Are these cars the shape of things to come?
Are these cars the shape of things to come?
Author
Discussion

RDMcG

Original Poster:

20,916 posts

238 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I saw these pics on a single page and it struck me how homogenized we have become. When I was a kid a Cadillac was a huge American boat and an Audi was a VW sub brand and a bit anonymous, but very European.Of course the Caddy and Audi are different, but I hope we do not go down a path of decreasing individuality.

Now:




NDA

25,831 posts

256 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I guess it's the shape of 'regulations'. Unless you are a very small manufacturer, like Morgan, it's hard to escape the heavy hand of regulation.

OutInTheShed

14,948 posts

57 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
NDA said:
I guess it's the shape of 'regulations'. Unless you are a very small manufacturer, like Morgan, it's hard to escape the heavy hand of regulation.
I suspect there's a big element of designers being heavily influenced by the same things.
Looks like they're chasing the 'want an evoque but can't afford it sector' to me.

Regulation and efficiency may shape a lot of the car, but things like the angle of the pillars and where the fore-aft creases in the body are all look derivative from certain cars?
The public wants what the public gets etc.

I reckon in 5 years time, a lot of new models will be heavily Tesla influenced.

If you offered the public something reminiscent of the old Audi 100, or Lancia HPE, they'd probably say it looked like a Hyundai.

Even Ducati make a lot of bikes that look like everything else at the moment.

btdk5

1,862 posts

221 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
OutInTheShed said:
Even Ducati make a lot of bikes that look like everything else at the moment.
Strange comparison.

Motorbikes have always looked pretty similar.

RicksAlfas

14,602 posts

275 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
That Cadillac looks good!

ingenieur

4,653 posts

212 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I call them watermelon cars because they all seem to have the vague outline of a watermelon.

If you don't like them show the manufacturers by buying the more ordinary 3-series or whatever. Don't keep buying watermelons if that's all you want a choice of.

OutInTheShed

14,948 posts

57 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
btdk5 said:
OutInTheShed said:
Even Ducati make a lot of bikes that look like everything else at the moment.
Strange comparison.

Motorbikes have always looked pretty similar.
To a non-motorcyclist perhaps?

Cars all look the same a box with a wheel in each corner, windscreen at the front behind the bonnet, doors at the side etc etc.

A Ducati 916 looked like no other bike. A 900ss likewise. A Pantah too.
Lately you can't see the V twin engine. Bodywork looks much like the average Jap sports bike.
I suspect being part of VW-Audi has a little to do with it.

Bobupndown

3,035 posts

74 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I wonder why most electric models look st and weirdly 'modernist'. Why make an ID3?, just make an electric Golf if you must.

FHCNICK

1,376 posts

262 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
That wheels on that Audi look almost as big as wagon wheels from the days of the wild west and judging by the minimal room between the tyre and the wheel arch there cannot be much in the way of suspension travel. I would have an x-ray on my back after driving that on our poorly maintained UK roads.

On second thoughts I would insist that those comedy clown wheels were swapped for rims at least 2 inches smaller diameter before I drove it.

Edited to add: Just what are those details over the exhausts? Is it supposed to trick following drivers that your car has full ground effects venturi tunnels running underneath the car?



Edited by FHCNICK on Friday 18th March 17:12

OutInTheShed

14,948 posts

57 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
FHCNICK said:
...

Edited to add: Just what are those details over the exhausts? Is it supposed to trick following drivers that your car has full ground effects venturi tunnels running underneath the car?



Edited by FHCNICK on Friday 18th March 17:12
Similar diagonal lines to the motorised handbag that is the evoque in that area?
And probably two dozen other models of car that don't annoy me so much.

NMNeil

5,860 posts

81 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
ingenieur said:
I call them watermelon cars because they all seem to have the vague outline of a watermelon.

If you don't like them show the manufacturers by buying the more ordinary 3-series or whatever. Don't keep buying watermelons if that's all you want a choice of.
Remember when the Ford Sierra was first released? it was described as a jelly-mold biggrin

NMNeil

5,860 posts

81 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
NDA said:
I guess it's the shape of 'regulations'. Unless you are a very small manufacturer, like Morgan, it's hard to escape the heavy hand of regulation.
Out of interest, what regulations are Morgan exempted from following?

Alex@POD

6,454 posts

246 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
FHCNICK said:
Edited to add: Just what are those details over the exhausts?
What exhausts?

