Traffic management companies, another annoyance on our roads
Traffic management companies, another annoyance on our roads
Author
Discussion

scorcher

Original Poster:

4,130 posts

265 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Whilst there are plenty of things already to annoy on the roads, Traffic Management companies are getting near the top of my list now.
There was a time when the utilities would turn up with own lights , set up , do whatever and pack up and disappear. Now we get…..
Turn up hours early to put their equipment up for whichever utility company has requested it.
Signs placed at the narrowest part of the road, usually right opposite each other restricting the flow of traffic to one lane.
Signs placed so close together, you can barely get a car between them, let alone a lorry.
Signs placed so close to the roadworks, they are pretty much redundant if there’s more than about five cars in the queue.
Signs placed so close to the roadworks that you suddenly find yourself having to pull up on a blind bend in a nsl because of the lack of warning of roadworks until you find the end of the queue, praying that whatever is coming around behind you is able to stop too.
Entrance and exit points so tight that lorries struggle to freely move through the works, restricting the amount of vehicles getting through on green.
‘Wait here’ signs placed the wrong side of side roads so traffic blocks them when lights are on red.
Badly timed lights that only allow four cars through at a time .
Signs that blow over in the lightest gust of wind. And not put back up for the duration of the works.
Lights and cones left up for hours/ days after roadworks have been completed.
Signs and cones left behind littering the countryside.

Anyone else???

Sheetmaself

6,129 posts

229 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Get yourself on a NRSWA course, learn about chapter signage and pass the inspector course. Will give you the authority to move the barriers to meet the requirements.

Main issue is the location of parked vehicles, your best effort to meet the requirements can look idiotic once the park cars have moved. This is why there is the need to periodically check the signage and it should be captured in the Dynamic Risk Assessment any deviation from ideal signage due to third party factors.

Type R Tom

4,338 posts

180 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Yep, here is a link to the red book, you can read all about it

https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/governmen...


swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Sounds like another ‘industry’ designed to extract money.

Smint

3,669 posts

66 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Why do they have to close almost all alternative routes for overnight works at the same time, why can't they agree a timetable of works instead of having to do everything at the same time.

Saturday early morning, A46 closed, A43 closed, A45 closed west of Coventry, could use the M6/M42/M5 but M6 near Coventry down to 1 lane due to crash.
Hope everyone living in the villages on the only viable alternative routes left being pounded by the many night running trucks didn't mind their houses being shaken all night.

A43 was electronically signed as closed at B4525 (Silverstone to Banbury which is a perfectly serviceable route) but no they'd shut the road at the McDonalds/BP at Towcester and put up local access only signs.

sigh

Sheetmaself

6,129 posts

229 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
swisstoni said:
Sounds like another ‘industry’ designed to extract money.
Interested to see why you think this?

Not having a go or being argumentative just wondering why you came to this conclusion?

Skyedriver

23,740 posts

313 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Complying with all the relevant regulations for TM is not straight forward, believe me I've done it.
When a Statutory Undertaker turns up and hoys their signs any old how, it can cause problems. Some local authority gangs are bad too.
And have a thought for the guys putting the TM out, one of the most dangerous jobs going. You wouldn't believe the stupidity of some drivers.

swisstoni

24,250 posts

310 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Sheetmaself said:
swisstoni said:
Sounds like another ‘industry’ designed to extract money.
Interested to see why you think this?

Not having a go or being argumentative just wondering why you came to this conclusion?
Well, we seemed to manage for decades without them.
And I doubt they are making roadworks any cheaper for local authorities to pay for.

gazza285

11,262 posts

239 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Three way traffic lights on a busy roundabout, on a major route, protecting a pile of dirt on the pavement.

Mafioso

2,416 posts

245 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
gazza285 said:
Three way traffic lights on a busy roundabout, on a major route, protecting a pile of dirt on the pavement.
This, this and THIS! So many times lately I've been tempted to pull up and move all the cones and lights out of the road to allow the traffic to freely move. Utterly ridiculous at times.

Plymo

1,280 posts

120 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
First sell the "problem", then the solution will sell itself...

Jaguar steve

9,232 posts

241 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
I'll just leave the words fking Anglian fking Water here.

This particularly obtuse Cunch of Bunts are in the regular habit of causing absolute carnage all over Essex and Suffolk by allowing their traffic management minions to leave temporary lights and closures in place often for days before and after they actually need to be in place.


DavePanda

6,826 posts

265 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Worse is when they set up lights etc just because they have to divert the pavement into a barriered off area, no works actually in the road. Would it really do any harm to shut the path for a few days instead of causing chaos?

