Locking wheel nut removal
Locking wheel nut removal
Author
Discussion

freeman3030

Original Poster:

37 posts

158 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Hi,

I've got a VW Passat and I don't have the locking wheel nut. I rung KwikFit for a price and they charge £100 for removal + replacement and F1 Auto centres charge £110 removal + replacement.

I found a place online that has a 100% success rate even removal of previous failed attempts but they're 90 miles away.

I phoned a couple of local places for prices and one guy asked for a photo. He phoned me back and said the only people that can remove them would be the AA or RAC. Is this true? I didn't quite believe him, so I rung another company and the same guy answered the phone and said - I've just spoken to you and told you not to waste your time. I'm not sure why he has multiple numbers/businesses doing the same thing!

Everywhere I have phone has said "we SHOULD be able to get them off" rather than, no problem, let get you booked in which might well backup the last gentleman's story of only AA/RAC... not sure what tools/skills only they have that no-one else has.

If anyone can help/advise I'd appreciate it (based near Brighton).

DickyC

58,958 posts

229 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
My local tyre place takes them off for £10 and when you see it done you think it's a rip off.

But it gets the job done.

s p a c e m a n

12,169 posts

179 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
https://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/VAG-SKODA-VW-AUDI-SEAT-...

Bought from here for our discovery, worked fine.

I see there is also a master key listed on eBay but don't know if it's for your style. It's pointless taking one nut off, and you'll need to buy new ones to replace, getting a new key is normally the best option.

cuprabob

19,958 posts

245 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
If you're not in a hurry you could try getting a replacement adaptor key from these guys.

https://www.lockingwheelnutkeys.co.uk/

Also, when you do get them off, just replace with standard OEM wheel bolts.

.

Colonel D

631 posts

103 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
It can be a nightmare to get them off depending on how tight/seized they are, clearance between nut and bolt hole. The tool I've seen commonly is a socket with teeth going anti clockwise, and can chew up the lock nut if it goes wrong. Worth checking local VW dealers, if genuine VW lock nuts they might have a set of sockets for each key VW use, and can order one for you. It was a regular thing with sales cars in BMW.

MG CHRIS

9,322 posts

198 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
They may take 5 mins to remove or 2 hrs some can be a right pain specially if they have been done up with a gun.

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Agree with the posters above. If it's a case of you just don't have the key (and it's not an emergency situation), they are available on eBay etc for <£10.

What kind of locking nut are you talking about? Some much harder to remove than others?

The McGard locking nuts with moving collar are a bit of a bugger to remove...trust me. A lot of places don't like to mess about with them.

Had an issue with this one:


Should look like this:


These guys: https://www.lockingwheelnutremovers.co.uk/ removed mine in <10 mins (no drilling or damage to the wheel etc). £45 iirc.

Edited by g3org3y on Sunday 20th February 12:41

biggles330d

2,703 posts

181 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
I found the key broken twice on one of my cars, seems to be made of the softest monkey metal which when broken makes them useless. First one I hammered on a socket and forced the nut off. Totally wrecks the nut but useless with a broken key anyway. Replaced that at great expense for a new set of locking nuts only for the next Quickfit outfit to break another key air-wrenching the nuts after a tyre change. Lesson learned, another socket forced it off and replaced at much leesss expense with normal wheel nuts. Locking nuts, more hassle than they are worth!

pigeyman

1,188 posts

132 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Brass nut removers are what you're looking for. However if like me you're broke, impatient and yet still somehow careful then a double hex socket, 1/2" drive extension, mallet and breaker bar can sometimes be enough.

Thermobaric

725 posts

151 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Another vote for bashing on an oversized socket. Does the job.

MG CHRIS

9,322 posts

198 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Thermobaric said:
Another vote for bashing on an oversized socket. Does the job.
Not if it's got a collar around the outside it will just spin the the collar then stuck with a socket wedged on your locking wheel nut.

brillomaster

1,914 posts

201 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Definitely another vote for binning all locking wheelnuts. Way more hassle than they are worth.

