Irrational things?
Author
Discussion

TheAngryDog

Original Poster:

13,315 posts

240 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Does anyone else do the same as this, or is it just me?

I won't buy a car that isn't HPI clear (I did once and it was a complete shed).

I won't buy a small car because I'd hate to take it on long motorway journeys. I've done it before, and I'll be doing it on Friday, but that will be me driving my wife's car. It's not something I would want to do regularly, so I have often bought larger cars. By small, I mean Twingo, Fiesta, Corsa, etc. I used to own a J reg Astra 1.7D (68 rampant stallions) but that was in the early 2000s, and felt an adequate size then. I prefer the bigger cars due to comfort and I feel safer in larger cars.

It's not just me, surely?

texaxile

3,819 posts

181 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
Not just you, it's partly about getting a motor to suit your needs while fitting some criteria.

For example I won't touch a car with over 100k miles or with more than a couple of minor MOT fails. I'd never touch a Cat Car or one which isn't HPI clear, even if it was to be used as a shed.

I make very few long journeys, maybe one a year so a small car wouldn't bother me, but if it was more regular then like yourself I'd need something with a bit of comfort.

Such are the joys of motoring.

valiant

14,344 posts

191 months

Saturday 19th March 2022
quotequote all
A modern Corsa is probably almost as big as an Astra of yesteryear and are perfectly adequate for long boring motorway journeys.

Did 200 miles in a hire Corsa a few months ago and it wasn’t an issue. It was no ball of fire but kept upto (and exceeded hehe) motorway speeds without a problem and never felt strained.

You are being a wee bit irrational.

Cold

16,747 posts

121 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
valiant said:
You are being a wee bit irrational.
/Checks thread title/ biggrin

Disastrous

10,218 posts

248 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
texaxile said:
For example I won't touch a car with over 100k miles
My in-laws are Bavarian and my FiL also has that ‘thing’ about 100k. Only I realised he was talking about km.

Moving a car on arbitrarily at 62k miles seemed crazy which made me think the whole 100k thing seemed a bit silly.

donkmeister

13,142 posts

131 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
TBH I think the most irrational thing, and surprisingly common, is people who refuse to buy/lease certain brands of car without regard for the car itself. I don't mean people who have decided they want a particular car, I get that, I mean the people who are full-on dead against an entire brand. Usually having never driven a car of that brand.

It seems like the equivalent of meeting the girl of your dreams, then sacking her off because she comes from a country that you have never visited, but Jeremy Clarkson slagged off once.

randomeddy

1,633 posts

168 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
Other than many years ago when I first started driving I have never had any interest in buying a Ford of any description.
Is that irrational?

QBee

22,547 posts

175 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
randomeddy said:
Other than many years ago when I first started driving I have never had any interest in buying a Ford of any description.
Is that irrational?
Yes and no.
Yes of course it is, but the only two (of the same model) I ever bought were the american Ford Explorer, and frankly they weren't good.

I have the same problem with BMWs - the only one I have even driven in the past was a 320 auto back in 1984, and to be fair to it, it got me into autos.
More recently I drove a hybrid 5 series from Shorpe to Cambridge for client. Perfectly nice car in side and to cruise on a motorway.
But I have never owned one and don't want to be thought of as one of those cocks who drives one.
Came past my local pub yesterday afternoon. It's right on a difficult main road junction where there are frequent accidents, and it has no car park.
So the council painted double yellow lines around the junction. Guess what make of car was parked on those double yellow lines, half on the pavement right outside the pub door? Got it in one.

QBee

22,547 posts

175 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
Sorry, but it makes me laugh how PH lets you type "cocks" but not "Shorpe" getmecoat

Rockets7

476 posts

161 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
I wont buy a car or bike if the plate adds up to 13..... and no chassis numbers that have 666 in them. Had an RVF400 once with the last three of the chassis sporting 666, I was seriously ill throughout the ownership with some major issues. Coincidence....probably!

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
TheAngryDog said:
Does anyone else do the same as this, or is it just me?

I won't buy a car that isn't HPI clear (I did once and it was a complete shed).

I won't buy a small car because I'd hate to take it on long motorway journeys. I've done it before, and I'll be doing it on Friday, but that will be me driving my wife's car. It's not something I would want to do regularly, so I have often bought larger cars. By small, I mean Twingo, Fiesta, Corsa, etc. I used to own a J reg Astra 1.7D (68 rampant stallions) but that was in the early 2000s, and felt an adequate size then. I prefer the bigger cars due to comfort and I feel safer in larger cars.

It's not just me, surely?
Surely neither of those things are irrational?

Roger Irrelevant

3,400 posts

144 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
texaxile said:
I'd never touch a Cat Car or one which isn't HPI clear, even if it was to be used as a shed.
This doesn't seem all that irrational particularly if it's something run-of-the-mill. Mind you I was recently told that I was being silly for ruling out a common old shed because it had it's EML light on (and was also advertised as a 'trade sale'), so maybe I'm a bit of a wuss.

