Road pricing and tax
Author
Discussion

TyrannosauRoss Lex

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
It seems that the government will be introducing road pricing schemes because they aren't getting the money from VED with EVs.

How do you think this will work? GPS trackers in cars (what about older cars?). What I find strange is we also pay what they're saying this is, it's called fuel. The more we drive and the less economical our car is, we pay more.

I feel this is really going to be a final nail in the coffin for enjoyable motoring. If you have GPS tracking then it absolutely means that you could easily get picked up for speeding etc.

Would be interested in hearing the thoughts of the collective.

LeeM135i

711 posts

85 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
The challenge is not the road tax which is fixed at £155 per car + the over £40,000 top up (which pretty much all electric cars fall into) its fuel.

Petrol tax is 57.95p per litre then 20% VAT on top of the tax and the cost of the fuel, we pay around 90p per litre at the moment, electric cars pay the road tax but not the fuel duty loosing the government over £45 every time you don't fill up with dino juice.

How do you tax the electric car that is supposed to be here to save the planet? Politically they can't charge you £45 in tax every time you charge your electric car at home so they will charge you per mile to use the roads. They did look at putting in a dedicated car charger which could be charged (taxed) at a different rate to your home electricity but most people would just use a 3 pin socket and charge the car every night.

How its going to be done? Who knows?

GPS in every car is expensive and can be tampered with VIA signal blocker
Cameras are expensive to put in if you want to cover every square mile
Annual bill when you MOT / inspect the car can be tampered with VIA clocking (magnet against the wheel to plugging a laptop in)

My worry is all cars will pay the per mile charge include the petrol ones which will also pay the tax on fuel and road tax pricing them off the roads.

NMNeil

5,860 posts

81 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
TyrannosauRoss Lex said:
It seems that the government will be introducing road pricing schemes because they aren't getting the money from VED with EVs.

How do you think this will work? GPS trackers in cars (what about older cars?). What I find strange is we also pay what they're saying this is, it's called fuel. The more we drive and the less economical our car is, we pay more.

I feel this is really going to be a final nail in the coffin for enjoyable motoring. If you have GPS tracking then it absolutely means that you could easily get picked up for speeding etc.

Would be interested in hearing the thoughts of the collective.
New cars already have black box recorders fitted as standard. I don't believe they track you yet, but it's in the pipeline.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7376227/E...
https://www.carthrottle.com/post/pay-as-you-go-car...
To make it work on older cars, they may compare mileage between one MOT test and the next, and calculate what you owe.
In the interim you may have to pay a monthly fee, and at the end of the year either make up the difference or get a refund, just like your income taxes.
But trust me, they will find a way.





Dingu

4,893 posts

61 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
But trust me, they will find a way.
And they should. We have consistently out spent tax take for years so can scarcely afford the reduction in income.

Unless the tax is added to other taxes of course.

I’m sure someone will be along soon to point out its not fair because they live 50 miles from anything, but any house has benefits and disbenefits.

TyrannosauRoss Lex

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
Dingu said:
NMNeil said:
But trust me, they will find a way.
And they should. We have consistently out spent tax take for years so can scarcely afford the reduction in income.

Unless the tax is added to other taxes of course.

I’m sure someone will be along soon to point out its not fair because they live 50 miles from anything, but any house has benefits and disbenefits.
Don't they already make that up though by the fact they get more tax from more fuel used by the ICE cars? Eg if you drive 10k miles/year you pay more tax than if you drive 5k miles per year?

Lozw86

903 posts

163 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
Yes

More money into the bottomless state pit

Nickbrapp

5,277 posts

161 months

Tuesday 15th February 2022
quotequote all
No doubt it will just be phased in, all new cars have GPS equipment in, so they will use that for EVs as they are new, old stuff still uses petrol and diesel, so tax will remain on that.

robdcfc

525 posts

189 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Dingu said:
NMNeil said:
But trust me, they will find a way.
And they should. We have consistently out spent tax take for years so can scarcely afford the reduction in income.

Unless the tax is added to other taxes of course.

I’m sure someone will be along soon to point out its not fair because they live 50 miles from anything, but any house has benefits and disbenefits.
Whos the WE have over spent?? The buffons running the country spend and spend like its never ending and borrow more money each money than is imaginable.

Until that stops then us normal folk will be picking up the tab for it.

They dont seem to understand what a budget is unless they are just saying you will pay more tax and have less money to feed/heat yourself/family.

They pay over the odds to their mates for works to be done in all fields and we all sit back and accept it.

Local to me they have done some road works budgeted at 15m that end up costing 47m and theres also HS2 for example, looking like 3 to 4 times over budget to build something that will be obsolete when finished but thats ok because its given people jobs for a while.

kambites

71,734 posts

252 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
To make it work on older cars, they may compare mileage between one MOT test and the next, and calculate what you owe.
Since those older cars are almost all running on fossil fuels and hence can be taxed in that way, do they actually need a way to levy this tax on older cars?

My guess would be that we'll see petrol/diesel duty stay roughly as it is, probably rising roughly in line with inflation, with an small additional per-mile tax for all vehicles produced after a certain date. That "small" additional tax can then be ramped up as desired in the future. This would have the added bonus that buyers of new ICE vehicles would get taxed twice, hastening the transition to EVs without the government having to directly subsidise it.

Edited by kambites on Wednesday 16th February 08:01

Jamescrs

6,554 posts

96 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Nickbrapp said:
No doubt it will just be phased in, all new cars have GPS equipment in, so they will use that for EVs as they are new, old stuff still uses petrol and diesel, so tax will remain on that.
I think this is the most likely outcome in the end, although again it does beg the question of how they will get around people blocking the GPS signal, sure they will make it illegal but so are many things related to motoring and we all know the chances of getting caught are tiny in reality

a_dreamer

2,414 posts

68 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Lozw86 said:
Yes

More money into the bottomless state pit
Andrews legal bills and settlement fees don't grow on trees

TyrannosauRoss Lex

Original Poster:

36,729 posts

243 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Jamescrs said:
Nickbrapp said:
No doubt it will just be phased in, all new cars have GPS equipment in, so they will use that for EVs as they are new, old stuff still uses petrol and diesel, so tax will remain on that.
I think this is the most likely outcome in the end, although again it does beg the question of how they will get around people blocking the GPS signal, sure they will make it illegal but so are many things related to motoring and we all know the chances of getting caught are tiny in reality
Used car prices are already crazy enough, you reckon when this scheme comes in they'll go even higher? hehe

bigothunter

13,592 posts

91 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
LeeM135i said:
My worry is all cars will pay the per mile charge include the petrol ones which will also pay the tax on fuel and road tax pricing them off the roads.
Road pricing will apply to petrol and diesel cars just like EVs. The chancellor won't miss that trick especially as it fits the green agenda.

MitchT

17,167 posts

240 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
The simplest and most obvious solution is to scrap VED and add a supplement onto the price of a litre of fuel for ICE cars. For EVs, meter the electricity that is used to charge them and add the supplement to the price of that electricity. That way your fuel/power consumption, and therefore pollution caused, is proportionate to what you pay.

Of course, if the government can avoid something so simple in favour of an overly complicated tech solution that takes ten times longer to implement than it should, runs massively over budget, wasting billions of taxpayers' money in the process, is full of bugs that create erroneous data and result in people being overcharged and, most importantly, presents an opportunity for a government minister to award the contract to one of their dodgy mates, then that's what they'll do.