For starters, alloy wheel theft is gonna be way down from where it was before- if your car is older than about 5 years, it wouldnt be targetted by crims anyway.

And secondly, if a crim is after your wheels, no locking nut would stop them anyway.

paintman

7,861 posts

221 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
On the basis that the quotes you had were for removal AND replacement which suggests they're going to sell you another set what would they quote just for removal?

Although I fully expect they will then refuse to do it & tell you that if you don't buy the new ones from them the sky will fall down & the world will end.

pits

6,704 posts

221 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
If VW are like BMW, just pop into your dealer and say you need a new locking wheel nut key, they can then get their box out and you can check which one it is, order one for £10 or so.

DickyC

58,958 posts

229 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
pits said:
If VW are like BMW, just pop into your dealer and say you need a new locking wheel nut key, they can then get their box out and you can check which one it is, order one for £10 or so.
This sounds like the correct answer. And I wish I'd thought of it.

Thermobaric

725 posts

151 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
MG CHRIS said:
Not if it's got a collar around the outside it will just spin the the collar then stuck with a socket wedged on your locking wheel nut.
I think that goes without saying. How common are those anyway?

Sheepshanks

41,395 posts

150 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
pits said:
If VW are like BMW, just pop into your dealer and say you need a new locking wheel nut key, they can then get their box out and you can check which one it is, order one for £10 or so.
A few yrs ago I tried two dealers for a spare for wife's now 6yr old Tiguan and both said VW doesn't sell spares - one suggested the company that made them had gone bust and offered to remove the exisiting wheel nuts and supply a new set for £70.

However they look exactly the same style as on daughter's Honda - she mislaid her key (put it in a bag she rarely uses after buying new tyres) and the dealer supplied a new key for a remarkably low £8 (yet wanted £50 for a set of wiper blades I thought I'd buy while there!).

The Tiguan keys (so I assume all other similar age VWs) are on eBay all the time for £15 ish. I know her's is 521A - I think there's only something like 15 different patterns.

Pat H

8,058 posts

287 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Find a rough looking local tyre fitters. The sort that sells part worn tyres.

They will have a big tub full of locking wheel nut keys.

For the price of a pint they will find one that fits and will remove your locking nuts.

Just replace them with ordinary wheel bolts/nuts.

Pretty much the first job I do when I buy a car is to remove the locking nuts and throw them away.


Glosphil

4,908 posts

265 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
I changed the locking wheel bolts for standard bolts on my last 4 cars - 2 Hondas, a Skoda & the current Seat.
Tyre fitters insist on tightening them with an air gun that causes the socket to slip & rounds off the 'key'.
The Hondas had chrome headed bolts.
The VAG cars use plastic covers on the bolt head. I dumped the bolts & covers from the Skoda & fitted decent bolts - same fitted the Seat.


Edited by Glosphil on Sunday 20th February 19:51

g3org3y

22,529 posts

222 months

Sunday 20th February 2022
quotequote all
Thermobaric said:
MG CHRIS said:
Not if it's got a collar around the outside it will just spin the the collar then stuck with a socket wedged on your locking wheel nut.
I think that goes without saying. How common are those anyway?
BMW factory fit items were of that type at one point in time.

Doing a google search for VW locking nut key suggests similar. frown



Keys very available from eBay, no need to mess about with dealers imo.


Pat H said:
Find a rough looking local tyre fitters. The sort that sells part worn tyres.

They will have a big tub full of locking wheel nut keys.

For the price of a pint they will find one that fits and will remove your locking nuts
Of the 'spline' type, I agree.


You can usually hammer in a 'close enough' fit and get away with it.

The McGuard spinning collar type are a whole other level of misery.

Pat H said:
Just replace them with ordinary wheel bolts/nuts.
yes