Temporary lights stuck on red. How long would you wait?
Temporary lights stuck on red. How long would you wait?
Author
Discussion

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Got caught in one of these today. I was the sixth car back in the queue. It was on an A road on a bend so couldn't see the opposing set.

I gave it about 10 minutes, nothing every came from the other end, got out of the car to see if there were any workers in sight, there were none, so got back in and went for it.

Got through safely. Opposing set stuck on red too. No workers anywhere.

Many chose to follow me. biggrin

How long would you wait?

RazerSauber

2,947 posts

91 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
I'd wait just long enough for an officer to turn up and pull me over for it, knowing my luck!

Mammasaid

5,659 posts

128 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Official guidance is you shouldn't, you should turn round and find another route.

The lights should have emergency contact info, usually the Streetworks Supervisor's mobile number, you should report that they're not working.

Don't forget, they are designed to 'Fail safe', i.e. all turn to red, if there's a problem.

Pistonheader101

2,206 posts

138 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
3 minutes.

jamei303

3,084 posts

187 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
I'd immediately summon a uniformed constable to wave me through.

DaveCWK

2,423 posts

205 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
3-5 minutes seems reasonable. Depends how far you can see as you say, or if there are gaps in the cones & safe areas you can pull into should a car come the other way.

anonymous-user

Original Poster:

85 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Mammasaid said:
Official guidance is you shouldn't, you should turn round and find another route.

The lights should have emergency contact info, usually the Streetworks Supervisor's mobile number, you should report that they're not working.

Don't forget, they are designed to 'Fail safe', i.e. all turn to red, if there's a problem.
Well their certainly was a problem, they weren't working and I had things to do places to go. laugh

Zetec-S

6,952 posts

124 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Quick call in to the local 4x4 response control room, one of their quick-deploy units could be on the scene in a matter of minutes and take control of the incident.

Glenn63

3,980 posts

115 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
It’s usually quite safe as they cone off 6 miles of perfectly fine lane for 2 meters of works so plenty of room to nip through the cones and stop if people start coming the other way.

georgeyboy12345

4,669 posts

66 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Honestly like a couple of minutes

Terminator X

21,014 posts

235 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
1 minute max.

TX.

OutInTheShed

14,949 posts

57 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
I believe I've seen this caused by the first car stopping too far from the lights to trigger the 'radar'.
I could see the car stopped at the red for a couple of minutes as I approached.
I could see the lights of a car stopped at the other end of the roadworks.
I waited about 2 minutes, then overtook the numpty, which triggered the lights to change in my favour.
Or it could have been chance?

off_again

13,917 posts

265 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Interestingly, not sure if anyone knows this - but several states in the US have a 'dead red' rule. Usually written as rules where the sensors dont detect a motorcycle (surprisingly it happens more frequently than you might imagine) - so you can pass through a red light, only if its safe to do so. Usually the guidance is that you should wait for 2 full cycles of the lights, assuming you are at a larger interchange with protected lights.

Unfortunately, this doesnt apply to California. Though I will admit that I have run a couple of red lights in the past. Stopped for 5+ mins, no traffic and the sensor wont detect you. Since most motorcycle accidents in California are rear-enders at lights, I doubt that they could make it stick in that situation.

KP328

1,879 posts

226 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Throughout last year on my way to work i encountered 6 faulty temporary traffic lights and 1 faulty normal traffic light, very frustrating.

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Tuesday 15th March 2022
quotequote all
Phone Rod Stewart to come and sort them out.

vikingaero

13,579 posts

200 months

Wednesday 16th March 2022
quotequote all
I go through red temporary lights every week. For about 2 years, for Covid, our Council have rented a set of temporary pelican crossing lights at a junction. About 5 days after the battery is changed, the lights fail and revert to red. Some of us stop and turn the lights sideways to increase traffic flow [cue indignation and PHers quoting legalese] Then a few days after they are stuck, the traffic company replaces the batteries. Rinse and repeat for the past 2 years.

The main point is the temporary lights were put in place because more people were walking as a result of Covid restrictions. There were very few cars then, so no need for the lights. Even now, with traffic back to normal, if the lights weren't there, and a pedestrian turned up, because it's slow moving urban traffic, most drivers wave people across.

230TE

2,506 posts

217 months

Wednesday 16th March 2022
quotequote all
I think this comes under the heading of "Very British Problems". I've had it a few times where I can see right to the other end of the roadworks: I sit there for ages thinking "have the lights really failed, do I dare, what if a policeman sees me". Then finally go for it, absolutely cane it to get through as fast as possible, the car behind doesn't follow me and I feel like a total rebel. Spend the rest of the journey thinking "should I have reported those lights to someone".


Rozzers

3,077 posts

106 months

Wednesday 16th March 2022
quotequote all
Until a uniformed Police officer directs me to proceed of course.

croyde

26,542 posts

261 months

Wednesday 16th March 2022
quotequote all
Zetec-S said:
Quick call in to the local 4x4 response control room, one of their quick-deploy units could be on the scene in a matter of minutes and take control of the incident.
rofl

psi310398

11,146 posts

234 months

Wednesday 16th March 2022
quotequote all
Genuine question here. What is the status of temporary lights, or indeed of a chap operating a stop/go lollipop?

Do the contractors actually have/require any lawful authority to instal these things? I’ve never seen seen a piece of paper pinned up setting out time periods, the stretch to which it applies, (as with parking bay suspensions) etc.