RE: Porsche Panamera Turbo | The Brave Pill
RE: Porsche Panamera Turbo | The Brave Pill
Saturday 26th February 2022

Porsche Panamera Turbo | The Brave Pill

Nearly 200mph for not quite £24K makes for a performance bargain



Demographers study changing human populations to try and work out approaching trends. At PH we try to do the same thing with cars, although calling the future of the used market is always an inexact science. But here's an indisputable fact, highlighted by this week's Pill: 500hp has never been cheaper, in both relative and absolute terms. The rise in power outputs in the 2000s and 2010s has crossed with the inevitable effect of savage depreciation.

While several examples of this genre have featured in Brave Pill before, this week marks the first appearance of the Porsche Panamera, here in range-topping Turbo format. Our Pill would have carried a £95,300 pre-options list price when it was new in 2009, with options moving that into six figures. Now, wearing an unscary 83,000 miles, it is being offered for just £23,990 - this for a car with a 4.2-sec 0-62mph time and a 190mph top speed. We are living in the gooiest part of the sweet spot.

No car company has ever been defined by a single model to a greater extent than Porsche. Even when we're not talking about a 911, the iconic ass-engined sports car inevitably gets hauled into any other discussion about Porsche's products, from those models intended to replace it, but also the ones made to supplement it like the Panamera.


The Cayenne was, pretty obviously, an attempt to splice the DNA of a 911 with an SUV. The Panamera is the attempted synthesis between a 911 and an executive saloon. Porsche had been threatening to do something similar for many years - the 1988 989 prototype was almost exactly the same idea two decades earlier. But the production Panamera that made its debut at the 2009 Shanghai motor show showed its influences as clearly as The Bootleg Beatles, with 911-style headlights, sloped roofline and interior architecture.

In traditional Porsche fashion, there were plenty of Panameras to choose from. Basic versions got the same Volkswagen-sourced 3.6-litre V6 which also did duty in the boggo Cayenne, and which was available with both rear-wheel drive and all-wheel drive. Further up the tree came a choice of two 4.8-litre V8s, with the Panamera S and 4S getting a naturally aspirated one that made 395hp and the Turbo's getting boosted to 493hp. An even brawnier 542hp Turbo S followed in 2011, launched at the same time as a diesel V6 and a plug-in hybrid.

The big mechanical difference over the Cayenne was the the Panamera's use of a seven-speed double-clutch gearbox rather than a conventional auto for the V6, S and Turbo. Porsche also offered the V6 and naturally aspirated V8 with the option of a six-speed manual gearbox, although this was picked as rarely as a statue's nose: total sales across both powertrains was reported under 150 cars globally. Beyond some low-speed hesitancy the DSG was a great transmission, deftly snapping its way between ratios with speed and smoothness.


The same two words can be used to sum-up the rest of the dynamic experience, the Panamera being effective but aloof. It was a supreme get somewhere fast machine, especially in Turbo form - as relaxed and comfortable as a private jet when asked to deliver serious cruising speed. But it also lacked the level of engagement that normally comes as standard in Porsche's sports cars.

I remember driving an early Turbo on a comparison test which pitted it against both a BMW M6 GranCoupe and a Mercedes CLS 63AMG. The all-wheel driven Panamera was much quicker over greasy Welsh roads, getting power down cleanly as the rear-driven pairing scrabbled for traction. But the Panamera finished last to its more charismatic rivals.

The Panamera's 911-esque cabin also felt a bit try-hard, especially the twin rows of buttons on either side of the centre console. These were fiddly to see and - all being the same shape and size - almost impossible to navigate by touch. On the plus side, it was reasonably spacious for rear-seat passengers and there was something close to family-sized luggage space behind the hatchback.


Porsche always intended the Panamera to exert strongest appeal in non-European markets, and this it definitely did, selling most strongly in the US and China. It managed respectable rather than spectacular numbers in the UK, the first generation never getting over 1,000 cars a year - less than half the volumes the guiltier pleasure that was the Cayenne managed throughout the same period. Many Panamera owners clearly loved them, Porsche saying it has one of the highest repeat business rates of any model it produces.

Our Pill comes from the first year of production and is the cheapest Turbo currently in the classifieds. The dealer has listed every single feature of function within the advert text, but an edited precis reveals the presence of what would have been a a full set of pricey dynamic options: carbon-ceramic brakes, these featuring the distinctive natty yellow calipers, plus the roll-fighting PDCC system and the dash-top watchface showing the presence of the Sport Chrono pack. Under respectful use the carbon discs can last almost indefinitely, despite the Turbo's chunky 1,800kg kerbweight, although sustained thermal loads can dramatically accelerate wear.

