Car not eligible to tow
Car not eligible to tow
Author
Discussion

NordicCrankShaft

Original Poster:

1,957 posts

146 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
Didn't realise this was a thing, just assumed all cars were allowed to tow.

I have a 2010 W219 Mercedes CLS, I have roof bars to carry bikes on the roof but have bought a new bike which is heavier than the recommended weight for said roof bars and also after a long ride I question whether I'd be capable of lifting 24kg above my head.
So, my plan was to get a detachable tow bar and fit a towbar mounted bike rack, I've done some calling around and it seems that nobody will fit a towbar to the car because its not one that's exempt from being allowed.
Don't really want to get rid of it and the seats don't fold down, so it looks like I'm going to have to use the roof bars and ratchet strap it for peace of mind.

swisstoni

24,251 posts

310 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
Nope. It’s flipping complicated when you dig in to it, but your average car can’t tow much at all.

If you were thinking of towing a car trailer for instance, the trailer would account for most of the capacity, leaving enough free for a very light car only.

Caravans are pretty light so a largish car is ok.

Proper towing needs a Range Rover class vehicle or a van.

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
I have heard of towbars being fitted to non type approved cars if the owner signs a declaration that they will not be using it to tow, only using it for bike racks etc.

eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Proper towing needs a Range Rover class vehicle or a van.
A 24kg bike is hardly ‘proper towing’ in fact it’s not towing at-all in the o/p’s case

swisstoni

24,251 posts

310 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
eliot said:
swisstoni said:
Proper towing needs a Range Rover class vehicle or a van.
A 24kg bike is hardly ‘proper towing’ in fact it’s not towing at-all in the o/p’s case
Yes, I did go into one a bit there, without properly reading the op’s particular issue.

SkodaIan

1,031 posts

116 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
It's becoming quite annoying that car manufacturers aren't bothering to homologate cars for towing which they think nobody will want a towbar on. Any car is capable of safely towing a light trailer (of the kind used to carry bikes, luggage, or garden waste to the tip) but they see it as a way to save a few pounds on the development cost.

Were you asking for a "Towbar" or a "towbar mounted cycle carrier mounting point"?

The lack of towing ability is a common problem for electric cars, but the hair shirt electric car types are also quite keen on cycling so want to be able to move bikes about. The problem has been solved by making a towbar which isn't a towbar. They have a couple of tabs on the side which means a bike carrier still fits but a trailer hitch won't (so it isn't a towbar from the legal perspective). As long as you don't exceed the loading weight of the vehicle, they are completely legal to use on any car.

Something like this might be available...

https://www.pfjones.co.uk/renault-zoe-hatchback-20...

Out of interest, why is the new bike so heavy? That's heavier than my old 1970s Raleigh commuter bike with a steel frame!!


HustleRussell

26,714 posts

191 months

Friday 18th February 2022
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Nope. It’s flipping complicated when you dig in to it, but your average car can’t tow much at all.

If you were thinking of towing a car trailer for instance, the trailer would account for most of the capacity, leaving enough free for a very light car only.

Caravans are pretty light so a largish car is ok.

Proper towing needs a Range Rover class vehicle or a van.
A Fiesta can tow more than a ton. Your ‘average’ car can probably tow more like 1,300 - 1,400kg.

Twin axle car trailers can weigh as little as 350kg.

Caravans are generally less stable to tow than a car trailer of the same weight due to the high sides / weight distribution / CoG.

What qualifies as ‘proper towing’?

Edited by HustleRussell on Saturday 19th February 00:03

NordicCrankShaft

Original Poster:

1,957 posts

146 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
SkodaIan said:
It's becoming quite annoying that car manufacturers aren't bothering to homologate cars for towing which they think nobody will want a towbar on. Any car is capable of safely towing a light trailer (of the kind used to carry bikes, luggage, or garden waste to the tip) but they see it as a way to save a few pounds on the development cost.

Were you asking for a "Towbar" or a "towbar mounted cycle carrier mounting point"?

The lack of towing ability is a common problem for electric cars, but the hair shirt electric car types are also quite keen on cycling so want to be able to move bikes about. The problem has been solved by making a towbar which isn't a towbar. They have a couple of tabs on the side which means a bike carrier still fits but a trailer hitch won't (so it isn't a towbar from the legal perspective). As long as you don't exceed the loading weight of the vehicle, they are completely legal to use on any car.

Something like this might be available...

https://www.pfjones.co.uk/renault-zoe-hatchback-20...

Out of interest, why is the new bike so heavy? That's heavier than my old 1970s Raleigh commuter bike with a steel frame!!
This is perfect, I'll do some more ringing around tomorrow and explain it this was rather Ryan just asking for a tow bar and then explaining its to mount a bike rack.

The new bike is an electric Mountain bike hence why it's around 10kg heavier and bulkier than my previous bike that would just fit on the roof.

aka_kerrly

12,506 posts

241 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
Have you considered a boot mounted rack?

http://www.carbicyclerack.co.uk/mercedes-bike-rack...

The 3 bike model should have no trouble supporting 24kg.

QBee

22,550 posts

175 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
Would detaching the battery and sticking it inside the car solve the weight on the roof issue?

eliot

12,000 posts

285 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
QBee said:
Would detaching the battery and sticking it inside the car solve the weight on the roof issue?
That thought occurred to me also, along with removing a wheel

delays

792 posts

246 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
There's also a cost-saving aspect to not certifying a car for towing (or, indeed, not rating it for a weight big enough for a trailer). Take the Mercedes GLE - base car can tow 2,700kg, adding the Towing Pack brings a tow bar and raises the capacity to 3,500kg.

