Manufacturer competitor tear downs
Manufacturer competitor tear downs
Author
Discussion

The spinner of plates

Original Poster:

18,084 posts

231 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
I remember reading back in the day that when a manufacturer had a new car approaching launch, competitors would have a covert order in.

On day of collection their engineers would then tear it down to it's component parts to in order to understanding everything - parts, technologies, manufacturing techniques etc to see what they could learn.

Does this still happen?
In todays digital / highly consolidated world, I guess there is a specialist company out there that does this and then sells that info on to anyone who wants to buy it?
So when the new S Class launches, within a week everyone else just buys a digital file with everything they need to know - complete with specs, CAD scans etc of every component within it.

Or - does it still happen? And BMW engineers pore over Mercedes parts in some top secret area of the factory, nodding in appreciation or mocking at the cost savings going on.

No idea why this thought has popped into my head on a Saturday morning.

Enlighten me PHers!

Grrbang

755 posts

102 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
It absolutely does.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
100% still does, there's even professional companies that you can pay to do it/for the info who do it anyway to save your own engineers the work.

e.g. Munro and associates: https://leandesign.com/

They also have a youtube channel with some interesting videos, although the chap is very pro-US and has a real love for Tesla (rightly or wrongly in some cases). https://www.youtube.com/c/MunroLive/featured

Tyre Smoke

23,018 posts

292 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
They certainly do. They also use other manufacturers as test mules.

TVR Cerbera as a mules for the Merc SLR. A very cheap way of a high performance chassis set up ready for your motor.


595Heaven

3,520 posts

109 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Yep, very much still a thing.

Fascinating to see.

gsr121

155 posts

151 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
I know this isn’t quite what you mean but I found this video, I assume made by Ford, on YouTube the other day. I had no particular affinity to either Ford or Vauxhall, but it did make me cringe a bit

https://youtu.be/Kw4B80-YNo0

Benmac

1,706 posts

247 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Yep definitely. I went on a factory tour at Bentley a few years ago and in the presentation from the design team they had some pics of them taking various measurements from cars they were benchmarking against.

One was a 911. They weren’t too impressed at me asking that considering they were ultimately part of the same company couldn’t they just have asked Porsche?

Sf_Manta

2,347 posts

222 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Still does, and there's even companies specializing in it.

https://portal.a2mac1.com/ for example

HJG

663 posts

138 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Sometimes an official swap is done between the manufactures. I guess this enables the manufacture to provide a 'control' sample.

Puddenchucker

6,011 posts

249 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
HJG said:
Sometimes an official swap is done between the manufactures. I guess this enables the manufacture to provide a 'control' sample.
IIRC, there was (is?) a 'gentlman's' agreement between German manufacturers do do just that with every new model produced.

couzens

602 posts

173 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Tyre Smoke said:
They certainly do. They also use other manufacturers as test mules.

TVR Cerbera as a mules for the Merc SLR. A very cheap way of a high performance chassis set up ready for your motor.

That is incredible. Never knew that!

Starfighter

5,352 posts

209 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Didn’t Aston use a Transit as a mule to get some engine miles?

rscott

17,526 posts

222 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Starfighter said:
Didn’t Aston use a Transit as a mule to get some engine miles?
Wasn't that Jaguar, with the XJ220 engine.
The Transit regularly goes up Goodwood, complete with ladder on the roof and empty coffee cups on the dash..

https://youtu.be/RpR3I_ZwyGw

trashbat

6,318 posts

184 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Alfa tore down a BMW 3 Series when developing the Giulia in its 'skunkworks', I believe.

Debaser

8,699 posts

292 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
OEMs have fleets of competitors cars for benchmarking. Also cars are loaned between OEMs if it’s a fairly brief assessment.

As mentioned above there are companies who conduct some tear down benchmarking, though OEMs still regularly tear down competitor vehicles.

ChrisSMorris

221 posts

266 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
100%. How can you make your car better if you don't understand the competition?

It reminds me when working for company A, we went testing with a vehicle from Company B at a proving ground. And whilst we were there, Company B turns up with one of our vehicles to do the same. Everyone's doing it.

samoht

7,325 posts

177 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all

I recall on the Mazda factory tour, noting an E46 M3 in Phoenix Yellow parked up for evaluation.

Rushjob

2,318 posts

289 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
In the bike world, Triumph Motorcycles, their R&D department had an account with the BMW dealership I worked for and were always ordering parts from me for 1200GS's and the 800's etc to reverse engineer and they also had several BMW bikes from us to use as test mules.

Magikarp

1,770 posts

79 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
Fascinating. It does make you wonder though, how, given that this goes on, it took so long for Audi and Mercedes so long to make any sort of inroad into the BMW 5 Series’ generally acknowledged superiority. Unless of course the things that made it popular and review better were at complete odds with the companies’ ethos?

ARHarh

4,892 posts

138 months

Saturday 12th February 2022
quotequote all
I worked in R&D for many years and this happens in all areas, not just cars. I spent many happy hours stripping apart competitor products, It was always nice to have a play with them first. And then to see some of the reworking to get early examples working. It was mostly consumer electronics stuff.