Crossrail 24th may 2022 is a rare win for the uk public
Crossrail 24th may 2022 is a rare win for the uk public
Author
Discussion

Fundoreen

Original Poster:

4,180 posts

106 months

Thursday 5th May 2022
quotequote all
Someone explain this st.
Crossrail cost approx 18 billion. Its a marvel of engineering and complexity.
Government Track and trace app development and operation. More than 18 billion easy.
What the fk is it? Your humble mobile contains all the sensors already. They no doubt adapted existing apps off the shelf that make use of the telemetry in a phone.
Even if there were hundreds of developers were they paying them 100 million each?
What a bunch of st.
Thank fk we got the trains and tunnels before these crooks spunked all the money on some other invisible effort.

poo at Paul's

14,546 posts

198 months

Thursday 5th May 2022
quotequote all
Mentalist

tangerine_sedge

6,173 posts

241 months

Thursday 5th May 2022
quotequote all
Fundoreen said:
Someone explain this st.
Crossrail cost approx 18 billion. Its a marvel of engineering and complexity.
Government Track and trace app development and operation. More than 18 billion easy.
What the fk is it? Your humble mobile contains all the sensors already. They no doubt adapted existing apps off the shelf that make use of the telemetry in a phone.
Even if there were hundreds of developers were they paying them 100 million each?
What a bunch of st.
Thank fk we got the trains and tunnels before these crooks spunked all the money on some other invisible effort.
Remember kids - don't drink and post!

faa77

1,728 posts

94 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
It's a good point though, each mobile runs the same software, regardless of number of devices.

Electro1980

8,916 posts

162 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Simple. The test and trace app didn’t cost £18 billion. The test and trace operation did (I’m assuming the number is correct as I haven’t verified it). The app was a tiny fraction of that.

poo at Paul's

14,546 posts

198 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
More people used test and trace than will use cross rail. 18 billion all for what, 3 million people to ever use?
Sounds pricey to me.

anonymous-user

77 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
poo at Paul's said:
More people used test and trace than will use cross rail. 18 billion all for what, 3 million people to ever use?
Sounds pricey to me.
It's overall capacity though. Say 3 million people use crossrail. That's 3 million people NOT using the other lines, buses, roads etc, which has a positive impact on another (say) 10 million people, so a far bigger net gain. Crossrail is a good thing.

poo at Paul's

14,546 posts

198 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
OnTheBreadline said:
poo at Paul's said:
More people used test and trace than will use cross rail. 18 billion all for what, 3 million people to ever use?
Sounds pricey to me.
It's overall capacity though. Say 3 million people use crossrail. That's 3 million people NOT using the other lines, buses, roads etc, which has a positive impact on another (say) 10 million people, so a far bigger net gain. Crossrail is a good thing.
A good thing for who,? The 3 mil that will ever use it, ( and I don’t mean daily, I mean ever) or the 50 million odd who live outside the m25?

Sway

33,522 posts

217 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Electro1980 said:
Simple. The test and trace app didn’t cost £18 billion. The test and trace operation did (I’m assuming the number is correct as I haven’t verified it). The app was a tiny fraction of that.
Exactly this.

In my village, we had a large scale testing centre. It's still renting the land, as they're marshaling the mobile testing booths there as they close other sites.

Absolutely staggering the spend. At least six staff as 'security/traffic directors' 24/7. 30-40 testing staff. Huge amounts of lighting, generators and brand spanking new site fencing (not to mention a billion cones) all on hire for 18 months. The staff were getting paid pretty decent wages too.

It was a tad more than 'an app'.

JagLover

45,924 posts

258 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Sway said:
Exactly this.

In my village, we had a large scale testing centre. It's still renting the land, as they're marshaling the mobile testing booths there as they close other sites.

Absolutely staggering the spend. At least six staff as 'security/traffic directors' 24/7. 30-40 testing staff. Huge amounts of lighting, generators and brand spanking new site fencing (not to mention a billion cones) all on hire for 18 months. The staff were getting paid pretty decent wages too.

It was a tad more than 'an app'.
To say nothing of ramping up laboratory capacity from the ability to run 5K tests a day to a million. Hopefully some of that spending was not wasted and might leave something useful for the future.

snuffy

12,232 posts

307 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
The issue is/was that the media repeated over and over again that the NHS track and trace app cost £37 billion. But they just kept on saying "app".

So everyone now thinks the app on their phone cost said £37 billion. And how can a phone app possibly cost 37 billion sheets? It can't, obviously, but the media never bothered to mention all the rest of it.


