Are weather forecasts a waste of airtime?
Are weather forecasts a waste of airtime?
Author
Discussion

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

3,902 posts

90 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Firstly, I'm biased on this because I never watch TV weather forecasts, they just drone on and on and really get on my nerves. They are like white noise. I can go online and within seconds can get a 7 day forecast for anywhere in the country, showing me hour by hour the likely temperature, wind speed and direction, humidity and likelihood of rain etc.
Are TV weather forecasts a waste of air time? Could better use of this time be made for something else? I find t strange that we are still stuck with these archaic presentations, when everyone and their auntie is surely online now. They also provide jumped up people like Ales Beresford to start thinking of themselves as celebrities when in reality, a monkey could do their job (I make an exception for Carol Kirkwood, who is lovely and brilliant, and for some reason, I don't mind watching now and then)

zetec

4,986 posts

273 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
lornemalvo said:
Firstly, I'm biased on this because I never watch TV weather forecasts, they just drone on and on and really get on my nerves. They are like white noise. I can go online and within seconds can get a 7 day forecast for anywhere in the country, showing me hour by hour the likely temperature, wind speed and direction, humidity and likelihood of rain etc.
Are TV weather forecasts a waste of air time? Could better use of this time be made for something else? I find t strange that we are still stuck with these archaic presentations, when everyone and their auntie is surely online now. They also provide jumped up people like Ales Beresford to start thinking of themselves as celebrities when in reality, a monkey could do their job (I make an exception for Carol Kirkwood, who is lovely and brilliant, and for some reason, I don't mind watching now and then)
You could say the same for the news that precedes it too?

As for the weather forecasts, with the super computers of this day and age, surely they could be more accurate? For example today, at 4pm the BBC weather app was showing a 18% chance of a light shower. At 4:15pm there was a monsoon that continued for around 20 minutes.

1000 Miglia

4,875 posts

101 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Soaps are a waste of air time ,I don't watch them but I gather some like them .

normalbloke

8,449 posts

241 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Almost all weather apps, that give an hour by hour forecast, out to 7 days,are tosh. Give me a synoptic chart anyway, and if you’re that keen, take a peek at the rainfall radar and the TAFs.

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

208 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
We're all different.

I flick between two speech radio stations, depending what they do to annoy me.

I'll happily listen to a weather forecast, even the shipping forecast.

I'll change channel in a second if they start talking about sodding sport.

lornemalvo

Original Poster:

3,902 posts

90 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
zetec said:
lornemalvo said:
Firstly, I'm biased on this because I never watch TV weather forecasts, they just drone on and on and really get on my nerves. They are like white noise. I can go online and within seconds can get a 7 day forecast for anywhere in the country, showing me hour by hour the likely temperature, wind speed and direction, humidity and likelihood of rain etc.
Are TV weather forecasts a waste of air time? Could better use of this time be made for something else? I find t strange that we are still stuck with these archaic presentations, when everyone and their auntie is surely online now. They also provide jumped up people like Ales Beresford to start thinking of themselves as celebrities when in reality, a monkey could do their job (I make an exception for Carol Kirkwood, who is lovely and brilliant, and for some reason, I don't mind watching now and then)
You could say the same for the news that precedes it too?

As for the weather forecasts, with the super computers of this day and age, surely they could be more accurate? For example today, at 4pm the BBC weather app was showing a 18% chance of a light shower. At 4:15pm there was a monsoon that continued for around 20 minutes.
I thought someone might suggest that the news is available online. I think the difference is that different channels tend to cover different things, except for the headline news stories, which they all cover, but often from a different angle. For example, I think the news from Ukraine has been very patchy and pretty poor, the best coverage, in my opinion, coming from CNN, by a country mile. There's only one weather forecast (met office) and I think few people need it on TV.

Dolf Stoppard

1,382 posts

144 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
BBC get their weather from Meteogroup, not the Met Office. If people didn’t want the weather I’m pretty sure the TV providers would have picked up on this and dropped it. You don’t like it, but it’s clear lots of people do. Like sport, or entertainment, or a tech story. It’s about a bit of something for everyone.

And lady weather presenters. Mmmmmm

SpeckledJim

32,505 posts

275 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Verasamy.
Tobin.
Kirkwood.



Antony Moxey

10,270 posts

241 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Ever since the Met Office moved to Exeter they’ve been woeful. This week in Cranbrook (three miles from the Met Office HQ) the forecast has been showing between two and five percent chance of showers whilst it’s been lashing down, and on more than one occasion too. FFS look out the fking window once in a while, you might actually get it right for once.

sparkythecat

8,060 posts

277 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Weather forecasts are okay, but do we really need a distracting weather forecaster taking up half the screen and waving their arms about like a magicians assistant ?
Some decent rolling CGI showing the weather development over different terrains would be far better.

Terminator X

19,452 posts

226 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
They can't even get the weather correct tomorrow. All of them a waste of time.

TX.

Terminator X

19,452 posts

226 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
zetec said:
You could say the same for the news that precedes it too?

As for the weather forecasts, with the super computers of this day and age, surely they could be more accurate? For example today, at 4pm the BBC weather app was showing a 18% chance of a light shower. At 4:15pm there was a monsoon that continued for around 20 minutes.
What does 18% chance of a shower actually mean though? 1 in 5 times you won't need a brolly?

TX.

bigmowley

2,477 posts

198 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
The TV and radio forecasts just give a general picture and as far as I can see are reasonably accurate. I concentrate on them when I am going on a long trip or interested in what the weather is doing where the kids live.
However I am in the building business and more often than not we need rapid and accurate local information. For this the TV, radio and phone data is completely useless. It’s rain radar, pressure charts, our local airport met office - who are great, and a good hard look out of the window smile
As ever horses for courses.

anonymous-user

76 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Tomorrows weather will be the same as todays.. is more accurate than weather forecast.
Quite incredible that weather forecasts are invariably rubbish. They change hourly, so not a forecast at all!

anonymous-user

76 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
bigmowley said:
The TV and radio forecasts just give a general picture and as far as I can see are reasonably accurate. I concentrate on them when I am going on a long trip or interested in what the weather is doing where the kids live.
However I am in the building business and more often than not we need rapid and accurate local information. For this the TV, radio and phone data is completely useless. It’s rain radar, pressure charts, our local airport met office - who are great, and a good hard look out of the window smile
As ever horses for courses.
Indeed.

The weather on the tv is for big picture stuff, storms, fronts general changes etc it’s the general nationwide outlook.

For accurate planning then you go onto reliable apps or weather radar pictures etc.


Evoluzione

10,345 posts

265 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Yes.

SuffolkDefender

278 posts

118 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
Always been ste. You get what you’re going to get. I look out the window/open the door before I do anything outside and make my decision ok that. Never use the forecast, don’t have a tv licence anyway.

Whats on Second

732 posts

55 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
i thinks its one of those things that TV and radio channels must do to please the broadcasting authorities.
news bulletins and a weather report, for radio on the hour or half hour.

Channel 4 even manage to give their weather report a leftie slant, nice trick actually.




Evoluzione

10,345 posts

265 months

Tuesday 31st May 2022
quotequote all
SuffolkDefender said:
Never use the forecast, don’t have a tv licence anyway.
You need a TV licence to read a weather forecast? scratchchin

Johnnytheboy

24,499 posts

208 months

Wednesday 1st June 2022
quotequote all
Whats on Second said:


Channel 4 even manage to give their weather report a leftie slant, nice trick actually.



hehe

How's that? Whenever it's warm they say "this is all your fault, you know?"