RE: Choice city cars | Six of the Best
RE: Choice city cars | Six of the Best
Saturday 26th February 2022

Choice city cars | Six of the Best

With Matt B leaving London for good, PH pays tribute to the citybound motorist...



BMW i3, 2019, 10k, £25,490

After what seems like an eternity, me and the fledgling family are departing the capital for a greener (cheaper) backdrop. So it's the end of a long-running urban love affair - not least with Landon's endlessly frustrating road network. Hence a rare PH tribute to the concept of the city car, which I'll kick off with BMW's game-changing effort.

The further we get from the i3's introduction, the more remarkable it seems. This is a carbon-tubbed, rear-wheel drive, electric BMW, launched almost a decade ago for less than £30,000. It weighed under 1,200kg (a Honda e weighs another quarter of a tonne more) it had an interior that redefined expectations of EVs, and it drove really nicely - stiff ride notwithstanding. It was one of the first cars I drove as a PH staff member, and really thought I'd seen the future. The exact styling of the future I wasn't sure of, but the way it worked was beyond any doubt.

That the i3 still looks so futuristic must have contributed to its relative lack of commercial success; even now plenty don't want to advertise their eco credentials too loudly, and the world is very different to 2013. Its early reliability issues certainly won't have helped the the model's cause, and it seems unlikely that BMW will attempt anything so bold ever again - see the iX3 for proof of what we're now likely to get. Pity.

Choosing the perfect city-spec i3 isn't easy. Most out there are the more powerful S, which is odd as the lower ride height is even stiffer than standard. This is a regular i3, but a 2019 car, so with the larger 42.2kWh battery and around 160 miles range. Which should be more than enough to run a week's errands. Or make a desperate return to London... MB


Volkswagen Up GTI 3dr, 2019, 31k, £13,780

The Volkswagen Up GTI is a bit of a Marmite car. In my experience, there are those that love it and those that see it as nothing more than an Up with tartan seats. It isn't the best hot hatch in the world, and certainly not a successor to the Mk1 Golf GTI, as Volkswagen alluded to when it was launched. It has the same power and similar dimensions, but that's about it. Yet I am in the former camp when it comes to this little car. I've really enjoyed driving them.

I remember covering the launch. I picked one up in Crickhowell, in the Brecon Beacons, and spent the day ragging it around miles of Welsh mountain roads. And I mean ragging it, because that's what the Up - with its 115hp and a buzzing, three-cylinder TSI motor - encourages you to do, while at no point feeling like the heavy arm of the law is about to punch you in the face. And en route back to London, a wally in a Mk7 Golf GTI tried to humiliate me with his power advantage, which was consummate. Then we arrived at a long radius, two-lane, tightening lefthander onto the A40, and I simply drove around the outside of him. Silly? Yes, but it made me chuckle.

When I arrived back in London the little Up managed to make darting around town a hoot because it's a city car, and therefore small and nimble. As I said, it isn't the best hot hatch, but as city car with some flair and the ability to run rings around prats in Golf GTIs it's great. This one, with 30,000 miles, is even relatively cheap in the currently overinflated used-car market and happens looks great in Tungsten Silver. JH


Citroen 2CV 0.6 Special, 1988, 74k, £7,000

Yes, I've chosen a 2CV this week. I wasn't allowed another MX-5, Monkey bike or an Oyster Card... so see this as an act of rebellion if nothing else. Growing up in London in the 90s I remember the most famous Citroen being a pretty common sight on the roads, especially those with 'deckchair' striped roofs. Fast forward to now though and the 'HowManyLeft' look up doesn't make for great reading. The fact there is only one for sale on PH rather confirms the endangered species status.

Granted, its age now makes it liable for a daily ULEZ charge so in truth is probably a terrible choice for a city car in 2022, at least financially. However if you can stomach the taxation, the 600cc engine would feel right at home in the 20mph citywide limit, safely carrying your basket of eggs over the many speed bumps back from the trendy east London farmers market, with the roof rolled back and drivers window flipped up.

