Failing to recognise your current car is perfect for you
Discussion
Some drivers choose a car and stick with it for decades - whether it’s the best car for their needs or not.
Others flit between cars like one-night stands, potentially ditching those that could be worthy of a much longer relationship.
I’ve been driving for 16 years and have had 8 cars - plus 3 second cars over the last 9 months. I’m very much in the itchy feet camp now, regularly debating whether to sell one or both of my current cars, despite them doing everything I need.
Both have pretty much all the kit I want, plus appealing engines and are in good condition. The only thing I actively object to is that the second one costs £600 to tax, which feels wasteful and I’d prefer sports seats. However, the car was a very good price, so that’s not the end of the world…
Am I the only one at risk of changing cars and getting something worse?
Others flit between cars like one-night stands, potentially ditching those that could be worthy of a much longer relationship.
I’ve been driving for 16 years and have had 8 cars - plus 3 second cars over the last 9 months. I’m very much in the itchy feet camp now, regularly debating whether to sell one or both of my current cars, despite them doing everything I need.
Both have pretty much all the kit I want, plus appealing engines and are in good condition. The only thing I actively object to is that the second one costs £600 to tax, which feels wasteful and I’d prefer sports seats. However, the car was a very good price, so that’s not the end of the world…
Am I the only one at risk of changing cars and getting something worse?
Traded out of a Seven series into a Range Rover Sport Tdv8. The ride was bone shaking, the economy was shocking and the interior was crap. The 7 series I’d sold for 2k was a much better car than the 25k rangie.
The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
mr_tony said:
Traded out of a Seven series into a Range Rover Sport Tdv8. The ride was bone shaking, the economy was shocking and the interior was crap. The 7 series I’d sold for 2k was a much better car than the 25k rangie.
The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
Ouch! A bone shaking ride in a Range Rover…was it on gargantuan alloys?The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
I needed this thread lmao. In the process of wanting to sell my 340i which is perfect for power and mpg and because I don’t hood my cars in pursuit of a w204 c63. My car so far has been reliable and perfect but can’t help to scratch that v8 itch after previously owning a XFR.
Thank I’ll have to use my head and not get the merc
Thank I’ll have to use my head and not get the merc
Slippybackside said:
I needed this thread lmao. In the process of wanting to sell my 340i which is perfect for power and mpg and because I don’t hood my cars in pursuit of a w204 c63. My car so far has been reliable and perfect but can’t help to scratch that v8 itch after previously owning a XFR.
Thank I’ll have to use my head and not get the merc
I’ve toyed with swapping my A6 Avant for a Merc W211 E500 for maximum comfort and every time I read the PH E500 threads I realise how bad an idea it is to even think about buying an old Mercedes. Don’t do it!Thank I’ll have to use my head and not get the merc
I don’t know how Mercedes is still seen as a premium brand when so many of its cars are so rusty and unreliable…
Yep. Guilty as charged.
Bought the wife a BMW 330i Touring with all of the option boxes ticked. Brilliant car. Loved it. She liked it too. Sold it because it was 'a bit big'. Replaced it with a Mini, yeah, I know.... instant regret. That BMW was perfect and should have kept it for years. Would have been perfect for our needs and wouldnt have wasted money chasing something to replace it.
Bought the wife a BMW 330i Touring with all of the option boxes ticked. Brilliant car. Loved it. She liked it too. Sold it because it was 'a bit big'. Replaced it with a Mini, yeah, I know.... instant regret. That BMW was perfect and should have kept it for years. Would have been perfect for our needs and wouldnt have wasted money chasing something to replace it.
I've probably changed my cars on average every 6-8 months in the 20 years I've been driving, there's lots to experience.
The best two without hesitation were a Legacy GTB bought for £600, that would be worth atleast £5k today and a £1200 Volvo V70 D5.
A combination of the two would be my perfect car I think, must try a Volvo V70R manual at some point, probably won't do 50mpg like the D5 though.
I didn't give the Legacy away it was written off and the Volvo had done 300k by the time I sold it.
The best two without hesitation were a Legacy GTB bought for £600, that would be worth atleast £5k today and a £1200 Volvo V70 D5.