Edited by Alex@POD on Friday 18th March 18:13

gazza285

11,262 posts

239 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
NDA said:
I guess it's the shape of 'regulations'. Unless you are a very small manufacturer, like Morgan, it's hard to escape the heavy hand of regulation.
Out of interest, what regulations are Morgan exempted from following?
Mandatory crash testing?

FiF

49,021 posts

282 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I think they are trying to rationalise the ranges / body styles.

The 3 box saloon is decreasing in popularity.
Hatchbacks only work in small car sectors, eg mini, supermini etc.
If somebody wants a larger hatchback then generally they go for an estate, but some don't like the big boxy wagon style.
Make the rear a bit less vertical / boxy and you can cover those who want an estate, a big hatchback, and those who want something large that isn't an SUV or full on 4x4 don't have anywhere else to go as 3 box saloons there's not much choice these days.
Increase the ride height a bit and you get folks who need a tad more ground clearance / easier to get in and out, maybe, but who actually don't want an SuV / 4x4.

Personally I think it's a good path to take.


NMNeil

5,860 posts

81 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
RDMcG said:
I saw these pics on a single page and it struck me how homogenized we have become. When I was a kid a Cadillac was a huge American boat and an Audi was a VW sub brand and a bit anonymous, but very European.Of course the Caddy and Audi are different, but I hope we do not go down a path of decreasing individuality.

Now:



What I like about the Lyriq is that it doesn't have a TV screen taking over the whole dashboard.
But on the down side, gimmicky dancing lights ????
https://www.cadillac.com/electric/lyriq

swisstoni

24,245 posts

310 months

Friday 18th March 2022
quotequote all
I’m optimistic that electric cars will eventually be allowed to attain shapes that do not ape the shapes that ice cars have taken for so long.

NDA

25,831 posts

256 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
gazza285 said:
NMNeil said:
NDA said:
I guess it's the shape of 'regulations'. Unless you are a very small manufacturer, like Morgan, it's hard to escape the heavy hand of regulation.
Out of interest, what regulations are Morgan exempted from following?
Mandatory crash testing?
Pedestrian safety regulations, for example, create specific rules that have changed car design. Low volume manufacturers are often exempt from some of the rules.

mikey_b

2,741 posts

76 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
NMNeil said:
What I like about the Lyriq is that it doesn't have a TV screen taking over the whole dashboard.
https://www.cadillac.com/electric/lyriq
Really? It might not be a Tesla-style vertical screen, but it sure has a massive LED panel:

GT9

9,104 posts

203 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
FiF said:
I think they are trying to rationalise the ranges / body styles.

The 3 box saloon is decreasing in popularity.
Hatchbacks only work in small car sectors, eg mini, supermini etc.
If somebody wants a larger hatchback then generally they go for an estate, but some don't like the big boxy wagon style.
Make the rear a bit less vertical / boxy and you can cover those who want an estate, a big hatchback, and those who want something large that isn't an SUV or full on 4x4 don't have anywhere else to go as 3 box saloons there's not much choice these days.
Increase the ride height a bit and you get folks who need a tad more ground clearance / easier to get in and out, maybe, but who actually don't want an SuV / 4x4.

Personally I think it's a good path to take.
Every single EV car designer is constrained by pretty much the same thing, how to make the car go further on a tiny amount of energy. Even 100 kWh is tiny compared to the 500 kWh or more that would have been in the tank of the equivalent ICE, let along the 50 kWh or so that is typical for many EVs.

The constraint is aerodynamics, not weight. The energy consumed by the weight of the car is largely recovered, whereas the drag losses are not. Adding weight to increase range is worthwhile, up to a point of course, but after that, you're left with the task of maximising range from whatever energy you can afford to store onboard.

So first and foremost, the design needs to have the lowest possible drag coefficient, and the lowest possible front area.

The long estate body with tapering roofline is about the best you are going to get for low drag and high internal volume, almost like a bullet train, if you like. One you've punched the smallest possible hole in the air, it makes sense to put as much car behind that hole as possible.

To minimise Cd, the trailing end of the car needs to be shaped to avoid rapid separation of the air, which is why the roofline is tapered and why the diffuser ducts underneath are quite prominent. It's not perfect, but it's far better than the bluff end you might typically see on an ICE estate. The other important elements for reducing drag for all EVs are closing off as many air apertures as possible, maximising the closed area of the wheel rims as seen from the outside and slimming down the mirrors.

In the post ICE scenario, until we get to the point where passenger EVs can carry a couple of hundred kWh of renewable energy, we are essentially stuck with trying to find the best combination of aero efficiency, ubiquitous access to recharging and, dare I say it, driving slower.

Edited by GT9 on Saturday 19th March 13:39