I think my garage is ripping me off and I need to know what
I think my garage is ripping me off and I need to know what
Author
Discussion

trevalvole

2,095 posts

64 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
I can't help very much, though by replying others who can help may see your post in "What's New".

It is possible that the garage had two people working on your car at the same time, so the amount of time they had your car doesn't have to limit the hours worked on your car.

Did you give them permission to do the work on the stabilizer bar and did they tell you what the cost would be before they started the work?

Is the garage you used part of a national chain or a member of an association which sets down rules for how they should work and complaints handling? (Don't name the garage - there are rules against that.) If so, find out what the rules are; speak to them in person and ask them to explain your bill to you and if you still aren't happy make a complaint. As part of this, ask them how they managed seven hours work in six hours.

I'm not optimistic that the above will work - if it doesn't work, then probably the best advice is to not use that garage again and to ask people you know for recommendations of good garages, plus check their reviews on Google etc.

sherman

15,342 posts

246 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
Biggest thing out of all this I spot is why did you only get one pad changed but both disks? It would have been buttons for the second pad.
£200 is expensive for rear pads and disks. I had front 330mm disks and pads changed on an rx8 for £180 at a main dealer.
Parts for steering could just be expensive this year due to continued supply issues from brexit.
You have a french car.

Jazoli

9,707 posts

281 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
Biggest thing out of all this I spot is why did you only get one pad changed but both disks? It would have been buttons for the second pad.
£200 is expensive for rear pads and disks. I had front 330mm disks and pads changed on an rx8 for £180 at a main dealer.
Parts for steering could just be expensive this year due to continued supply issues from brexit.
You have a french car.
The rear discs have integrated wheel bearings, £200 from a garage is about right to be honest, it has no relation to what you paid for discs on a completely different car.

Can't help with the rest OP

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
Biggest thing out of all this I spot is why did you only get one pad changed but both disks? It would have been buttons for the second pad.
I strongly suspect that the garage fitted one set of pads to go with the two discs. (A set of pads is four pads, sufficient for two discs.) They would not have fitted a single pad and left the others.

Scrump

23,948 posts

189 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
I am struggling to understand this.
Brake parts come to £264.43, new stabiliser link is £52.75 (with VAT), so a total of £317.18 on parts. Your opening post says you were charged £410 for this work including labour. They have charged you a total of £92.82 on labour which seems like a very good price.
I think the 6 hours labour is wrong or they have a very cheap hourly rate. Either way you do not seem to have been overcharged.

Jazoli

9,707 posts

281 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
6 labour hours at £94.56, that's more like 0.6 hours, no garage is going to work for £15/hr, a lot of places are charging £150/hr these days which would be right, the prices seem right to me, I can't see why you have been ripped off, the car will have 2 stabiliser links (or anti-roll bar links) there's every possibility that the other side has failed after one side has been changed previously.

Getting cars fixed at garages is expensive, but what you have quoted seems reasonable.

Bobupndown

3,035 posts

74 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
What is the stabiliser bar you describe and how is it getting damaged every year?

On power steering, on full lock you will get a noise which goes away when you take the lock off, quite normal.

If you go to one garage who tell you there is no problem and you go to others you are going to get bitten by someone thinking you are an easy touch.

ian in lancs

3,853 posts

229 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
Get help from trading standards a government department to help in such matters https://www.gov.uk/find-local-trading-standards-of...

Richard-D

2,316 posts

95 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
There is always some subjectivity in deciding whether or not a noise is normal, reasonable or excessive. There usually isn't a definitive test to decide when something is 'too worn'. From your description it could easily be that one 'anti roll bar drop link' was changed last year and the other this year.

The prices don't sound excessive. More than I would pay but I fix my own car. If you can't do that then you have to pay people for their time. People's time isn't free and business rates, electricity bills, tools, experience etc etc all costs.

silentbrown

11,024 posts

147 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
Biggest thing out of all this I spot is why did you only get one pad changed but both disks?
Perfectly normal. Brake disks are sold individually, pads as a set per axle. (And two pads per side, obvs.)


davidexige

601 posts

237 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
Just so you know, your car will be fitted with two stabiliser link bars, It's possible that the one they've replaced was not the one you had replaced last year.

silentbrown

11,024 posts

147 months

Saturday 12th March 2022
quotequote all
Bobupndown said:
What is the stabiliser bar you describe and how is it getting damaged every year?
I'd assume its the front ARB. There are balljointed links from the struts. I expect a link has been replaced.

0.6 hours seems about right for that job.

Wicker Man

867 posts

274 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
Prices seem about right for a garage that has wages and overheads to pay.

But if money is tight then DIY is always an option. You just need the inclination a few (pink?) tools and somewhere to work. Or know someone who has…

Pit Pony

11,518 posts

152 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
Hydraulic power steering has a characteristic noise at the end of the steering lock. Is it a relief valve opening?

4Q

3,607 posts

175 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
£94 labour doesn’t sound bad, my local Land Rover dealership wanted £180 (1-hours labour) just to have a look at the job before actually doing any work.

Cloudy147

3,185 posts

214 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
Hi Laura80,

I'm taking the whole brake disc thing out of the equation as this seems to be something that you are happy with.

Regarding the other work, it could be an entirely honest garage - mechanic'ing is often not an exact science as others have mentioned.

My guess is that you advised them of the problem, so they had a poke around and spotted that the stabiliser link was faulty and thought "that will likely be the issue". So they quoted to fit it, and you accepted. They fitted the part and you paid the money, but unfortunately it didn't resolve the problem. You called and spoke to another mechanic who said that in his opinion there is nothing actually wrong from your description. However, the point to note here is that they may well have actually fixed a different problem that you didn't know you had.

If that is the case, then you haven't been ripped off in terms of the work done, its just that you've paid for something to be fixed that you didn't know was broken.

I could be wrong of course, but wanted to offer a different perspective as it is possible that have done something legitimate here.

I also wouldn't focus on the labour rates down to individual hours etc - they quoted a price, you were happy with it, and they did the work for that price. Whether you'd want to use them again in the future based on their prices would be your choice.

My suggestion would be to talk to them in the first instance and ask why they replaced a part when the other mechanic said it didn't need doing in order to resolve the problem that you brought to them - and then take it from there if you aren't satisfied with the answer.

Edited by Cloudy147 on Sunday 13th March 11:57

Export56

576 posts

119 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
Has the noise gone away? If so they have fixed it and a service plus discs and pads and stabiliser bar for 520 seems good deal.

CS Garth

2,873 posts

136 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
I think you’ve made a mistake. They haven’t charged you 6 hours labour. They’ve charged you 94 quid. Which isn’t 6 hours.

I would suggest you contact them to confirm this and then ask yourself are you happy. I would be. Then move on. Maybe use another garage next time as well.

sherman

15,342 posts

246 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
silentbrown said:
sherman said:
Biggest thing out of all this I spot is why did you only get one pad changed but both disks?
Perfectly normal. Brake disks are sold individually, pads as a set per axle. (And two pads per side, obvs.)
If your changing discs why would you not change the pads whilst you are there? No point in taking the wheel off twice.

silentbrown

11,024 posts

147 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
sherman said:
If your changing discs why would you not change the pads whilst you are there? No point in taking the wheel off twice.
That's what they did. 2 discs, 1 set of pads. All pads changed. It's not difficult, surely?