RE: BMW M240i xDrive | PH Video
RE: BMW M240i xDrive | PH Video
Thursday 31st March 2022

BMW M240i xDrive | PH Video

The M240i ticks a lot of boxes on paper. Find out how it does on film...


 

It's a common problem. You've grown up, possibly without realising it, and progressed far enough along the journey of life to find yourself with a blossoming family. And that brings all kinds of joy, of course - but at the same time some predictable limitations. More often than not, the kind of car you buy must reflect the growing numbers at the dinner table. Unless you're wealthy enough to have a fleet - and probably a nanny on tap to give you the breathing space to enjoy trips out in two-seaters - the pressure to compromise on driving pleasure and chase practicality is inevitable.

So, if the time with your Porsche Cayman or Alpine A110 has run its course, but your desire to drive something exciting and pleasurable hasn't, what choice do you have? If your available funds are around £45,000, we'd argue the new BMW M240i xDrive is a worthy contender. It's based not on the 1 Series and 2 Series Gran Coupé platform (which is predominately front-wheel drive) but on the CLAR platform that underpins the current BMW 4 Series. What you get, then, is the same longitudinally-mounted B58 3.0-litre straight-six as the M440i xDrive, right down to the available power output of 374hp. That, for the record, is more than a Cayman S.

If you're thinking that's all well and good but the M240i's xDrive drivetrain will be neutering the fun, you might be surprised. Sure, it isn't going to emulate the dexterity of a rear-wheel-drive mid-engined car, but all that power and its considerable torque (369lb ft) is sent rearwards as a rule. It's only when the rear tyres run out of ideas that the M240i will call upon its front axle to dig you out, which means the potential for fun remains. And while the extra components add 205kg to the car's mass - which stands at a considerable 1,765kg - like the latest M3 and M4, the M240i xDrive has an uncanny ability to disguise its portliness well.

It's also refined and easygoing when you're not barrelling around and, crucially, has the selling points of four useable seats and a generous boot. Is it the answer to your prayers, then? Watch our latest video to find out, and don't forget to like and subscribe to the PistonHeads channel to get alerts for all our forthcoming content.


 

Author
Discussion

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Does the all wheel drive components genuinely add 200kg? I thought Porsche's only added around 50kg to the weight of a 911 so it's a marked difference between the two solutions.

Chunkychucky

6,094 posts

200 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
1765kg... a fking E39 M5 weighed less than 1800kg rofl

Water Fairy

6,658 posts

186 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Harrypop said:
Does the all wheel drive components genuinely add 200kg? I thought Porsche's only added around 50kg to the weight of a 911 so it's a marked difference between the two solutions.
This. I thought VWs haldex only added around 50kgs.

thecremeegg

2,100 posts

234 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Chunkychucky said:
1765kg... a fking E39 M5 weighed less than 1800kg rofl
Similar sized cars surely?

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Water Fairy said:
Harrypop said:
Does the all wheel drive components genuinely add 200kg? I thought Porsche's only added around 50kg to the weight of a 911 so it's a marked difference between the two solutions.
This. I thought VWs haldex only added around 50kgs.
For a 200kg penalty I'd be expecting a relatively complex hybrid based all wheel drive system with the batteries and motors.

Filibuster

3,407 posts

246 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
4 posts and all are about the weight. Come on, with all the creature comforts and safety features, cars will weight more than they did 20 years ago.
I love a fairly light, manual sports car just as much as everybody on PH, in fact I own one!

But the simple fact is that 99% of buyers of an M240i X don't care about the weight. And to be honest, most people, me included, can't tell the difference in normal day to day driving. And this makes up for 99% of driving time. To be brutally honest, who doesn't want to be in comfort and safety while sitting in a traffic jam on the M3?

ScoobyChris

2,307 posts

233 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Filibuster said:
who doesn't want to be in comfort and safety while sitting in a traffic jam on the M3?
Funnily enough, I encountered one of these last Sunday on the M3 (not in a traffic jam). Performance seems broadly similar to my M140i and it looks very smart in the flesh. Need to wangle a good test drive in one and see if it's worth trading up!

Chris

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Filibuster said:
4 posts and all are about the weight. Come on, with all the creature comforts and safety features, cars will weight more than they did 20 years ago.
I love a fairly light, manual sports car just as much as everybody on PH, in fact I own one!

But the simple fact is that 99% of buyers of an M240i X don't care about the weight. And to be honest, most people, me included, can't tell the difference in normal day to day driving. And this makes up for 99% of driving time. To be brutally honest, who doesn't want to be in comfort and safety while sitting in a traffic jam on the M3?
If you can appreciate the specifics of some of the posts you are referring to though none of what you have countered with is remotely relevant to the content within them.


Edited by Harrypop on Thursday 31st March 16:50

Olivera

8,843 posts

270 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Harrypop said:
Does the all wheel drive components genuinely add 200kg? I thought Porsche's only added around 50kg to the weight of a 911 so it's a marked difference between the two solutions.
There's absolutely no way that the 4wd system added anywhere close to 200kg. For comparison the M2 Competition DCT was 1650kg: https://www.bmw.co.uk/en/all-models/m-models/m2-co...

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Does anybody know who the reviewer is? Quite an enjoyable video. I don't recognise him personally and I'm guessing that he isn't called PH Staff!

loudlashadjuster

6,552 posts

215 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Harrypop said:
Does anybody know who the reviewer is? Quite an enjoyable video. I don't recognise him personally and I'm guessing that he isn't called PH Staff!
John Howell. It was at the end of the video.

