Jetson flying 'bike'
Author
Discussion

350Matt

Original Poster:

3,848 posts

300 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
I presume you chaps have seen this mad device

https://www.jetsonaero.com/

part of me thinks this is brilliant, but a bigger part is is thinking people are going to die .....

Evanivitch

25,556 posts

143 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
eVTOL taxis and personnel carrying vehicles are becoming incredibly popular amongst investors. It's an interesting market and really intriguing to see how it moves over the next decade.

It certainly looks better than Malloy Aerospace's attempt, but that had a bit of Mad Max to it...

anonymous-user

75 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
The issue is entirely around legislation and air safety.

What "licence" do you need to commute in one of these?

People i see driving everyday can't even parallel park or reverse, so no way are they going to be flying something anytime soon.......

P675

652 posts

53 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Looks great but if you can only do it in a huge field/desert that you personally own, whats the point?

Evanivitch

25,556 posts

143 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
The issue is entirely around legislation and air safety.

What "licence" do you need to commute in one of these?

People i see driving everyday can't even parallel park or reverse, so no way are they going to be flying something anytime soon.......
TBD

https://www.caa.co.uk/safety-initiatives-and-resou...

JonChalk

6,469 posts

131 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
When I win the Euromillions tonight, this is so high on the "want" list. Will be great for getting from one end of the estate to the other.

Been following this for months, its absolutely brilliant.

zedx19

3,013 posts

161 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
General population struggles to use mirrors to look behind them or in blind spots, no way they can be trusted when you've got to look up and down, as well as front to back and side to side. Looks great fun though!

mikeyr

3,243 posts

214 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Love it but not sure I trust a flight computer that has been made redundant 3 times. Suggests it's not great at its job.

Evanivitch

25,556 posts

143 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
mikeyr said:
Love it but not sure I trust a flight computer that has been made redundant 3 times. Suggests it's not great at its job.
That's not quite how Functional Safety works.

anonymous-user

75 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
mikeyr said:
Love it but not sure I trust a flight computer that has been made redundant 3 times. Suggests it's not great at its job.
That's not quite how Functional Safety works.
here polly, here polly polly..... . ;-)

anonymous-user

75 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Max_Torque said:
The issue is entirely around legislation and air safety.

What "licence" do you need to commute in one of these?

People i see driving everyday can't even parallel park or reverse, so no way are they going to be flying something anytime soon.......
TBD

https://www.caa.co.uk/safety-initiatives-and-resou...
Realistically i can't see any licencing or training requirements being less than those required currently for a fixed wing PPL, and probably something slightly stricter,heading at least towards a rotary licence due to the amount of time spent in proximity to the ground and highly varied operating environment / proximity to general public etc?

TheDeuce

30,616 posts

87 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
These sorts of things are becoming very hot in the emergent tech world. Not for right now... But for when battery tech is improved to the point they're entirely practical.

Regards rules & regs.. already some places in the world are allowing automated drone delivery of goods, it shouldn't make a difference if the thing being delivered in the future is 'you' although that might well mean it's a call up book type of transport that will fly itself.

The actual safety aspect of all multi motor drones is insanely good because they can all set down safely even if more than one motor gives up.

This is one for wealthy investors to get excited by today, and probably something we can look to enjoy 'tomorrow'.

anonymous-user

75 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
TheDeuce said:
The actual safety aspect of all multi motor drones is insanely good because they can all set down safely even if more than one motor gives up.'.
Have a look at the number of rotary wing crashes caused by pilot error vs equipment failure. Yes, helicopters do fail and they fail in rather unsafe ways, but the fact is, people flying into objects still rates as a signficant cause of rotary wing crashes....... (precisely because unlike fixed wing aviation you can fly in close proximity to objects on a normal basis)

