Insurance groups and costs for young drivers
Insurance groups and costs for young drivers
Author
Discussion

Olds124

Original Poster:

102 posts

91 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
Looking at a getting a car for 17 year old daughter. Got the boy a 2009 1.2 Jazz a couple of years ago. A nice look8ng 2007 1.4 Fiesta Zetec might be available. It is insurance group 10. The Jazz is 13. Each around the same value. When I do a confused quote, the Fiesta comes up as just over £1000 with a black box (which is what the Jazz was when the boy was 17), but the Jazz, with its higher group, is “only” £768 without a black box. The only material difference is the engine size, but wouldn’t this be reflected in the group? Anyone able to cast any light about what might be happening here?

Dingu

4,893 posts

61 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
Claim statistics.

Group is only a fraction of the story. Claim rates for similar profile drivers in each car is the simple answer.


To expand a little if the companies see 17 year old drivers of similar profile crashing x% of times for the fiesta and y% for the Jazz and y is appreciably less than x then the price will be lower. The group difference won’t matter particularly in that calculation.

A jazz with its reputation could be quite a good first car choice in terms of insurance as it won’t be that desirable to your average 17 year old.

Edited by Dingu on Wednesday 9th February 18:17


Edited by Dingu on Wednesday 9th February 18:18

Olds124

Original Poster:

102 posts

91 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
Thanks. Very helpful. I’d actually prefer to get another Jazz anyway as the first one has been extremely reliable and cheap to run. In fact I’d prefer to make them share the first Jazz but that is not going to be very practical.

stogbandard

443 posts

81 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
I remember my 1st premium being £360 third party fire and theft in 1990 for a 1979 Toyota Corolla 1.3 Liftback and thought that was expensive. It was left hand drive though. I guess inflation would put that at close to £1,000 in today’s money. Petrol back then was 38p per litre. The old 10p piece was the size of a manhole cover.

Canon_Fodder

1,775 posts

94 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
Also how much they get nicked correlated to postcode.

Makes me think - has a Jazz ever been stolen? And if so, why?

Someone whose Gran has mislaid her shopping trolley but urgently needs to get her incontinence pants back from Asda?

Or another reason?


Eyersey1234

3,097 posts

110 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
When I was 19 I remember one company quoting me £3000 to insure a M reg Fiesta, this was in 2006. They were basically saying they didn't want the business. I paid about a grand for the first years insurance in the end

anonymous-user

85 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
my first insurance was £2200 from Norwich Union (i think) for a £1300 1.3 swift 8v. I soon realised TPFT was the way forward in such a cheap car.

MRichards99

330 posts

159 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
That's similar to my experience insuring my first car in 2016. Getting quotes for a Corsa and Fiesta were £1800-2000 with no black box. A Yaris or Ka were £1100-1300. I think the key to cheap(er) insurance for a young driver is insuring something that most 17 year olds wouldn't drive and therefore crash.

Are insurance groups are less relevant than they were 10-15 years ago? I remember them being part of most car reviews of cars marketed for new drivers, I don't know if they still are these days.

Jack2199

35 posts

79 months

Wednesday 9th February 2022
quotequote all
Yep the insurance groups mean noting for young drivers. M a also one of them. Hd black box polices around two years back.

Yes the Honda jazz will any day be cheaper than the fiesta for a new driver. Infact for me the 1.0 corsa D was the most expensive even tho it was a 04 insurance group😂

Have checked several quotes during those years and some of the cheaper ones are: (that I can recall)

Skoda fabia
Honda jazz
Citroen C3
Hyundai i10
Hyundai i20
Vw polo 2006 to 2010
Toyota yaris
Toyota aygo
Citroen c1
Kia picanto (was the cheapest)
Nissan micra


andrebar

523 posts

153 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
Teenage driver insurance seems to make no sense these days. My daughter has been seeing cheaper quotes for a 2.0 litre Mondeo than some of the Panda/Aygo class vehicles that conventional logic would suggest.

TwigtheWonderkid

49,305 posts

181 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
andrebar said:
Teenage driver insurance seems to make no sense these days. My daughter has been seeing cheaper quotes for a 2.0 litre Mondeo than some of the Panda/Aygo class vehicles that conventional logic would suggest.
If an particular insurance company finds that teenage drivers produce better claims stats in 2.0 Mondeos than in Panda/Aygos, then it makes perfect sense.

RicksAlfas

14,610 posts

275 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
Teenagers like Corsas and Fiestas so there are a lot of claims against those cars.
Buy a Jazz or Roomster and whilst the kid will not be trendy the insurance will be lower.
I seem to remember the Focus and Duster weren't bad either if they want something bigger.

QuattroDave

1,821 posts

159 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
Jack2199 said:
Yep the insurance groups mean nothing
... beyond the first couple of years of production.

I'm surprised more people aren't aware that insurance groupings are really only indicative of a cars relative cost of insuring for the first couple of years of a models production whilst claim data is sufficiently built for them to rely on. Actuarial data will always be preferred over indicative ratings from new.

When I was looking at my first car waaay back in 1998 I spent ages getting quotes for various cars and the 'low' insurance group 40bhp 1.0 fiesta's were coming out at £1,500ish to insure whilst much higher insurance group cars such a the 105bhp Rover 216i came in at £700.

More people claimed whilst driving fiesta's than those driving Rovers, I suspect because more young people drove fiestas whilst older 'safer' people drove Rovers.

Best bet is get a shortlist of cars and check them all out on comparator websites. Chances are some larger insurance group cars will be considerably cheaper than lower ones. Go for a brand perceived to be driven by 'old' people and there you'll get the relatively cheaper quotes!

LankyFreak

876 posts

59 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
Dumb one but I had a 350z quoted to be the same as my mums 1.0 litre ST Line Fiesta...

QuattroDave

1,821 posts

159 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
LankyFreak said:
Dumb one but I had a 350z quoted to be the same as my mums 1.0 litre ST Line Fiesta...
Not dumb at all. More claims are made (and/or higher average claim value) on Fiesta's than 350z's.

I had a C6 RS6 with a declared 700bhp of mods. insurance for 10k miles was £190 full comp Replaced temporarily with an Alfa 147 1.9JTDI with 115bhp (whilst M140i was being built) and insurance for that was £300.

True story - the alfa was much more fun to drive than the RS6!

spookly

4,397 posts

126 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
I've been looking at quotes for my 17 year old lad.
Getting quotes that are about the same for an NB 1.6 mx5 as for a 1L Fiesta.

stu67

892 posts

219 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
I had the same thing with my son a good few years back. His first car was a Fabia that was fairly cheap to insure, it got interesting 2 years later when he went for his second car. He got a decent job and wanted to buy a fairly new Golf, very expensive quote, same for a Focus, Fiesta etc. He ended up buying a couple of year old Jaguar S type that was actually cheaper to insure than the Fiesta's etc. So my advice would be to go "off piste"

QuattroDave

1,821 posts

159 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
stu67 said:
I had the same thing with my son a good few years back. His first car was a Fabia that was fairly cheap to insure, it got interesting 2 years later when he went for his second car. He got a decent job and wanted to buy a fairly new Golf, very expensive quote, same for a Focus, Fiesta etc. He ended up buying a couple of year old Jaguar S type that was actually cheaper to insure than the Fiesta's etc. So my advice would be to go "off piste"
This 100%

Your son basically did the same thing I did when I was young and bought an 'old man' car and has ended up with a more powerful, refined, comfortable, spacious car that costs a lot less to insure and probably not a massive amount different to run!

RazerSauber

2,955 posts

91 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
When my other half first looked at driving, her insurance quotes were really high. Followed the Martin Lewis 21 day trick and looked at weird and wonderful cars. Mk3 Mondeos were surprisingly cheap in poverty spec automatic format. As other people have said above, they're crashed by teens less so hopefully cheaper to insure. Worth looking into stuff that's not micro hatch backs with wheezy engines in. They might get such creature comforts as an arm rest or air con, too. I seem to find that 5 door cars are cheaper than 3 door equivalents too. Perhaps stolen more because they look "better"?

Elroy Blue

8,858 posts

223 months

Thursday 10th February 2022
quotequote all
My 18yr old (full licence since Nov), pays £800 fully comp with black box for a 1.4 Citroën DS3.