I agree though, much more engaging than some PH vids. Someone at PH has been looking enviously at Carwow's YouTube stats... biggrin

Dan43

9 posts

56 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Is it just me that winces at a £45k price tag. If I had £45k to spend I would be looking at a 2-3 year old M2 or M3 not a brand new mid range sports car.

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
loudlashadjuster said:
John Howell. It was at the end of the video.

I agree though, much more engaging than some PH vids. Someone at PH has been looking enviously at Carwow's YouTube stats... biggrin
Doh, should have thought of that! I went to the trouble of seeing if it was mentioned in the Youtube details but didn't do the bleeding obvious! Good to put a face to a name though, I prefer John's written content to many others.

Filibuster

3,407 posts

246 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Harrypop said:
Filibuster said:
4 posts and all are about the weight. Come on, with all the creature comforts and safety features, cars will weight more than they did 20 years ago.
I love a fairly light, manual sports car just as much as everybody on PH, in fact I own one!

But the simple fact is that 99% of buyers of an M240i X don't care about the weight. And to be honest, most people, me included, can't tell the difference in normal day to day driving. And this makes up for 99% of driving time. To be brutally honest, who doesn't want to be in comfort and safety while sitting in a traffic jam on the M3?
If you can appreciate the specifics of some of the posts you are referring to though none of what you have countered with is remotely relevant to the content within them.


Edited by Harrypop on Thursday 31st March 16:50
You are right. Let me word it differently:

This, imho, is the best looking BMW in a long time. Absolutely lovely looking in fact! Love the launch colour too!
Probably a cracking daily driver and one of the nicest car to live in day to day. Yes it is heavy, but so what. I doubt a 300kg lighter M240i xDrive would be a better road car!

Again, not commenting on the 200kg 4x4 drivetrain statement, which probably is wrong.

What I was trying to denounce, was that no post so far, mine included, was about how great this car looks (again, imho) or what a cracking real world, small but practical 4 seat coupe/2 door limousine it is!

resolve10

1,264 posts

76 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Dan43 said:
Is it just me that winces at a £45k price tag. If I had £45k to spend I would be looking at a 2-3 year old M2 or M3 not a brand new mid range sports car.
Just the 'new normal', as much as I hate that phrase. The next-gen M2 will most likely be a £60k car.

The only reason people could get into a previous-gen M135/140/235/240i for such low prices was because BMW were churning them out like there was no tomorrow. Go to a dealer today and order a new M240i and you're probably looking at a 9 month wait.

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Dan43 said:
Is it just me that winces at a £45k price tag. If I had £45k to spend I would be looking at a 2-3 year old M2 or M3 not a brand new mid range sports car.
But this will be for those who are looking at purchasing a brand new car with the option for monthly payments if they desire though so the asking price isn't always going to be the absolute consideration, nor will be the second hand market.

British Beef

2,573 posts

196 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all

In summary:

- Looks like st

- Goes like st of a shovel

- Expensive and heavy

Harrypop

Original Poster:

2,611 posts

153 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Filibuster said:
You are right. Let me word it differently:

This, imho, is the best looking BMW in a long time. Absolutely lovely looking in fact! Love the launch colour too!
Probably a cracking daily driver and one of the nicest car to live in day to day. Yes it is heavy, but so what. I doubt a 300kg lighter M240i xDrive would be a better road car!

Again, not commenting on the 200kg 4x4 drivetrain statement, which probably is wrong.

What I was trying to denounce, was that no post so far, mine included, was about how great this car looks (again, imho) or what a cracking real world, small but practical 4 seat coupe/2 door limousine it is!
I don't disagree with the majority of what you have posted although I'd wager that taking 300kg out of any road car, without compromises, would give the engineers a better chance of producing a superior product if they had the opportunity to. Regardless of it's weight, and how this is proportioned, I would fully expect this car to be more than adequate for most people's needs, assuming that a coupe fulfils them in the first place of course. I don't think that it is stunning personally but there's nothing really offensives about it either and I definitely think that this segment is the size of car I'd want to be considering - things have got mahoosive lately!

Nik Gnashers

945 posts

187 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
I really like it.

Yes it's a bit heavy but so is everything nowadays.
Yes it's expensive but so is everything nowadays.

I don't think it's as good looking as the outgoing M240i but it isn't ugly in the same way the M4 is. The lights front & rear look a bit too small, and the body lines don't match up with the places they should do, in order to create flow and a uniform over all appearance, but it's not 'terrible'.

I can't see why it won't sell by the shedload, although xDrive doesn't interest me personally as I prefer RWD, it will probably actually sell to a wider market than the current outgoing M240i, as the majority of buyers will probably see AWD as a bonus, and lets be honest only a minority actually want to feel the rear end moving around.

Not for me, but a pretty decent offering compared to some other models in the BMW line up.

Water Fairy

6,658 posts

186 months

Thursday 31st March 2022
quotequote all
Filibuster said:
4 posts and all are about the weight. Come on, with all the creature comforts and safety features, cars will weight more than they did 20 years ago.
I love a fairly light, manual sports car just as much as everybody on PH, in fact I own one!

But the simple fact is that 99% of buyers of an M240i X don't care about the weight. And to be honest, most people, me included, can't tell the difference in normal day to day driving. And this makes up for 99% of driving time. To be brutally honest, who doesn't want to be in comfort and safety while sitting in a traffic jam on the M3?
To be fair we were discussing the weight added by the 4wd system