Breakdown cover be one off tow?
Breakdown cover be one off tow?
Author
Discussion

CarDoodle

Original Poster:

71 posts

71 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Not sure this is for GG but can’t see a better fit! I’ve never used breakdown cover so might be silly questions, but…

My car has broken down on the drive with a snapped gear cable. The local garage will fit supply and fit a replacement.

They’ve quoted about £45 to recover the car. Is there any better alternative such as joining a breakdown service and getting recovered to the garage? It looks like it would cost a small amount more than a one off lift, but it would then cover for any other issues.

I would assume AA/RAC or other wouldn’t attempt to fix that for me on the drive, particularly if a known issue?

vikingaero

13,578 posts

200 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
If you can wait 24hours after joining before calling them out, then you're have the benefit of a years breakdown cover.

With the AA/RAC, you can join at full rates and get immediate cover. I do advise you to buy via Quidco/TopCashBack if you choose this route, so you can halve your cost of breakdown.

Hol

9,316 posts

231 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
When looking, be aware that some providers may charge more for home recovery, over the standard roadside recovery. AA certainly do/did.

Have you considered a mobile mechanic to attend and fit the cable on your driveway?
The labour time may be higher, due to the lack of a ramp, but their overheads and per hour rates are cheaper.

georgeyboy12345

4,669 posts

66 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
I’d just pay the £45 recovery to the garage. That’s cheap. Breakdown cover is a waste of money.

rxe

6,700 posts

134 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
How far to the garage?

Put the car in second on the box (at lot of the mechanisms are accessible) and just drive it there.

SteveR1979

601 posts

172 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Are you ready moaning over £45??

CarDoodle

Original Poster:

71 posts

71 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Thanks for the responses.

Not moaning on the £45, actually a bit less than I was expecting to be honest. Just trying to work out if for similar cost I could get full cover.

Would AA/RAC recover it to the garage or would they try and fix it first? Not sure if it’s acceptable practice to have the garage booked in with part ordered then call the AA to recover it. Never had cover before.

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Indeed. It’s called gambling. I’m firmly in the camp of breakdown cover is a waste of money (despite having it automatically through my bank account). I don’t drive sheds and I’ve needed a breakdown service once in 35 years of driving. The money I’ve saved would now afford me a tow to some nicely exotic places, should I want.

Sir Bagalot

7,114 posts

212 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
georgeyboy12345 said:
Breakdown cover is a waste of money.
Totally 100% agree.

Until you need it that is, then it's invaluable.

jamieduff1981

8,092 posts

171 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
The money one could save by jettisoning expensive newish depreciating cars could pay for breakdown cover and leave many thousands spare smile

Nigel Worc's

8,121 posts

219 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
georgeyboy12345 said:
I’d just pay the £45 recovery to the garage. That’s cheap. Breakdown cover is a waste of money.
I disagree , my motorcycle broke down last year in the middle of Wales, they recovered the bike and put me in a Taxi back to Droitwich.......how much would that've cost ?

ghost83

5,660 posts

221 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Check to see if you get breakdown cover as part of your bank account?

I didn’t realise I had it but used it a few times now!

My NatWest account uses green flag and they’ve being brilliant every time

trevalvole

2,095 posts

64 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
You usually only get home-start as part of the higher-priced packages.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
Nigel Worc's said:
I disagree , my motorcycle broke down last year in the middle of Wales, they recovered the bike and put me in a Taxi back to Droitwich.......how much would that've cost ?
Obviously, less than all the premiums they are expecting you to have paid over the years. Because that's how insurance works.

Chubbyross

5,017 posts

116 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Nope, nope and, again, nope.

georgeyboy12345

4,669 posts

66 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
I stopped paying for breakdown cover 10 years ago. In that time I must have covered well over 80,000 miles in the various cars I have owned in that period. I have needed to use breakdown recovery twice. The first time it cost nothing as it happened after a cambelt change on my mx-5 - the cam position sensor hadn’t been securely attached by the garage, so they recovered it 10 miles. The second time was last year when I got a puncture in the middle of town and the stupid puncture repair kit didn’t work. That cost me £70. So that works out at £7 a year. Glad it didn’t happen the day before though when I was in the middle of the lake district! Though i doubt someone like the AA or RAC wouldn’t have been much use there either, I would have been waiting hours. I would have rang a local garage and had my car recovered to them for a new tyre.

deckster

9,631 posts

286 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
"Expecting" being the keyword. On average, people pay in less than they get out. This is an absolute and very obvious statement.

Which is why it's only worth insuring against losses that you can't reasonably bear yourself; the risk of a £37k household claim is a good reason to insure your house, and paying a few hundred quid to protect myself against the risk that I smash my car into a Chiron is also common sense.

But paying out a couple of hundred quid a year on the offchance I need a tow somewhere? Not such an obvious equation.


grumbas

1,178 posts

222 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
To answer the original question - you've already broken down, so you're asking if it's ok to make a fraudulent insurance claim? £45 for a tow is cheap as chips.

As for whether breakdown cover is worth it, very much depends on your circumstances.

Regularly travel alone, rarely more than 20-30 miles from home, possibly worth self-insuring.

Regularly travel with the family further from home, for the £50 odd it costs (there are numerous providers around this price point or less, but they won't have orange or yellow vans) and it's invaluable to save the ear ache and/or stress.

paulrockliffe

16,668 posts

258 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
But if you break down you can just call the people that Green Flag etc will call and pay the money then rather than in advance whether you need it or not.

vikingaero

13,578 posts

200 months

Tuesday 22nd March 2022
quotequote all
grumbas said:
To answer the original question - you've already broken down, so you're asking if it's ok to make a fraudulent insurance claim?
No! The AA/RAC (and possibly other providers) allow you to take out cover if you've already broken down. You obviously have to pay the full years premium up front, then you get rescued, and you have cover for the rest of the year.