Opinion on K&N panel air filters
Opinion on K&N panel air filters
Author
Discussion

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
Sure this is a rather controversial topic, but does anyone use one of these and prefer them over paper filters?

My car had one in when I bought it, but I'm tempted to replace it with a paper filter for better filtration. Not too bothered about losing 2bhp on a road car.

I also don't get the hype over reusing them, you're never going to get them 100% perfect after cleaning. And the risk of over/under oiling them makes it a rather risky affair with the risk of ruined MAFs or a filter that is not trapping enough particles. I do think just swapping a paper filter is far less hassle and no doubt quicker.

wpa1975

14,870 posts

145 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
As you said, Maf issues caused be the oil has always put me off them.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

204 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
They don't filter as well as a clean paper filter, that's a fact.

Just remove the filter completely if you're that bothered about the pressure drop.

MC Bodge

30,206 posts

206 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
I used them on cars years ago. I needed to clean the MAFs when I serviced the car.

I wouldn't bother now. Just use paper filters.

talksthetorque

10,821 posts

166 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
I believe if you're replacing the OEM airbox with a cone filter or other modified inlet then great.

For whatever reason you are changing it - better induction noise, under bonnet looks, percieved or actual performance/throttle response gains, go for it.

If you're swapping an airbox internal filter for a K&N there's got to be a miniscule window of applications where the benefits outweigh the drawbacks and additional cost.

AJB88

16,004 posts

202 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
They don't filter as well as a clean paper filter, that's a fact.

Just remove the filter completely if you're that bothered about the pressure drop.
100% seen many turbos go where they have been running these long term.

I did some back to back dyno runs with one of my old cars and it made 0 difference as well.

adblack28

22 posts

118 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
I happily use one. I've got a 2010 Mk 6 VW Golf Gt TDi 140 bhp. I bought it on 15,000 from VW in 2012, it's now on 205,500k in 2022.

I've run it pretty much solely (from about 20k onwards) with a K&N direct panel filter swap; I've periodically taken it out, fully cleaned it, re-oiled it and reinserted it with no issue. The car has done higher MPG as a result and I've had no MAF or turbo issues. The car is entirely stock, full VW specialist service history and oil changes every 15k. I took it from Leicester to Falkirk and return last month and squeezed 750 miles from a tank.

It's the second Golf I've done this with, previously I had a Mk4 Gt TDI with a 115bhp PD engine which got to 275k before the body finally wouldnt pass anymore MOT'S.

talksthetorque

10,821 posts

166 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
adblack28 said:
I happily use one. I've got a 2010 Mk 6 VW Golf Gt TDi 140 bhp. I bought it on 15,000 from VW in 2012, it's now on 205,500k in 2022.

I've run it pretty much solely (from about 20k onwards) with a K&N direct panel filter swap; I've periodically taken it out, fully cleaned it, re-oiled it and reinserted it with no issue. The car has done higher MPG as a result and I've had no MAF or turbo issues. The car is entirely stock, full VW specialist service history and oil changes every 15k. I took it from Leicester to Falkirk and return last month and squeezed 750 miles from a tank.

It's the second Golf I've done this with, previously I had a Mk4 Gt TDI with a 115bhp PD engine which got to 275k before the body finally wouldnt pass anymore MOT'S.
How do you know you have got higher mpg than you would have with an OEM air filter?

Athlon

5,955 posts

237 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
I did back to back dyno runs with various filters for a manufacturer on the same day with as close to exact conditions as possible on a fully calibrated state of the art Bosch dyno.

Stick to O.E. There is little to no gain in performance filtration wise or performance. Some do sound good though! Some actually reduced h.p. ( I am looking at you cone filters..)

No cards in the game, just what we learned on the day.

adblack28

22 posts

118 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
It's simple concept of Air flow. I work in a CCGT power station, and so consulted our in house gas turbine engineers before buying one. they all recommended it. I did the aforementioned return journey to Falkirk on (albeit a trip computer mpg) of 65.7mpg with the cruise control set at 72mph. Clearly I'm sure someone else might beat that but its pretty goo going for a (at the time) 204k common rail diesel engine.