A combination of the two would be my perfect car I think, must try a Volvo V70R manual at some point, probably won't do 50mpg like the D5 though.
I didn't give the Legacy away it was written off and the Volvo had done 300k by the time I sold it.
I don't really have a perfect car, and probably never have, but I did have one that was a great all rounder, and with a cheap sellable mod, was hilarious fun to drive, and that was my old FN2 Type R. Even though I've had lots of 'better' cars (including a DC2 ITR), this one was such a great all rounder I thought. Still looks modern today, and the cheap mod I made was a Hondata map which really woke up the engine, which sounded awesome with this on it, and you got a lot more of that lovely VTEC to enjoy. Fautlessly reliable and ludicrously cheap to buy. The cabin was even a fairly nice place to be. I think they are pretty underrated. I still think about it to this day.
ChocolateFrog said:
I've probably changed my cars on average every 6-8 months in the 20 years I've been driving, there's lots to experience.
The best two without hesitation were a Legacy GTB bought for £600, that would be worth atleast £5k today and a £1200 Volvo V70 D5.
A combination of the two would be my perfect car I think, must try a Volvo V70R manual at some point, probably won't do 50mpg like the D5 though.
As an ex-Legacy 3.0R Spec B, V70 2.5T and S60 T5 owner, I very much get the appeal of the V70R.The best two without hesitation were a Legacy GTB bought for £600, that would be worth atleast £5k today and a £1200 Volvo V70 D5.
A combination of the two would be my perfect car I think, must try a Volvo V70R manual at some point, probably won't do 50mpg like the D5 though.
I was admiring this yesterday. LOVE the tan interior:
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/255384189507?hash=item3...
And then I looked at the MOT history and how it’s peppered with endless advisories over the years and failed three times in a row for the same thing. And then I remember the atrocious turning turning circle. And the annoying V70 electrical issues and none-too-reliable all-wheel-drive system and the lack of performance for the running costs etc. etc.
I think Volvo seats and speakers in the Legacy 3.0R Spec B is my ultimate Volvbaru.
RoVoFob said:
mr_tony said:
Traded out of a Seven series into a Range Rover Sport Tdv8. The ride was bone shaking, the economy was shocking and the interior was crap. The 7 series I’d sold for 2k was a much better car than the 25k rangie.
The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
Ouch! A bone shaking ride in a Range Rover…was it on gargantuan alloys?The seven was pretty shagged though, and at 120k miles was definitely into ‘probably throwing a massive bill’ at any moment. The lad I sold it to set off on a 6k mile European tour in it. Wonder how he got on…
mr_tony said:
No - think they were 19” the original first generation RR Sport. Which had neither the sportiness promised and none of the comfort of a Range Rover. In retrospect it was utterly pointless - we just fell for the ‘need a bigger car cos we had a child’ marketing rubbish…..
Hmm. That’s no good. Think that generation of RR Sport weighed as much as the Disco 3 somehow, so no doubt the weight scuppered everything.Well, I get the child=bigger car marketing pull, as I bought my A6 because of an impending child. I had to get a 4.2, though, as pushchairs and car seats are heavy.

RoVoFob said:
mr_tony said:
No - think they were 19” the original first generation RR Sport. Which had neither the sportiness promised and none of the comfort of a Range Rover. In retrospect it was utterly pointless - we just fell for the ‘need a bigger car cos we had a child’ marketing rubbish…..
Hmm. That’s no good. Think that generation of RR Sport weighed as much as the Disco 3 somehow, so no doubt the weight scuppered everything.Well, I get the child=bigger car marketing pull, as I bought my A6 because of an impending child. I had to get a 4.2, though, as pushchairs and car seats are heavy.

mr_tony said:
It can play to the advantage too. I managed to arrive at the incontrovertible decision that a 2 door v12 twin turbocharged 4wd hatchback from Italy was a ‘sensible’ family car choice shortly after we had the second child…. That’s another one I should have kept - it was actually brilliant.. the ‘sensible’ 4 door v8 I replaced that with as an ‘economy’ option cost me the same or more in running costs and depreciation while being a lot less comfortable and fun and nice to be in. Sometimes you don’t know what you’ve got until it’s gone….
I didn’t know such thing as a V12 twin-turbocharged 4WD hatchback existed. I fear I’m not as ready for parenthood as I need to be. Tell me more…I may have to sell the house to fund it, but children deserve the best.I like the idea of a 6.0-litre 552hp Bentley Continental Flying Spur as a family car. What better first vehicle in which to travel in 2022 than a W12 saloon that can do 195mph? This one is the same age and mileage as my A6 and less than £10,000 more: https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202202122...
Now where’s my man calculator?
I’m quite careful when I buy, so aim to get it right and keep cars for the long term.
Longest I’ve owned a car is my current toy - 987S. It’s fast approaching 17, and I’ve had it for more than half its life. I thought about a 981, but after a test drive stayed with the 987.
Daily cars vary - I only change due to ‘need’ - kept my previous daily from new (pre-reg) for 8 years, only sold due to pandemic meaning I was barely using it. I’ve just replaced it, and I’ll probably keep the replacement at least 5 years if not more. It’s comfy, quiet, reasonably quick, and I see no point in swapping it for the sake of it. Mandatory speed limiters mean I may keep it a lot longer than expected!
Longest I’ve owned a car is my current toy - 987S. It’s fast approaching 17, and I’ve had it for more than half its life. I thought about a 981, but after a test drive stayed with the 987.
Daily cars vary - I only change due to ‘need’ - kept my previous daily from new (pre-reg) for 8 years, only sold due to pandemic meaning I was barely using it. I’ve just replaced it, and I’ll probably keep the replacement at least 5 years if not more. It’s comfy, quiet, reasonably quick, and I see no point in swapping it for the sake of it. Mandatory speed limiters mean I may keep it a lot longer than expected!
This gets worse if you’re trying to make a “collection” - what fits together? What represents your passion? What looks after your money? What ages, colours, engine types, genres?
And in my limited experience with a very modest garage of cars compared to some you ALWAYS need one more space than you have, one more lot of money more than you have.
Finally, when you assemble what looked great on paper sometimes it just doesn’t fit anymore and you have to sell things. It’s really, really hard.
And in my limited experience with a very modest garage of cars compared to some you ALWAYS need one more space than you have, one more lot of money more than you have.
Finally, when you assemble what looked great on paper sometimes it just doesn’t fit anymore and you have to sell things. It’s really, really hard.
mr_tony said:
No - think they were 19” the original first generation RR Sport. Which had neither the sportiness promised and none of the comfort of a Range Rover. In retrospect it was utterly pointless - we just fell for the ‘need a bigger car cos we had a child’ marketing rubbish…..
Coz a 7 series wouldn't be big enough for a family of 3?I chipped away at a family car until finding something suitable. It was partially realising the limitations of what I had.
E30 325i Sport, too small
E63 645Ci, too small for rear occupants
2001 V70 2.4T, lovely, smelly, undertaken by a 530d despite my best to close the gap to the car ahead... wasn't having that so a
S211 E500 which is needy and awesome
The issue with this generation of Mercs isn't quality, it's deferred maintenance.
E30 325i Sport, too small
E63 645Ci, too small for rear occupants
2001 V70 2.4T, lovely, smelly, undertaken by a 530d despite my best to close the gap to the car ahead... wasn't having that so a
S211 E500 which is needy and awesome

The issue with this generation of Mercs isn't quality, it's deferred maintenance.
Bobupndown said:
mr_tony said:
No - think they were 19” the original first generation RR Sport. Which had neither the sportiness promised and none of the comfort of a Range Rover. In retrospect it was utterly pointless - we just fell for the ‘need a bigger car cos we had a child’ marketing rubbish…..
Coz a 7 series wouldn't be big enough for a family of 3?I've had my license for 27 years and had 22 cars and 10 bikes. I usually discover how much I've liked something about a month after selling it and moving on.
I habitually look at cars for sale when I'm bored and don't generally get attached to them. Bikes are different for some reason, I've had my main bike for 7 years now and still have my first bike after 20+ years.
I habitually look at cars for sale when I'm bored and don't generally get attached to them. Bikes are different for some reason, I've had my main bike for 7 years now and still have my first bike after 20+ years.
Gassing Station | General Gassing | Top of Page | What's New | My Stuff