Edited by MitchT on Wednesday 16th February 08:40

a_dreamer

2,414 posts

68 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Something has to replace the fuel tax. The current system is ridiculous as it generates a huge amount of tax. They have to be careful though. You should tax things you want to discourage, petrol, diesel, cigarettes and alcohol etc and not tax things you wish to encourage. But at some point there will be a tipping point and the government will want to create billions of revenue for a best mates new business.

kambites

71,734 posts

252 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
MitchT said:
The simplest and most obvious solution is to scrap VED and add a supplement onto the price of a litre of fuel for ICE cars. For EVs, meter the electricity that is used to charge them and add the supplement to the price of that electricity. That way your fuel/power consumption, and therefore pollution caused, is proportionate to what you pay.
The problem is that's not simple at all. There is no practical means for working out what electricity is used to charge cars and what's used for other purposes. I think realistically to tax electricity used for charging EVs they'd have to ban charging EVs from standard 3-pin sockets, which would significant reduce the practicality of them for many people.

Either that or they'd need the car itself to report how much it has been charged, and if they have that they might as well use that link to charge per mile, which would also allow them to charge different amounts at different times and on different roads which would be hugely appealing.

bigothunter

13,592 posts

91 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
MitchT said:
The simplest and most obvious solution is to scrap VED and add a supplement onto the price of a litre of fuel for ICE cars. For EVs, meter the electricity that is used to charge them and add the supplement to the price of that electricity. That way your fuel/power consumption, and therefore pollution caused, is proportionate to what you pay.
Multiple taxation routes conceal how much is actually being extracted from the consumer (aka motorist). Why scrap VED when it can be applied almost unnoticed? Nothing to stop an extra 'green tax' being added to the price of fuel though.

FiF

49,046 posts

282 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
I don't know how they will do this, though suspect it will involve some sort of GPS tracking system, some insurance companies are already doing this to figure out premiums. Alternatively using a tag system that you carry / display some sort of electronic tag that is detected might work for toll roads, but general network too expensive to setup in my opinion. Is the ANPR network sufficient to read number plates, maybe in urban areas and motorways / trunk roads, away from that probably not, and again expensive.

Which brings us to the crux of my concerns. At the moment the Exchequer has a very simple tax collection system, namely it just feeds through the system from places which sell fuel. All these alternatives will not only need infrastructure, sometimes quite expensive, but also there will be the need to millions of payment accounts one for each vehicle. It just seems like a significantly less efficient way to collect the revenue.

Plus if we believe, a very big IF there, if we believe what some proposers say that road charging will be set to be revenue neutral for the average motorist, then placing such a complicated charging process in the hands of an organisation whose efficiency is limited by the weakest link, ie DVLA, then either tax take will be reduced, or the tax at source will have to be significantly increased.


Dingu

4,893 posts

61 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
robdcfc said:
Whos the WE have over spent?? The buffons running the country spend and spend like its never ending and borrow more money each money than is imaginable.

Until that stops then us normal folk will be picking up the tab for it.

They dont seem to understand what a budget is unless they are just saying you will pay more tax and have less money to feed/heat yourself/family.

They pay over the odds to their mates for works to be done in all fields and we all sit back and accept it.

Local to me they have done some road works budgeted at 15m that end up costing 47m and theres also HS2 for example, looking like 3 to 4 times over budget to build something that will be obsolete when finished but thats ok because its given people jobs for a while.
We as a country elected them, so me, you and everyone else ultimately. It’s not an issue isolated to one party or one side of politics so I would be surprised if you have never voted for a party which have borrowed to spend.

GroundZero

2,085 posts

85 months

Wednesday 16th February 2022
quotequote all
Why couldn't government vastly simplify road tax? By placing a rate on vehicles by weight as they roll out the factory. Weight is a strong contributing factor for damaging road surface for which in many people's eyes the road tax was originally introduced to fund.
So a simple formula say, Weight(kg)x0.2=£Tax

It would remove the need for all cars to install new location/speed equipment and remove the need to for government to install monitoring/surveillance equipment, people can retain privacy when they travel and the government receive a steady predictable income.