The asking price doesn't seem so bad for a French slice of motoring history and the dealer assures us that a vicar appears in the ownership history (certainly handy to have the Almighty onside). Dare I say a future candidate for electric conversion and ULEZ exemption, perhaps then it would all make perfect sense again; Vive la 2CV! SL


Bentley Continental GT, 2004, 17k, £24,950

Nothing says 'city car' like a two-door, 6.0-litre twin-turbo W12 Bentley GT, pushing out 552hp through all four wheels, right? It's definitely a lot more fun than a dour hatchback. Moreover, based on its status as a 'footballer's car', and with London boasting no less than seven teams in the Premier League, I figure there's at least a tenuous link to our great capital. Bit of a reach? Well, it's also (remarkably) ULEZ compliant, can adequately seat four, and frankly isn't a bad way to wile away the hours spent sitting in traffic.

Of course, where the GT really comes into its own is the time in between, be it an A-road commute home, or perhaps a more fitting jaunt along the French Riviera towards Monaco. You won't want for power (not something you could say about most of the other contenders), but it's not all brutish straight-line grunt - with a 50:50 torque split that varies as required, the 2.4-tonne monster has been said to corner 'as if on rails'. Nice and safe on the North Circular, then.

Despite being 18 years old, this example presents a solid value proposition. Priced at roughly a fifth of its list price at launch, with low miles, only a few owners, and the most recent one being on the V5C for nearly a decade, it seems to be a cherished example. From the pictures it looks very tidy, and I think the cream leather works really well with the bluish-grey paint. As a possible future classic, a city beater, or a commuting monster, I really can't see you going wrong here. Assuming running costs aren't a concern. AF


Sutton VIP LEV Taxi, 2020, 101 miles, £121,480

Best city car? What a silly question. Anyone that actually lives in a city - the hipster, avocado-eating millennials like myself - know you don't have a car in the city. Firstly because no one can afford it, but also, no one really needs it. Especially not with a parade of Priuses at your fingertips.

Except of course I wasn't allowed to choose a Prius for one of the 'best city cars' - and quite rightly. So here's the business person's alternative - a London black cab. And not just any black cab - this is the Sutton VIP LEV Taxi. And what a Very Important Prius it is. Forget Uber - we're talking uber-luxurious.

Part of a genuine, money-CAN-buy production range, this one listed in the classifieds has four seats (not the posher, private-plane style two), plus a TV, and a fridge, and real leather. There's ambient lighting to "match the passenger's mood" (i.e. stressed or drunk), a Bluetooth stereo system, and the rear doors close as if by magic, thanks to the automatic closure from a Rolls Royce. Indeed, the listing says these are "extravagant features usually reserved for superyachts and private jets".

Top speed? Who knows. Power? Who cares. You won't be driving this thing, just appreciating it from the back seats, so that's all you need to look at. But it is £120,000. Well, that's only a couple of nights at a x5 Uber surcharge and you'll have made your money back. Yes, it's tacky and awful, but it beats a Prius. Nothing fake going on here. BW


Mini Cooper Sport, 1999, 62k, £14,950

This list could hardly be taken seriously without the original city car of Great Britain. It's not the first time I've called shotgun on a Mini for Six of the Best either. I've had a hankering for one as long as I can remember as a rolling restoration project to tinker with. This 23-year-old example appears to be in fine fettle and may not need much tinkering, but since when has that stopped us...

The Cooper Sport was one of the last evolutions of the classic Mini, before it went off sale in 2000. Almost 1.6 million Minis were sold in the UK since production started in 1959 and I for one am grateful to still see so many on the road. It's prowess in an urban environment hardly needs additional explanation; suffice it to say that very few modern cars can claim to rival its combination of dinky size and gap-finding pep.

Which brings me on to my next point - how brilliant does this car look wearing its British Racing Green paint? Sure, you might get a bit of cramp in your left leg and a bit hot sat in traffic, but at least you'll be doing it in quintessential style. BL


Author
Discussion

Mysstree

Original Poster:

547 posts

77 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
The initial message was deleted from this topic on 26 February 2022 at 20:11

griffdude

1,938 posts

279 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
i3 or Mini for me. If you’re considering the Bentley, might as well look at a FFRR.

ambuletz

11,803 posts

212 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
much as i would love to own a late rover mini they're expensive for what they are. More importantly it's not ULEZ. There's also that worry of you getting into an accident with a modern car, even if it is something 'small' like Ka, i10, up etc..