The earlier PDCC system was hydraulic, and as a Turbo our Pill also has air suspension as standard, plus PASM active dampers. All complicated bits of tech capable of throwing up £££ bills. But, presuming all are working as intended, their presence means this Panamera should offer the sharpest possible driving experience for an early 970 generation car. More curious is the presence of an 'S' badge on the tailgate as the Turbo S wasn't introduced until 2011, and its not as if - as a well-equipped regular Turbo - it is exactly lacking in either urge of performance kudos.


The advert makes no mention of the sort of inches-thick service history that provides reassurance in this part of the market, and the advert says the car has had seven former keepers. But even with those provisos the MOT history is impressively clean and green, containing just one minor blemish - a fail last year for worn rear tyres. Other than that there isn't even an advisory, which suggests an impressive degree of care and attention for something so large, fast and heavy.

First-generation Panamera values are still sliding and, if they follow the trajectory of the Cayenne, there will likely be the chance to write about the sub-£15K and maybe even the sub-£10K Turbo in the fullness of time. Yet this example still looks like a huge amount of both car and performance for the money. It's not the most exciting Turbo-badged Porsche, but it may well be the most sensible. Sensible can be sexy, right?


See the full ad here



Author
Discussion

Lotusgav

Original Poster:

170 posts

190 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I keep looking at these as a sensible family car. Hatchback for dogs and all that. But you ah r to have the tow kit in from factory, they can’t be retrofitted apparently- need that for bikes. Relatively cheap compared to a 911 here in Aus. The turbo, new is 400k AUD 😬

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.

GT03ROB

14,037 posts

252 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Gloriously daft cars in the higher powered versions..... great things though. Pretty reliable too.

Dombilano

1,482 posts

86 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.
Refurbished turbos every other year? Really? And as long as the carbon ceramic rotors haven't been trashed they'll outlive the next owners ownership

To my eyes, this is a bargain and brave with a small b

kippaxking

185 posts

251 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I’d like to know which of the seven previous owners added the ‘S’ badge! That’s a red flag.

The ‘P’ looks a bit wonky as well. Definitely time for a debadge or maybe a smattering of BMW ‘M’ badges…?

andyvvc

267 posts

174 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Just had the turbos replaced on my 911. At 20 years old (and located under the rear of the car collecting all manner of dirt and debris) the casings had finally begun to split and fail.

I suspect the freqency of replacement for turbos on the Pan ought to be even less frequent smile

Roger Irrelevant

3,401 posts

144 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I was half-seriously looking at these as a half bonkers, half practical family car for when my house renovation has ceased to be such an all-consuming money pit and I deserve a bit of a treat. If anything I'll be looking at them three-quarters seriously now; nothing in the article puts me off as I was already well aware that running costs would be substantial. To get anything vaguely comparable with a manufacturer warranty still on it you'd need to fork out tens of thousands more to begin with so four-figure bills need to be seen in the round. I think they've aged very well too. Maybe one day...

Mogul

3,066 posts

254 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
It’s almost MT58 ANX

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Dombilano said:
Chubbyross said:
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.
Refurbished turbos every other year? Really? And as long as the carbon ceramic rotors haven't been trashed they'll outlive the next owners ownership

To my eyes, this is a bargain and brave with a small b
I wasn’t suggesting turbos would need replacing every other year. I was just suggesting that every year or so these cars can and will throw up large bills. I run a similar age 911 Turbo and a major service last year cost me £5k, two years before that I had a bill for £4k. You get used to it on these cars. They’re in no way cheap to run.

randlemarcus

13,646 posts

262 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
They are things to go into with eyes wide open, agreed. First service on mine (major, naturally) includes discs and pads all round, and one new caliper. That stung.

Glorious place to spend petrol money though, and a proper Jekyll and Hyde experience. Near Bentley luxury really ought not to so things on the B roads that thing could.

JD2329

513 posts

199 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Better off with an M5 IMO, either an E60 or F10.
Similar speed and more involvement for less money.

Tannedbaldhead

3,218 posts

163 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.
You sound like an old uncle of mine.
Many moons ago, long before the prices of use 911s became stratospheric, I had sufficient savings and income to put myself in a fairly decent used 911. My uncle confronted me with more or less the same points you have just made then summed up with "If u can't afford a new one u can't afford to run an old one".
I chickened out of buying my used Porsche and bought a new VW Corrado instead.

