RE: BMW Z3 Roadster | Shed of the Week
RE: BMW Z3 Roadster | Shed of the Week
Friday 11th March 2022

BMW Z3 Roadster | Shed of the Week

Yes, it's the 1.9-litre slusher. Redeemed at shed money? Or beyond forgiveness?



With the onset of spring, the idea of a sporty two-seater traditionally gains traction in the collective consciousness. Whether you'd ever put the word 'sporty' in the same paragraph, let alone the same sentence, as the phrase 'BMW Z3 1.9-litre automatic' is a moot point however.

Despite what the ad says (1997) this week's shed is a 1998 example of the Joji Nagashima-designed (under Chris Bangle tutelage) Z3 roadster. According to the internet, a year after our car was registered BMW put out a prototype Z3 roadster with an M73 5.4-litre motor under the bonnet. It had 322hp, 361lb ft, a six-speed manual gearbox and a 0-62 time of 5.5sec. Now that would have been something. Inexplicably, they opted not to produce it.

Instead they droned on with the 138hp 1.9, an impressively relaxed thing which in 5-speed manual form ambled through the 0-62mph run in 9.5sec, assuming you could bring yourself to hold on to the gears until max power was attained at 6,000rpm. In reality those revs were rarely reached by anyone with functioning ears. You couldn't rely on torque to get you down the road either: you had just 133lb ft of that at an uncomfortable 4,300rpm.


As you might guess, bolting a four-speed torque converter to it, as here, didn't improve matters. That trans added 140kg to the plot and a full second to the manual's 0-62 time, resulting in not very jolly performance: 0-62 in 10.5sec, a doleful top end of 122mph and combined fuel consumption of 32mpg, drooping to 22mpg in town.

If you found yourself at the top of a glacier and needed to get to the bottom quickly, and you had the choice of a 1.9 auto Z3 or your legs, you were probably better off standing still at the top and waiting for global warming to get you to your destination. Even the BMW Basics 114hp 1.8-litre Z3 was quicker than the 1.9 auto to the tune of one tenth off the 0-62, so still not exactly rapid.

So, what is the appeal of the Z3 then? Well, a lot of folk quite like the looks of these, and this particular example has only done 53,000 miles. Scanning the MOT history you might think that's not quite right as it had already done nearly 86,000 miles by last June, but if we dig back far enough (2017) we note that the readings at that point were in kilometres. So the 56,000 miles that's stated now may well be correct.


Successive owners will undoubtedly have tried to put more miles on it but would have been prevented from doing so by the lack of speed and the need to do other stuff, like eat. Last June's MOT tester was clearly lulled into a sense of stupor by it as they couldn't be bothered to write a single advisory note on the chit. Which is good as rot is usually the problem on these, in the sills, boot floor and arches. The hood looks OK too, which will save the next owner quite a few bob, although fixing the split seat might be cheaper than replacing it.

The question of course is why has it got a km speedo, if it does. Shed can't really tell from this distance. No doubt some bright spark on the forum will have a thought on that. Might it be connected to the wooden dash, which (as far as Shed remembers) wasn't available on UK Z3s? Does anybody remember otherwise? Is it some sort of Euro spec thing and we're looking at a UK import here, or has someone just glued on one of those veneer kits?

A few mysteries to be solved then. The front of a Z3 looks a bit like Hercule Poirot so you could use that as inspiration. If you're a Z3 auto kinda guy, or gal, you're probably not going to be in much of a hurry to work it out. Does any of it matter anyway when other Z3s are commonly advertised for three or even four times that amount? The last time we did one of these, back in October 2020, Shed noted that three grand seemed to be the ballpark figure for sub-100,000 milers. This one is £1,500.


See the full ad here




Author
Discussion

supacool1

Original Poster:

744 posts

210 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Already sold! Nice seats. Black with red interior does look good.

Global Nomad

105 posts

112 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
despite this weeks shed selling fast, my actual shed is faster......

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Loved ours, great cars to live with, easy to own, watch the rust though

Billy_Whizzzz

2,677 posts

174 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Australian Import? Might be rust free but that auto kills an already rubbish car.

humphra

636 posts

123 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Nice colour combo and perhaps the lazy engine/ gearbox combination could suite it in a suitably lazy environment, like a coastal road drive.

For me at least, an interesting shed!

yme402

670 posts

133 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Try and get the later E85 Z4. A better car in every respect and its design is ageing far better and is already overtaking Z3 now in collectability.

prand

6,246 posts

227 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
My wife has a 3.0l manual msport version. It's great for a 20yr old car.

aston addict

475 posts

189 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Interior space only a gnome could love, and worn seats that give away a far higher mileage…

Court_S

14,828 posts

208 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
I used to really dislike these, but they’ve grown into their retro looks pretty well. This is a nice colour combo but it’s dog slow.

Car Throttle bought a four cylinder Z3 as a project car last year, which was a series of videos that I quite enjoyed. There are a few mods for the 1.9 that appear to improve it a bit.

Nu57jez9639

1,068 posts

69 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
5 owners with only 56,000 miles on it that doesn't seam Wright to Me unless it's lived all its life on jersey, under powered and 22 mpg that's horrendous for something under 2.0 L

In need of tlc but sold anyway .

Court_S

14,828 posts

208 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
yme402 said:
Try and get the later E85 Z4. A better car in every respect and its design is ageing far better and is already overtaking Z3 now in collectability.
They’re a lot more expensive though. I agree they’re a much better car, but at a cost.

helix402

7,913 posts

213 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Hideous aftermarket wheels.

benzinbob

750 posts

87 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
yme402 said:
Try and get the later E85 Z4. A better car in every respect and its design is ageing far better and is already overtaking Z3 now in collectability.
No one is collecting a car at this price point.

x5tuu

12,793 posts

218 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
benzinbob said:
No one is collecting a car at this price point.
Tell that to the people who bought up mk1 and 2 fiestas, mk2/3/4 escorts, e30’s, etc… for peanuts a few years back that are now worth considerable money.


rallycross

13,763 posts

268 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
yme402 said:
Try and get the later E85 Z4. A better car in every respect and its design is ageing far better and is already overtaking Z3 now in collectability.
Not for £1500 - you won’t get anything close.

pb8g09

3,296 posts

100 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
A terrible version of a classic.

The kind of drivetrain that gives a bad name to the model. Not one to care about image normally but is there anything more ‘hairdresser’ than a 1.9litre slushbox in one of these?!

bangerhoarder

819 posts

99 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Was the auto available on the later SOHC M43 (8v)? Now that would’ve been special. They’re glacial with a manual.

Flanners

268 posts

161 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
So what was/is the appeal....I was left thinking that too and still am. Overpriced, overweight and underpowered throw in the awful styling, colours and reliability issues...it's peers make for far better ownership than this turd of a car.

cerb4.5lee

45,310 posts

211 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
That is a nice colour combo and it is the same as the Z4M I had. This seems like a very nice bit of top down motoring for the money I reckon. I'd personally want a manual and a bit more punch though.

These have definitely grown on me as the years have gone by.


12lee

193 posts

196 months

Friday 11th March 2022
quotequote all
Japanese import?