Lester H

4,475 posts

136 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
.....and here was silly me expecting Fiat 500, Picanto, Twingo' Up'108 and Hyundai i10. All around £6995.

Groaver

85 posts

64 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Not a Kei car in sight. frown

Earthdweller

19,816 posts

157 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Lester H said:
.....and here was silly me expecting Fiat 500, Picanto, Twingo' Up'108 and Hyundai i10. All around £6995.
laugh

Me too!

I have a Fiat 500 1.2 and it’s perfect as a runabout, bought it new in 2015 for just over £10k and brilliant, we don’t do a lot of miles in it, but as something that’s easy to drive/park/service and costs peanuts to insure/tax/fuel/maintain its perfect

AC43

13,722 posts

239 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
My wife insisted on a MINI or a Fiat 500 for our city car despite me pointing out Pandas, Ups, Swifts, i10's and so on. To be fair, they do look good (well, not so sure about the latest MINI...) and you can kit them out with much better kit than their more dowdy rivals; loads of colours choice, leather interiors, sunrooves and so on that are impossible to find on the more "sensible" options.

In fact, MINI's and 500's are everywhere you look here in NW London. I once went for a four mile and counted 30-odd of each on the local streets. The next most popular small car would probably be the Up/Citigo/Mii.

Small cars are just so handy in Zone 2. The shorter and narrower the better.




swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
A lot of i3 about when I was in the West End a couple of months ago.

VR6 Eug

832 posts

230 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Mini for me, had several over the years and enjoyed them very much, always made you smile ( unless it was raining) never has so little power felt so quick!

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Six of the best city cars, includes an old Bentley and a taxi that cost over 100k! Far better city cars around that deserve a mention including the Toyota iQ, Smart and one of the many rare but brilliant little Kei cars, plus many others

sideways man

1,676 posts

168 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
£13780 for a 3 yr old Up with 31k miles; they only cost that when new!

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Smart 450, Renault 4, original 500, 2cv, original Panda, Toyota iq and any number of bonkers kei cars would have made a much more interesting read.

Sharon-coizu

89 posts

89 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Nice clickbait list! Personally would go:

Smart FourTwo Brabus
Toyota IQ
Lupo GTi
Fiat Cinquecento Sporting
Honda S660

And my Picanto Gtdi - lowered by 30mm and remapped to 140bhp, with amusing results!

FlukePlay

1,201 posts

176 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
'Of course, where the GT really comes into its own is'...when something fails and you receive a bill for 7 grand.

Edited by FlukePlay on Saturday 26th February 18:10

Johnny G Pipe

283 posts

259 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Love my i3. Form follows function, like my 2CV. Its on its winter tyres and it rocks. Its reliable and funky and good to drive, and really satisfying to park next to ever more incomprehensible £120 per tank RR sports.
And I don’t even live in the city.

FPC

97 posts

82 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I know it's not out yet and RHD isn't confirm but the Microlino looks like great urban transport to me. Cute too.

CDP

8,062 posts

285 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
I live a long way from the city but with the horrific state of the roads round here that 2cv certainly looks tempting.

rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Best advice would be any Suzuki swift, 100% reliable and fun to drive.

I'd chose a Lupo GTi though, small nimble light and quick and zero depreciation better to drive than an Up GTi (but age goes against it so maybe an Up GTi better choice).

If your skint just get a late model KA zetec 2008 model for £1k

scorcher

4,130 posts

265 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
If living in a city means st choices like this , I’ll stick to living in the country and not bothering taking my business and spending my money there.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 26th February 2022
quotequote all
Sharon-coizu said:
Nice clickbait list! Personally would go:

Smart FourTwo Brabus
Toyota IQ
Lupo GTi
Fiat Cinquecento Sporting
Honda S660

And my Picanto Gtdi - lowered by 30mm and remapped to 140bhp, with amusing results!
Can't believe I forgot to all Cinq Sporting, adore those wee cars. Original Ka should also be on any city car list, brilliant handling and such a supple ride