TheDeuce

30,616 posts

87 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
TheDeuce said:
The actual safety aspect of all multi motor drones is insanely good because they can all set down safely even if more than one motor gives up.'.
Have a look at the number of rotary wing crashes caused by pilot error vs equipment failure. Yes, helicopters do fail and they fail in rather unsafe ways, but the fact is, people flying into objects still rates as a signficant cause of rotary wing crashes....... (precisely because unlike fixed wing aviation you can fly in close proximity to objects on a normal basis)
A helicopter doesn't have 7,8,9 or more rotars though, and the ability to land safely on just 3 of them. I see these bits of kit on the film's I work on, we trust them to fly over waterfalls and skim tree tops with over £200k of equipment on board. They don't fail, they can't. They can partially fail and return on an established safe route to a recovery zone, but that's as bad as it can get pretty much.



As for the point about people flying and making errors, as I said, don't assume that the human on board will be allowed to fly it. Don't even assume there will be any way of flying it from within the machine.

MadMullah

5,299 posts

214 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
JonChalk said:
When I win the Euromillions tonight, this is so high on the "want" list.
Unfortunately thats not going to happen.

i'm winning it tonight

JonChalk

6,469 posts

131 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
MadMullah said:
JonChalk said:
When I win the Euromillions tonight, this is so high on the "want" list.
Unfortunately thats not going to happen.

i'm winning it tonight
Oh...........cry........that makes me sad. But if you're sure, I'll do the bigger man-thing and step aside with a stiff upper lip.

Evanivitch

25,556 posts

143 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
Evanivitch said:
mikeyr said:
Love it but not sure I trust a flight computer that has been made redundant 3 times. Suggests it's not great at its job.
That's not quite how Functional Safety works.
here polly, here polly polly..... . ;-)
I'll whoosh myself for that.

Evanivitch

25,556 posts

143 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Max_Torque said:
Realistically i can't see any licencing or training requirements being less than those required currently for a fixed wing PPL, and probably something slightly stricter,heading at least towards a rotary licence due to the amount of time spent in proximity to the ground and highly varied operating environment / proximity to general public etc?
I disagree. PPL is still a hangover from analogue flight (which is still largely true of most light aircraft) and flying with little to no assistance.

eVTOL will be highly assisted, if not fully automated with only limited safety demands on the operator. Fly by wire, flight envelope limitations, active collision avoidance etc etc.

Maybe there will be an operator's licence, but it won't be anywhere equivalent of a PPL. It'll be a more equivalent to a basic medical, simple theory test and a couple of hours in a simulator.

JonChalk

6,469 posts

131 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
Max_Torque said:
Realistically i can't see any licencing or training requirements being less than those required currently for a fixed wing PPL, and probably something slightly stricter,heading at least towards a rotary licence due to the amount of time spent in proximity to the ground and highly varied operating environment / proximity to general public etc?
I disagree. PPL is still a hangover from analogue flight (which is still largely true of most light aircraft) and flying with little to no assistance.

eVTOL will be highly assisted, if not fully automated with only limited safety demands on the operator. Fly by wire, flight envelope limitations, active collision avoidance etc etc.

Maybe there will be an operator's licence, but it won't be anywhere equivalent of a PPL. It'll be a more equivalent to a basic medical, simple theory test and a couple of hours in a simulator.
Sort of agree, really. Whatever you think of Musk's snake oil salesmanship around the non-existent FSD, ultimately non-human management of vehicles is the "best" way to maximise road usage, increase safety and increase efficiency. Doing the same in 3- dimensions is not that big a stretch, once 2D has been cracked.

TheDeuce

30,616 posts

87 months

Friday 1st July 2022
quotequote all
JonChalk said:
Sort of agree, really. Whatever you think of Musk's snake oil salesmanship around the non-existent FSD, ultimately non-human management of vehicles is the "best" way to maximise road usage, increase safety and increase efficiency. Doing the same in 3- dimensions is not that big a stretch, once 2D has been cracked.
100%. They say it's dangerous to tailgate on the motorways... But it wouldn't be if the cars were all hive controlled.

Humans manage to screw up every motorway in the land each day.

Machines are doing this: