The sound of a Lada door shutting...
The sound of a Lada door shutting...
Author
Discussion

iano

Original Poster:

104 posts

264 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
Picture the scene - Me and the girlfriend zooming through the twisty country lanes on a sunny afternoon in the 993. Glorious flat 6 barking behind us and sublime handling through every corner. We arrive at our destination, hop out of the car and shut the door which sounds like a cheap Lada!!

Is it just mine or do all 993 doors sound like cheap russian motors?

If this is a general shortfall can it be fixed?

I am tired of friends getting out of the car with a big smile after a ride and then apologising when they close the door, as if they have broken it.

993_2s

216 posts

253 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
They sound fine mate. They should sound like a proper clunk - reflecting the solid build quality they are. Have you got a check-strap broken??

iano

Original Poster:

104 posts

264 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
That may be the problem then.

They never sound as solid and with a 'thunk' as my BM doors.

Thanks for the advice

silver993tt

9,064 posts

266 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
iano said:
That may be the problem then.

They never sound as solid and with a 'thunk' as my BM doors.

Thanks for the advice



There is your problem - or not. The 'thunk' on BMW, VW etc happens because there is a thick rubber sealing strip around the door. It not due to engineering! The 993 has it right, sealing strip but also well engineered catch mechaism which you can hear.

I personally hate the 'thunk' on modern cars, it sounds cheap to me and a cover up for cheap door locks/catches.

993 sounds MUCH nicer IMHO.

>> Edited by silver993tt on Thursday 4th August 08:57

993_2s

216 posts

253 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
It's a very common fault unfortunately. Do both door sound the same? Take the car to Porsche or at the very least a Porsche familiar bodyshop. The proper repair is a little involved so the chaps need to know what they are doing.

iano

Original Poster:

104 posts

264 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
If that is how it is supposed to sound due to the way it is engineered I will happily live with it.

Never ceases to amaze me what a quality product the 993 is. I thought I had found it's achilles heal with the door and it turns out that is just better engineering than normal cars as well.

Ian

leosayer

7,767 posts

271 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
The sound of most modern car doors shutting these days is engineered to sound 'solid' so that the buyer thinks they have bought a solid, quality product. There's nothing natural about it.

Do you really want to be fooled in this way?

iano

Original Poster:

104 posts

264 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
Next you will be telling me that the dash is not made of real tropical rainforest!

david hype

2,296 posts

279 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
Trust me...Its the best sounding door shut noise ever made! And it stopped for ever in 1996!

RIP Real quality door shut sounds...

verysideways

10,268 posts

299 months

Thursday 4th August 2005
quotequote all
[quote=david hype]Trust me...Its the best sounding door shut noise ever made! And it stopped for ever in 1996! quote]

Oi, 1998!!!

phelix

4,666 posts

276 months

Friday 5th August 2005
quotequote all
That door sound has been the same for years in the 911. It's special; enjoy it!