MOT advisory dispute
Author
Discussion

EssexPorsche

Original Poster:

176 posts

204 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
From viewing the .gov MOT test results I can see my BMW Z4 has passed but with a few advisories. I haven’t received a call from the garage doing it (a BMW specialist) as it’s also having some other work completed and I assume this hasn’t been done yet… Either way, I was keen to know so checked the site.

I’ve noted that the advisories include: Nearside Rear Wheel bearing slightly noisy. This was also present on the past MOT. So in July 2021 - a whoppping 800miles ago - I took it to a different BMW specialist who fitted two new rear wheel bearings. They used genuine BMW bearings and are a well-respected garage.

I’m a little stumped… I rang the garage who fitted the bearings to get their opinion and they of course said they’d need to see it to comment but they can see no reason why it would have been noted on an MOT. I’m yet to speak to the place who’ve done the MOT but want to get a gauge as to how to approach them before I do.

As I’m about to list the car for sale, I’d rather not have an advisory like this on the MOT history if it’s not legitimate. If the garage do admit a mistake, are they physically able to amend an MOT advisory list once it’s been published?

Thanks in advance.

Edited by EssexPorsche on Wednesday 23 March 18:45

Dynion Araf Uchaf

5,202 posts

254 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
MOT testers have a habit of reading the prior test history and then just repeating it. you could have told him about the replacement bearings but it sounds like a right lazy tester.

don't think they can be amended unless you ask them to do another test.

Panamax

10,111 posts

65 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Don't waste your time and effort. Just get another MOT done by somebody who knows what they're doing. And if it turns out your newish wheel bearings are dodgy you'll have learnt not to use that garage again.


thebraketester

15,843 posts

169 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
It’s easy to prove to someone/a prospective buyer that a wheel bearing isn’t fked so I wouldn’t worry about it.

Sheepshanks

41,371 posts

150 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
The Merc indie I use MOT'd my car then before he finished the test he went and looked up the previous MOT to make sure he hadn't missed anything.

I asked 'aren't you supposed to test as presented?' and he got quite defensive. He always give it a very extensive list of advisories so I suppose he might think it would look bad (for him as a tester) if one or more disappeared.

CraigyMc

18,374 posts

267 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Dynion Araf Uchaf said:
MOT testers have a habit of reading the prior test history and then just repeating it. you could have told him about the replacement bearings but it sounds like a right lazy tester.

don't think they can be amended unless you ask them to do another test.
DVSA can remove incorrect/failed MOT results. I've had it done for an "aborted test" when the tester couldn't safely jack my car. It no longer shows on the vehicle's history.

EssexPorsche

Original Poster:

176 posts

204 months

Wednesday 23rd March 2022
quotequote all
Mmh, thanks all! Seems like a frustrating one that I’ll just have to accept and move on from in that case. I’m not very excited about the idea of spending another £50 odd quid on another test and having to go through the hassle of getting it booked in elsewhere etc…

Woulda thought that conducting an MOT should be, by it’s nature, a simple, black & white tick box exercise!