I installed one for sustainability reasons ( I appreciate thats potentially little environmental benefit when running a car up to and over 200K) rather than performance, but the car is in pretty good health, and I'd actually happily say it runs better at 200k then it did at 60k).

adblack28

22 posts

118 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
(having said that, if anyone has a great Mk6 Golf leather interior in the NW, I'm all ears, because my drivers seat is pretty buggered tbh).

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
adblack28 said:
It's simple concept of Air flow. I work in a CCGT power station, and so consulted our in house gas turbine engineers before buying one. they all recommended it. I did the aforementioned return journey to Falkirk on (albeit a trip computer mpg) of 65.7mpg with the cruise control set at 72mph. Clearly I'm sure someone else might beat that but its pretty goo going for a (at the time) 204k common rail diesel engine.

I installed one for sustainability reasons ( I appreciate thats potentially little environmental benefit when running a car up to and over 200K) rather than performance, but the car is in pretty good health, and I'd actually happily say it runs better at 200k then it did at 60k).
More air flow means less filtration surely?

adblack28

22 posts

118 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
For sure, I'd agree, more air flow = less filtration. But then I'm driving a relatively boring golf on mundane UK roads. the percentage of real dust / sand intake is fairly small I'd reckon whereas the sticks / leaves / grotty bits are still kept out. I'm betting most OEM paper filters are designed for all environments, and so (to me) as long as you don't over oil your filter you wont poison any sensors and as long as you don't drive in dusty areas you wont bugger your turbo (I mostly commute between North Wales and the Midlands) I'm not really going to see that much dust or smaller particles. Clearly I'm also driving probably the most mundane of cars ( A silver, diesel Golf) rather than anything more specialist or expensive. But to me, I reckon it's a fairly safe assumption I've done ok. Clearly if you've got a 10k specialist built engine in a race car, it's possibly a different set of worries.

aturnick54

Original Poster:

1,328 posts

59 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
adblack28 said:
For sure, I'd agree, more air flow = less filtration. But then I'm driving a relatively boring golf on mundane UK roads. the percentage of real dust / sand intake is fairly small I'd reckon whereas the sticks / leaves / grotty bits are still kept out. I'm betting most OEM paper filters are designed for all environments, and so (to me) as long as you don't over oil your filter you wont poison any sensors and as long as you don't drive in dusty areas you wont bugger your turbo (I mostly commute between North Wales and the Midlands) I'm not really going to see that much dust or smaller particles. Clearly I'm also driving probably the most mundane of cars ( A silver, diesel Golf) rather than anything more specialist or expensive. But to me, I reckon it's a fairly safe assumption I've done ok. Clearly if you've got a 10k specialist built engine in a race car, it's possibly a different set of worries.
I think in my case I'd be smart to switch back to a paper filter as I'll be driving to the south of Europe in summer so dust will be more of a concern.

Timothy Bucktu

16,952 posts

231 months

Sunday 13th March 2022
quotequote all
They're an 80's carburetted car throwback...times have changed.
See also Redex, Wynns/STP/ZX1 oil additives etc etc.

dhutch

17,959 posts

228 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
aturnick54 said:
More air flow means less filtration surely?
Not nessarally. But maybe yes.

I just use a standard brand name OEM spac filter.

steveo3002

11,244 posts

205 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
plenty of tests showing how a paper filter is better over xxx miles , waste of money imo

Griffith4ever

7,080 posts

66 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Timothy Bucktu said:
They're an 80's carburetted car throwback...times have changed.
See also Redex, Wynns/STP/ZX1 oil additives etc etc.
This was my exact thoughts. Gone are the days where we need to squeeze an extra 1.5hp out of an NA car that was 102hp stock (when they made a decent total percentage difference it mattered).

Petrols are now fast and diesel easy to chip for massive gains.

MC Bodge

30,206 posts

206 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
Some very powerful cars manage with paper filters

Griffith4ever

7,080 posts

66 months

Monday 14th March 2022
quotequote all
I think also, a factor is that in the 80's a reusable filter paid for itself after a few services. Now we have the internet and Euro car parts et al. A paper filter comes in at a few quid these days.