Where i work they are building a new trade park, in order to construct the new entrance to it they've shut the pavement for 50yds and set up 2 pedestrian crossings so the people who walk along it can cross to one side for 50yds then cross back again, of course by the time the first set of lights have changed green the others are going red so they can cross back to the correct side. To add insult to injury they've put ramps jutting into the road so karen in her mobility scooter can get down the kerb, the road is narrow enough so that only cars can pass unhindered, a truck or bus has to stop and go around the ramp

MadCaptainJack

1,915 posts

71 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Mafioso said:
This, this and THIS! So many times lately I've been tempted to pull up and move all the cones and lights out of the road to allow the traffic to freely move. Utterly ridiculous at times.
I wonder what you'd be done for if you were caught.

Krikkit

27,943 posts

212 months

Sunday 27th February 2022
quotequote all
Skyedriver said:
Complying with all the relevant regulations for TM is not straight forward, believe me I've done it.
When a Statutory Undertaker turns up and hoys their signs any old how, it can cause problems. Some local authority gangs are bad too.
And have a thought for the guys putting the TM out, one of the most dangerous jobs going. You wouldn't believe the stupidity of some drivers.
I'm sure! Problem is, like most things in life, done right I'm sure it'll make things much easier for everyone. The lazy cowboys, however, ruin it for the rest.

bad_panda

132 posts

100 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
scorcher said:
Whilst there are plenty of things already to annoy on the roads, Traffic Management companies are getting near the top of my list now.
There was a time when the utilities would turn up with own lights , set up , do whatever and pack up and disappear. Now we get…..
Turn up hours early to put their equipment up for whichever utility company has requested it.
Signs placed at the narrowest part of the road, usually right opposite each other restricting the flow of traffic to one lane.
Signs placed so close together, you can barely get a car between them, let alone a lorry.
Signs placed so close to the roadworks, they are pretty much redundant if there’s more than about five cars in the queue.
Signs placed so close to the roadworks that you suddenly find yourself having to pull up on a blind bend in a nsl because of the lack of warning of roadworks until you find the end of the queue, praying that whatever is coming around behind you is able to stop too.
Entrance and exit points so tight that lorries struggle to freely move through the works, restricting the amount of vehicles getting through on green.
‘Wait here’ signs placed the wrong side of side roads so traffic blocks them when lights are on red.
Badly timed lights that only allow four cars through at a time .
Signs that blow over in the lightest gust of wind. And not put back up for the duration of the works.
Lights and cones left up for hours/ days after roadworks have been completed.
Signs and cones left behind littering the countryside.

Anyone else???
I wondered what had changed here. Didn't even realise that utilities firms had stopped looking after their own traffc management, but I'd noticed that it'd got far worse for all the reasons you list, all of which drive me mad. Now it makes sense.

vikingaero

13,606 posts

200 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
MadCaptainJack said:
I wonder what you'd be done for if you were caught.
We have temporary pedestrian lights at a junction near me. They were put in during Covid as tons of people were walking. To be honest they weren't necessary as it's a congested/slow moving junction - pedestrian turns up to cross, drivers are at walking pace anyway and wave them across. So 2 years later the lights are still there.

As they are battery powered the light fail and lock on red after 4-5 days. And people stop at the red, even though it could be 3am before dithering and driving through. When this happens some considerate drivers get out and turn the light sideways to prevent delays. The inconsiderate drivers just topple them over. Then a few days later the Traffic Management Company turn up and replace them. So 2 years of renting temporary lights, signs, barriers etc.....

Ziplobb

1,623 posts

315 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
scorcher said:
Traffic Management

Anyone else???
They dont actually manage - they should be renamed 'Creators of Congestion and Inconvenience Companies'

vikingaero

13,606 posts

200 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
Ziplobb said:
scorcher said:
Traffic Management

Anyone else???
They dont actually manage - they should be renamed 'Creators of Congestion and Inconvenience Companies'
A few years ago, I remember seeing a Traffic Management Company, cone off one lane of The Highway in London and it caused me a few minutes delay as I was near the front of the queue. On my return journey a few hours later it was gridlock, caused by this one lane being closed. As I approacched in the oncoming lane, a guy in a white van got out and moved all the cones and signs onto the central reservation and in an instant the bottleneck was free.

What I don't understand is why they don't do this? Place everything to one side until they turn up to actually do the work. As soon as you move the cones out, you create the safe working space. Obviously common sense is very dangerous.

Smint

3,669 posts

66 months

Monday 28th February 2022
quotequote all
Very similar a few years back A43 s/b approaching Cherwell Valley services, a truck had turned over just leaving the first roundabout where M40 s/b exited, but as he was almost fully off the road and as you leave the roundabout all traffic was flowing past no trouble.

I returned a couple of hours later thankfully no delays my way, but wombles had coned off down to a single lane before the roundabout, results miles of queuing traffic.
They could easily have waited to cone the road off till the wrecker turned up but that wouldn't have caused anywhere near as much disruption.