It allows OEMs to fit a smaller cooling pack etc to the base vehicles (ie the majority) and only offer the serious stuff to the customers that "opt in". Where that leaves the aftermarket, is anybody's guess.

Rozzers

3,077 posts

106 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
I wonder if the loom kit is compatible with the E class, then you could fit a generic/ custom tow bar kit yourself on the understanding it’s only for the bike, as it will be more secure than any strapped on malarkey.

Obviously remove before selling in case someone tries to tow a double axle mobile speed restriction.

leyorkie

1,824 posts

207 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
aka_kerrly said:
Have you considered a boot mounted rack?

http://www.carbicyclerack.co.uk/mercedes-bike-rack...

The 3 bike model should have no trouble supporting 24kg.
That’s a rebranded Saris Bones rack available for much less money

E bike battery weighs around 3 kg wheel around 2.5 kg but that’s still some weight to lift shoulder high

PDP76

2,583 posts

181 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
More importantly ! What the hell are you riding now that’s 24kg ?
E mtb ?

Edit : see you’ve already answered it and I was correct lol


Gafferjim

1,337 posts

296 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
Contact Watlings, if they've not got what you want already, they'll make it for you. https://www.watling-towbars.co.uk/towbars.html

SignalGruen

632 posts

231 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
Zulu 10 said:
I went through this saga when I owned a CLS W219.

OP, you're correct to say that Mercedes did not get the W219 type approved for towing, simply because as a policy they didn't want the look spoiled by seeing it used as a tow car.

Just because the manufacturer didn't go for type approval, does not mean that no one else can subsequently do so.

As I'm sure you're aware, the W219 is based on the W211 E Class, so an enterprising and very large German tow bar company took the design data set for the E Class and persuaded the German TuV that the W219 was indeed capable of towing, and got their tow bar type approved.

I was nervous about all this and so contacted VOSA who confirmed that the German type approval paperwork was valid in the UK.

Consequently I bought and fitted a Rameder tow bar to my CLS entirely legitimately.

If you want chapter and verse then I can endeavour to find the original correspondence.

The Ramader bar is here: https://www.kupplung.de/gdw-anhaengerkupplung-komp... but be warned that it's not cheap.

Finally, OP: I've just noticed that you're in Norway, so you may need to check with your national authority that they would recognise the German paperwork.

Edited by Zulu 10 on Saturday 19th February 08:24
Does your VIN plate have a gross weight ? I have a Japanese imported W211 Estate, I can get a towbar for it but the VIN doesn't contain the gross weight so I assume I'd be on dodgy ground from an insurance point of view if I decided to get a towbar fitted.

QBee

22,550 posts

175 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
I would be interested to know what one would tow with a Merc GLE that weighs more than 2700 kg but under 3500kg (excluding mini-excavators etc).
I used to tow my horse trailer with two horses on board with a Merc ML. It weighed 2400 kg including tack.
Towed very nicely with the Merc ML's 2.7 diesel engine, yet towing with a 4 litre petrol Ford Explorer (weight limit 2500 kg) it was hard work.
I know you can get a 3 horse trailer, so that would be one thing if you had 3 horses on board (average medium sized horse is around 500 kg).
A boat is the only other thing I can think of, but then you get size issues I imagine.

LouD86

3,290 posts

184 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
QBee said:
I would be interested to know what one would tow with a Merc GLE that weighs more than 2700 kg but under 3500kg (excluding mini-excavators etc).
I used to tow my horse trailer with two horses on board with a Merc ML. It weighed 2400 kg including tack.
Towed very nicely with the Merc ML's 2.7 diesel engine, yet towing with a 4 litre petrol Ford Explorer (weight limit 2500 kg) it was hard work.
I know you can get a 3 horse trailer, so that would be one thing if you had 3 horses on board (average medium sized horse is around 500 kg).
A boat is the only other thing I can think of, but then you get size issues I imagine.
I quite regularly move my offroad landrovers by trailer. 2.2t Truck, 1100kgs trailer, so need at least 3.3t assuming I haven't filled the 110ltr fuel tank. I use an ML350, and L322 Range Rover purely for the 3.5t capacity and air suspension.

Dog Star

17,650 posts

199 months

Saturday 19th February 2022
quotequote all
NordicCrankShaft said:
Didn't realise this was a thing, just assumed all cars were allowed to tow.

I have a 2010 W219 Mercedes CLS, I have roof bars to carry bikes on the roof but have bought a new bike which is heavier than the recommended weight for said roof bars and also after a long ride I question whether I'd be capable of lifting 24kg above my head.
So, my plan was to get a detachable tow bar and fit a towbar mounted bike rack, I've done some calling around and it seems that nobody will fit a towbar to the car because its not one that's exempt from being allowed.
Don't really want to get rid of it and the seats don't fold down, so it looks like I'm going to have to use the roof bars and ratchet strap it for peace of mind.
OP you CAN get these and probably for your car.

They are detachable towbars but they’re actually for cycle racks - there is a “knob” on the 50mm ball to prevent you using it with a trailer, but these are compatible with Thule bike racks for example.

There’s a company called AHK Preisbrecher in Apens (near Bremen) and they will fit them - note that they won’t supply, only fit. I’m taking my SL to them next month for this exact same thing. Got my ferry and hotel booked. Obviously with an SL there tree s no roof option.

Edit: yes they do!

https://www.ahk-preisbrecher.de/Anhaengerkupplung-...

They aren’t cheap - for my SL including fitting an electrics it’s €1200 but I have no choice. However it’s all proper TüV approved etc. we are just making a mini-holiday of us. They’re lending us a car so we can go off and do something during the day. What with holidays everywhere it actually will be very much worth the money as we will make far more use of the car.

PM me if you need more info.




Edited by Dog Star on Saturday 19th February 14:37