Service history: does it stop being relevant at some point?
Discussion
The £1-5k barge thread raised a question in my mind this evening...
When buying a classic, there is a general rule that buying from an enthusiast who works on the car himself (possibly using specialists for the trickier jobs, e.g. if it's a Citroen then the fancy suspension is probably such a task) is a good thing. Such an enthusiast who includes a bootload of spares and consumables, and possibly starts crying as you drive his P&J away is a better thing. The logic being that he will have kept on top of maintenance and known when things weren't working as they should and will have fixed them. An original service book is more of a souvenir that goes along with the car for provenance.
When buying a nearly-new car, there is a general rule that you want to buy something that has been serviced, preferably by the main dealer, on time. Service history is paramount. The logic being that if you've bought a nice new car then skimped a few hundred quid on maintenance then you've probably thrashed the car half to death and it will explode as soon as the second owner gets it home.
At some point, a car will go from the latter to the former. When is that point for you? 10 years? 20 years? Longer?
(Obviously if you only ever buy new or nearly new this won't apply and you may not have an opinion on it!)
When buying a classic, there is a general rule that buying from an enthusiast who works on the car himself (possibly using specialists for the trickier jobs, e.g. if it's a Citroen then the fancy suspension is probably such a task) is a good thing. Such an enthusiast who includes a bootload of spares and consumables, and possibly starts crying as you drive his P&J away is a better thing. The logic being that he will have kept on top of maintenance and known when things weren't working as they should and will have fixed them. An original service book is more of a souvenir that goes along with the car for provenance.
When buying a nearly-new car, there is a general rule that you want to buy something that has been serviced, preferably by the main dealer, on time. Service history is paramount. The logic being that if you've bought a nice new car then skimped a few hundred quid on maintenance then you've probably thrashed the car half to death and it will explode as soon as the second owner gets it home.
At some point, a car will go from the latter to the former. When is that point for you? 10 years? 20 years? Longer?
(Obviously if you only ever buy new or nearly new this won't apply and you may not have an opinion on it!)
It’s an interesting question. I’ve wondered the same thing regarding mileage. As a Porsche owner I’m told that on no account must I drive my car for fear of piling on the miles and wrecking the value. But at some point it ceases to matter. Nobody would care if a Porsche 356 had covered 250k miles if the car had an interesting history and was in a reasonable condition. In fact the higher miles would possibly add to the car’s value - I remember reading an auctioneer’s perspective where he said that classic cars that have been really driven and have stories to tell are often more collectible than garage queens that have sat for years in a private collection.
I guess it’s the same point with service history. Nobody cares about service history on a GTO 250. At some point the inherent value of a car outweighs things like mileage, service history or number of owners.
Sorry, I didn’t give you an answer. Forgive my Saturday morning musings.
I guess it’s the same point with service history. Nobody cares about service history on a GTO 250. At some point the inherent value of a car outweighs things like mileage, service history or number of owners.
Sorry, I didn’t give you an answer. Forgive my Saturday morning musings.
Once it's out of warranty I couldn't care less who's serviced it, as long as it *has* been serviced and there's receipts to back that up.
I've seen quite a few cars with "full main dealer history" that have obviously been bodged and not done properly, fixed price servicing and the huge glass palaces means that you really don't get value for money there imho, and once they tell you to jog on for warranty claims what's the point?
I'm influenced because I DIY, but I think the best history is a fastidious, self-servicing owner who has receipts for everything and does a job right. Particularly if they've got multiple cars, therefore the quick fix isn't the one to use.
I've seen quite a few cars with "full main dealer history" that have obviously been bodged and not done properly, fixed price servicing and the huge glass palaces means that you really don't get value for money there imho, and once they tell you to jog on for warranty claims what's the point?
I'm influenced because I DIY, but I think the best history is a fastidious, self-servicing owner who has receipts for everything and does a job right. Particularly if they've got multiple cars, therefore the quick fix isn't the one to use.
Not the end of the world but it’s most important to me that it’s been cared for. If an owner keeps bills, and makes the effort to keep on top of things that’s important to me. However when it’s clearly been run on a budget history doesn’t help. Likewise if it’s been looked after but with very few bills.
I don’t care for dealer stamps though. A decent local garage seeing the car at sensible intervals will do me nicely. I keep receipts for everything on my own cars, and write in the service book when I service it.
I don’t care for dealer stamps though. A decent local garage seeing the car at sensible intervals will do me nicely. I keep receipts for everything on my own cars, and write in the service book when I service it.
I buy in the £2-3k range, usually cars around 10- 12 years old.
I go by condition and give the car a good look over (including underneath), check the mot history for anything terrible (usually corrosion or emissions stuff worries me) and leave it at that.
Service history is irrelevant as I won't be keeping it up, I do the servicing myself and no one cares if I write anything in the book.
I go by condition and give the car a good look over (including underneath), check the mot history for anything terrible (usually corrosion or emissions stuff worries me) and leave it at that.
Service history is irrelevant as I won't be keeping it up, I do the servicing myself and no one cares if I write anything in the book.
I have bought two Saab 9-5s for around £900 each and about 15-20 years old in recent years.
One had a full Saab service history, and has given almost no trouble over the past 7 years.
The other had a fairly rubbish service history and has had one thing after another fail.
Straw poll of two, identical model. Regular servicing matters. Even in a shed.
One had a full Saab service history, and has given almost no trouble over the past 7 years.
The other had a fairly rubbish service history and has had one thing after another fail.
Straw poll of two, identical model. Regular servicing matters. Even in a shed.
I stop worrying about dealer history when the warranty is up, as long as the receipts are there and the car has obviously been looked after (mot history, matching tyres and number plates, etc) then I'm happy. If anything self servicing by a competent enthusiast is better than going to a garage/dealership as mechanics can be careless when not working on their own cars.
You should always buy on condition…but the problem is that most of us aren’t car mechanics and usually can’t tell a good car from a bad car. FSH gives some confidence, which may be false, that any problems have been identified and dealt with.
Having a pre sale inspection is best but only worthwhile on cars that are expensive ie proper classics.
Having a pre sale inspection is best but only worthwhile on cars that are expensive ie proper classics.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