Sway

33,522 posts

217 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
JagLover said:
To say nothing of ramping up laboratory capacity from the ability to run 5K tests a day to a million. Hopefully some of that spending was not wasted and might leave something useful for the future.
Yep - plus of course sending hundreds of millions of lateral flow test kits out.

vaud

58,004 posts

178 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Electro1980 said:
Simple. The test and trace app didn’t cost £18 billion. The test and trace operation did (I’m assuming the number is correct as I haven’t verified it). The app was a tiny fraction of that.
Correct.

Fundoreen

Original Poster:

4,180 posts

106 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
So some detail added there.
I dont think crossrail was built by one person though. Anyway its time all the people and venues associated with test and trace were sacked off to save some money.

Tankrizzo

7,916 posts

216 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Fundoreen said:
So some detail added there.
I dont think crossrail was built by one person though. Anyway its time all the people and venues associated with test and trace were sacked off to save some money.
At least you got your wish.

Fundoreen said:
Someone explain this st.

Sway

33,522 posts

217 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Fundoreen said:
So some detail added there.
I dont think crossrail was built by one person though. Anyway its time all the people and venues associated with test and trace were sacked off to save some money.
Who has said CR (or indeed the entire test and trace operation) was built by one person?

Just own that you've been an utter fool, and have had your ignorance corrected.

Most of the people and venues associated with test and trace have been "sacked off". There are some bits, as noted above, it'd be very prudent to retain for the future.

Fundoreen

Original Poster:

4,180 posts

106 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Sway said:
Fundoreen said:
So some detail added there.
I dont think crossrail was built by one person though. Anyway its time all the people and venues associated with test and trace were sacked off to save some money.
Who has said CR (or indeed the entire test and trace operation) was built by one person?

Just own that you've been an utter fool, and have had your ignorance corrected.

Most of the people and venues associated with test and trace have been "sacked off". There are some bits, as noted above, it'd be very prudent to retain for the future.
A vast and complex engineering project would cost 18 billion. Some people hired to stand around in hi viz jackets , sit in an office watching netflix and others stick some samples in some testing machines, and simply look for a yes or no result is not really in the same league, but somehow costs a fortune. I guess some jobs just pay more. The country is doomed because so many do so little to earn their vast crust.
Whats worse is we got the same result as not bothering with any of it. Just some more rich people trousering more cash for doing nothing effective.

Sway

33,522 posts

217 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Fundoreen said:
Sway said:
Fundoreen said:
So some detail added there.
I dont think crossrail was built by one person though. Anyway its time all the people and venues associated with test and trace were sacked off to save some money.
Who has said CR (or indeed the entire test and trace operation) was built by one person?

Just own that you've been an utter fool, and have had your ignorance corrected.

Most of the people and venues associated with test and trace have been "sacked off". There are some bits, as noted above, it'd be very prudent to retain for the future.
A vast and complex engineering project would cost 18 billion. Some people hired to stand around in hi viz jackets , sit in an office watching netflix and others stick some samples in some testing machines, and simply look for a yes or no result is not really in the same league, but somehow costs a fortune. I guess some jobs just pay more. The country is doomed because so many do so little to earn their vast crust.
Whats worse is we got the same result as not bothering with any of it. Just some more rich people trousering more cash for doing nothing effective.
How much do you thinks a couple of hundred million home test kids - used by every school kid and plenty of workers frequently - spun up from scratch in terms of manufacturing and distribution, costs?

We also didn't 'get the same result' in terms of excess deaths. See the WHO analysis put out this week.

Carry on revelling in your ignorance and bile.

Brave Fart

6,501 posts

134 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
snuffy said:
The issue is/was that the media repeated over and over again that the NHS track and trace app cost £37 billion. But they just kept on saying "app".

So everyone now thinks the app on their phone cost said £37 billion. And how can a phone app possibly cost 37 billion sheets? It can't, obviously, but the media never bothered to mention all the rest of it.
AIUI, that £37 billion was the budgeted cost of T&T over two years. The actual spend in year one was around 13.5 billion. Still an eye watering amount, and I don't think the final bill is known yet. But, as others have said, the T&T cost includes all the testing - the last time I looked there had been 510 million test results. The cost of processing those tests must be huge, but mass testing seemed rather popular with the public in my opinion.

Whether the £x billion spent on T&T actually achieved anything is arguable. At least Crossrail leaves a long term piece of infrastructure.

tangerine_sedge

6,173 posts

241 months

Friday 6th May 2022
quotequote all
Sway said:
Carry on revelling in your ignorance and bile.
NP&E would be a dull place if it wasn't for the ignorance and the bile!