For something really irrational - if I unlock my car when I'm right next to it, I always wait for the mirrors to fully unfold before opening the door. There is no reason whatsoever to do this.

Crumpet

5,507 posts

211 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
I don’t think any of those things are irrational. You’re just buying a car that meets your requirements.

Only one thing for me; I’d never, ever own another four cylinder engine. I just don’t like them. Hateful things.

Actually, two things; I’d be reluctant to buy a front wheel drive car again. Again, I just don’t like them.

Oh, and I’d never buy a car without a central arm rest.

That being said, I’d happily buy a little three-cylinder, FWD runaround without a central arm rest!

x5tuu

12,793 posts

218 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
I have the 100k mile limit

I used to refuse to have anything with more than 3 doors

Both irrational, was was overcame through need the other I just can’t break through at all - it’s weird

psi310398

11,146 posts

234 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
randomeddy said:
Other than many years ago when I first started driving I have never had any interest in buying a Ford of any description.
Is that irrational?
My parents owned Fords of various descriptions throughout the 60s, 70s and into the 80s. They never could start consistently in the cold and/or wet. But I suspect electronic ignition and fuel injection had made that a problem of the past at least three decades ago.

So it is probably completely irrational that I have never even contemplated owning one during my adult life (except for the red Escort Ghia my mother passed on to me in the mid-80s that I chopped in pronto for an Alfa Sud grotbox that was mechanically, physically and electrically more suspect in every waysmile).

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
Small cars are exhausting on the motorway. Once I drove a Ford Ka from Reading to London. Felt absolutely knackered at the end of it. So loud and so pointy. It drove like a go cart which was its undoing if you just wanted to go straight for long periods of time. Really fun in B roads and around town though.

Longer wheelbase cars are definitely more stable and planted at speed, but large cars are a pig to drive around Victorian roads in Central London, and make it hard to find on street parking. The majority of UK cars are Fiesta or Focus size and therefore parking spots are too.

Found Golf size cars the best compromise. Stable enough on the motorway, small enough to thread through tight spots in town.

Only last week, there was a small space between double parked cars. Had to reverse up the road to let a BMW X3 ahead of me back out. I drove straight back up and drove through the gap.

Court_S

14,828 posts

208 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
QBee said:
Sorry, but it makes me laugh how PH lets you type "cocks" but not "Shorpe" getmecoat
We did a project for a company in Shorpe and we had to refer to it as Scunny in emails otherwise the clients email filter would block it.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
wyson said:
Small cars are exhausting on the motorway. Once I drove a Ford Ka from Reading to London. Felt absolutely knackered at the end of it. So loud and so pointy. It drove like a go cart which was its undoing if you just wanted to go straight for long periods of time. Really fun in B roads and around town though.

Longer wheelbase cars are definitely more stable and planted at speed, but large cars are a pig to drive around Victorian roads in Central London, and make it hard to find on street parking. The majority of UK cars are Fiesta or Focus size and therefore parking spots are too.

Found Golf size cars the best compromise. Stable enough on the motorway, small enough to thread through tight spots in town.

Only last week, there was a small space between double parked cars. Had to reverse up the road to let a BMW X3 ahead of me back out. I drove straight back up and drove through the gap.
I have found you just adjust your expectations and driving style. Tens of thousands of miles in Cinquecentos,Smart cars, Ka, Classic Beetles etc, always arrive with a smile on my face!

wiliferus

4,225 posts

229 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
I’m with you on the ‘big car’ thing. I just don’t like small cars. Maybe it’s a wheel base thing - I prefer the ride and comfort of a larger car and they feel more secure and safe. All perception of course as my current car is a 15 year old 200k mile Volvo V70. I’m sure a brand new Focus is probably just as quiet and just as safe as technology advances.
I do have kids as thus a need for a bigger car, but even in the future I can’t see me ending up in a super mini type car. The other half had a Mini Cooper and insisted we drive that on a 4 hour road trip as opposed to my Volvo. It was a torturous, noisy, underpowered, stiffly sprung journey. My soggy old Volvo would have wafted us there in comfort.

anonymous-user

85 months

Sunday 20th March 2022
quotequote all
wiliferus said:
I’m with you on the ‘big car’ thing. I just don’t like small cars. Maybe it’s a wheel base thing - I prefer the ride and comfort of a larger car and they feel more secure and safe. All perception of course as my current car is a 15 year old 200k mile Volvo V70. I’m sure a brand new Focus is probably just as quiet and just as safe as technology advances.
I do have kids as thus a need for a bigger car, but even in the future I can’t see me ending up in a super mini type car. The other half had a Mini Cooper and insisted we drive that on a 4 hour road trip as opposed to my Volvo. It was a torturous, noisy, underpowered, stiffly sprung journey. My soggy old Volvo would have wafted us there in comfort.
I've put 40k miles on my Mini One D, zero issues, brilliant driving position, love it!!