auto, surely they are entertaining ?

thanks
Based on your comments above why did you get an automatic?

Automatics aren't for enjoyment, they remove interaction from the driving experience. High powered cars are autos to stop people over-revving the engines and claiming the damage on warranty.

If possible a gearbox re-map might improve things as the OEMs have to think about emissons, etc so the gearbox map/operation gets compromised from a driving enjoyment perspective.


Dashnine

1,719 posts

81 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
gottans said:
High powered cars are autos to stop people over-revving the engines and claiming the damage on warranty.
Hilarious and utter rubbish. rofl

OP - depends what the manual mode is like and how it’s activated, flappy paddles can be fun as can sequential style fore and act gear lever action.

A gearbox is only there because an ICE can’t cope with the full power / rev range required for the speed range (an electric motor can hence no gears). So you’re just helping the engine out as it can’t do what’s required itself, and while fun in some circumstances gets tedious in traffic, pootling around, etc. when an automatic is great and has a good manual mode for fun driving. Never missed it in the last 6 years of auto driving and doubt will ever go back to a manual by choice.

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

241 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
gottans said:
DrTroy said:
Hi all, does anyone have any tips on how to enjoy driving an automatic car?

Spent the majority of my driving life with a manual, love the granularity and precision it offers. Now driving an auto and just can not get any enjoyment out of it. Worried electric is going to be the same. Is this the end of enjoyable driving? Although I notice all high end cars are auto, surely they are entertaining ?

thanks
Based on your comments above why did you get an automatic?

Automatics aren't for enjoyment, they remove interaction from the driving experience. High powered cars are autos to stop people over-revving the engines and claiming the damage on warranty.

If possible a gearbox re-map might improve things as the OEMs have to think about emissons, etc so the gearbox map/operation gets compromised from a driving enjoyment perspective.
I was wondering that too because the whole point of an automatic is to relax and have less involvement in driving.





prand

6,248 posts

227 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Driving an auto is by its nature easier as its very much point and shoot driving. but I do agree somewhat with you OP.

My last 2 cars have been autos and I do miss the manual.

I I don't like the pause waiting for kickdown and pulling off the line. And I miss a good bit off clutch control.

My current car is a 3.0l audi biTDi with an 8 speed ZF auto. Amazingly quick when rolling; but In anything but Dynamic mode it really doesn't feel special unless you keep your foot pushed down.

I don't seem to get the eagerness feeling that you get from a manual when in 1st or 2nd you feel the car tugging to go faster. All a bit too controlled in an auto. Then again this is a big 2 tonne cruiser, I should get a carweham if I really want eager!

I am thinking about a remap of some sort, engine or gearbox to sort the off the line kickdown pause.

And don't get me started on adaptive cruise, its the nanny state in automotive form.


Hol

9,316 posts

231 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Ice_blue_tvr said:
Which car? Some autos are better than others.. Then you have the whole cvt/torque converter/dual clutch variance.
This.. I had a new S4 Audi in 2014 and I although I missed the manual box, I found ways to work around it.

For example, kicking the selector back into sports mode for small roundabouts and sharp turn dropped it quickly down a few gears and made that transition easier.

markymarkthree

3,720 posts

202 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Its the simplest form of motoring, just forget you have a left leg.

Howitzer

2,865 posts

247 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
A fun auto completely relies on a good engine in front of it.

It needs to be torquey, smooth but with a reasonable amount of range.

We have a 5.0 V8 petrol with a 4 speed auto and a 5.0 V8 with a 7 speed auto. The 4 speed is far nicer as it uses more of the engines Rev range and aural fun, so you can be dragging the car out of a corner in 3rd and go from 2000 to 6300rpm in one long surge with all the noise changes and drama that go with it. The 7 speed has had 3 gear changes and limited Rev range in the same situation.

The car would be fun with a manual in some situations but overall driving enjoyment is better with the old style auto.

Dave!

Lexington59

974 posts

96 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Get a Porsche PDK.

markymarkthree

3,720 posts

202 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Thankyou for telling me what i did or didn't do. rolleyes

Alex_225

7,913 posts

232 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
DrTroy said:
Hi all, does anyone have any tips on how to enjoy driving an automatic car?

Spent the majority of my driving life with a manual, love the granularity and precision it offers. Now driving an auto and just can not get any enjoyment out of it. Worried electric is going to be the same. Is this the end of enjoyable driving? Although I notice all high end cars are auto, surely they are entertaining ?

thanks
I guess it very much depends on the car and what element of driving you enjoy. If you're covering lots of miles the comfort and effortless can be a real joy. My S Class is ideal for doing just that, the enjoyment comes from the relaxing, ease of driving and the comfort. It's not really a car you fire down a B road and enjoy in that sense.

I think there are cars that strike a balance of that, performance cars with paddle shifts are probably a good compromise of both.

Depends on what aspects of driving you enjoy most I guess.


anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Dashnine said:
gottans said:
High powered cars are autos to stop people over-revving the engines and claiming the damage on warranty.
Hilarious and utter rubbish. rofl
If that statement is so wrong why don't tell everyone why you think it is wrong and what the correct answer is?

Just rubbishing an answer says you don't know and just felt the need to post some verbal diarrhoea, do you need any imodium?

Chubbyross

5,019 posts

116 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Lexington59 said:
Get a Porsche PDK.
This. With a Porsche attached. The PDK in my 911 turbo is absolutely perfect for the car. Once it’s learned that day’s driving style it practically reads your mind. You can also use the paddles or use the gear lever as a sequential-style stick. Don’t get me wrong, I still love manuals but it all depends on the car. I’d never get a smaller roadster with auto.

journeymanpro

933 posts

108 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
gottans said:
Dashnine said:
gottans said:
High powered cars are autos to stop people over-revving the engines and claiming the damage on warranty.
Hilarious and utter rubbish. rofl
If that statement is so wrong why don't tell everyone why you think it is wrong and what the correct answer is?

Just rubbishing an answer says you don't know and just felt the need to post some verbal diarrhoea, do you need any imodium?
He was right, what you posted was utter rubbish and just not true on any level.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
Well an autobox will stop you selecting a gear out of order i.e. too low a gear and over-revving the engine that way. Just because you can't do it when accelerating as the rev limiter stops it doesn't mean it cannot be done another way.

Grrbang

755 posts

102 months

Saturday 29th January 2022
quotequote all
The best way to enjoy your auto is to buy a second, manual car for the weekends.