GianiCakes

718 posts

104 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I had one of these for 4 years from new. I’ve been fortunate to have owned some good stuff but I think this was my favorite car of all and I miss it more than the 997.1 I had before. As the article mentions, that generation of pdk was a little jerky around town but everything else was superb. Very much an alpha dog feeling on the autobahn and it steered and handled very well helped by the low set seating position. A 5 series feels like an suv after. The comment about the other cars on test having more character surprises me as the Panny was a real drivers car.
It always felt well made and I had no problems during my time with the car, although I can’t vouch for how reliable it would be at this stage. A friend of mine has had some expensive warranty work done on his current generation car though.
I tried the “S” before settling on the turbo and I’d suggest that it is a much faster and better car for a relatively small additional outlay. Mine had black window surrounds and some de-chrome wrap would give this one even more attitude. I didn’t get another one because of the extraordinary amount of depreciation, but no regrets.

XJSJohn

16,152 posts

250 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Had my Panamera 970 for 6 months and 6000 miles now, and all be it an E-Hybrid rather than a turbo, it has all the other options listed. 2015 car on 70’000 miles.

It has been faultless since I have had it, never a squeak or rattle, every button works, full set of Porsche stamps in the log book and no horror stories in its past history either.

It gets to silly speeds very fast and without you even realising it, and we love it as our family / daily driver car.

It’s even averaged 40mpg over those 6000 miles!



Edited by XJSJohn on Saturday 26th February 08:52

The spinner of plates

18,084 posts

231 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
kippaxking said:
I’d like to know which of the seven previous owners added the ‘S’ badge! That’s a red flag.

The ‘P’ looks a bit wonky as well. Definitely time for a debadge or maybe a smattering of BMW ‘M’ badges…?
Agreed on the up-badging.

Minor point, but at least one former owner is an idiot.

Mosdef

1,849 posts

258 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
JD2329 said:
Better off with an M5 IMO, either an E60 or F10.
Similar speed and more involvement for less money.
Depends what you’re after. The M5 is slightly sharper but doesn’t have 4WD (useful for most months of the year if you really want to drive a 500bhp+ car quickly without any unwelcome drama), the ride quality and refinement is abysmal next to the Porsche, the M5 feels pretty cheaply made and it’s roots are ultimately those of a mass produced rep mobile. They’re great cars but a very different proposition.

Dr mojo

217 posts

210 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
F10/E60 M5 is good but the Panamera turbo S I had blew it away in terms of speed/ handling and build quality. No comparison except perhaps the Panny is more visually challenging externally but much better place to sit and drive. I really miss it.

IJB1959

2,141 posts

117 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.
That rear end is horrible, but the latest one is fab. Same goes with the Cayenne.


IJB1959

2,141 posts

117 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Chubbyross said:
Dombilano said:
Chubbyross said:
A very, very brave pill indeed, perhaps bordering on a crazy pill. This was a £100k car to buy new and is still a £100k car to fix. There is no such thing as a cheap Porsche. You’d have to allow for at least £2k per year for maintenance, and that’s just to keep on top of the smaller wear-and-tear items. Every couple of years you could be looking at refurbed turbos, disks and pads, etc. then you’re looking at £4k, or higher, service bills.

It’s no doubt a fabulous car in which to shift the family but if I were having to spend upkeep costs like that I’d want something I’d be happy to look at. Let’s be honest, the Panamera was never a looker.
Refurbished turbos every other year? Really? And as long as the carbon ceramic rotors haven't been trashed they'll outlive the next owners ownership

To my eyes, this is a bargain and brave with a small b
I wasn’t suggesting turbos would need replacing every other year. I was just suggesting that every year or so these cars can and will throw up large bills. I run a similar age 911 Turbo and a major service last year cost me £5k, two years before that I had a bill for £4k. You get used to it on these cars. They’re in no way cheap to run.
Agreed. If you can afford a Porsche then you must be able to afford the running costs that go with it.....most people forget that.

dbowyer

4 posts

172 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Having owned one of these, I have to agree this is a very brave pill with a capital B..... during my ownership the PASM had to be fixed and replaced twice, both times with bills in excess of £10k - only an OPC can work on the adaptive air suspension, there where no specialist at the time that had the equipment to work on them or the will to work on the suspension........ so you are stuck taking it to an OPC and paying over the top costs. Whilst I loved my Panamera ownership, and they are fantastics cars, which I have yet to find/own anything else as good, because of their complexities, (they are majorly complex cars - hence the £100k starting price tag), when something goes wrong, be prepared for a hefty bill indeed - Panamera ownership can not be done on a shoe string. During my second stint of trips (over 6 in total) to the OPC to get the Adaptive air suspension problems resolved, I was informed that the life span is roughly 60k miles... therefore hence the 'B' if this has not yet already had work done, that suspension is a ticking time bomb, that will destroy your wallet........

Edited by dbowyer on Saturday 26th February 13:23