PCP - early exit clarity for a numptie
PCP - early exit clarity for a numptie
Author
Discussion

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
Hi guys, I'm struggling to get my head around this - realtime example below:

New Car, £80K
Deposit, £20K
Agreement 48 months at 670.64
Mileage 6,000 pa
Balloon 46,424

Say I exit after a year and car is still worth £70K,

What has it effectively cost me, I think you get a significant rebate of the interest - is it 3 years less 1month 30 days or something under and FCA regulated agreement?

What if I exit after 3 months and car is still worth £80K?

I've never done a PCP before!

Thank you.

Shabaza

289 posts

125 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
Hi guys, I'm struggling to get my head around this - realtime example below:

New Car, £80K
Deposit, £20K
Agreement 48 months at 670.64
Mileage 6,000 pa
Balloon 46,424

Say I exit after a year and car is still worth £70K,

What has it effectively cost me, I think you get a significant rebate of the interest - is it 3 years less 1month 30 days or something under and FCA regulated agreement?

What if I exit after 3 months and car is still worth £80K?

I've never done a PCP before!

Thank you.
As with any loan which has APR.
You will be paying more proportion of the APR at the beginning of the agreement in your monthly £670 instalments.
If you decide to leave the agreement early, you are perfectly entitled to do so without incurring the interest for the remainder of the agreement.
Whole point of PCP is from a marketing perspective is flexibility to change more regularly.


From the above, looks like you are borrowing 60k, work out how much of the loan you pay off after 1 year.
Take that number away from the 70k you think the car is worth, thats how much you'll get back

Mandat

4,550 posts

266 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
Hi guys, I'm struggling to get my head around this - realtime example below:

New Car, £80K
Deposit, £20K
Agreement 48 months at 670.64
Mileage 6,000 pa
Balloon 46,424

Say I exit after a year and car is still worth £70K,

What has it effectively cost me, I think you get a significant rebate of the interest - is it 3 years less 1month 30 days or something under and FCA regulated agreement?

What if I exit after 3 months and car is still worth £80K?

I've never done a PCP before!

Thank you.
What do you mean by "exit"?

Do you want to:

  1. Sell the car
  2. Part-ex for something different
  3. Hand the car back to the finance company & walk away?

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
I'd sell it (potentially back to the dealer). It is an extra car, new Emira. Landing before Christmas if they can make the stars align at Hethel.

I don't know if I will love it and keep it forever or spend some time in it and exit. I not bothered about trying to sell it / flip it for overs as some are trying to do, I have had 8 Lotus so a big fan of the brand. What I don't want to do is catch a massive cold on it if I decide that it is not for me after a few months. So far the short test drive (heavilg regulated by Lotus) has told me very little about the car.

Sheepshanks

40,480 posts

147 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
Dunno what I am doing wrong in there as it always tells me I am owing more than I borrowed by about 20 grand at 100% apr....

Mineral1

59 posts

78 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
Ordinarily one would call the finance company up and ask them for the settlement figure, you can either pay that off with cash and keep the car, or you can sell the car and use the proceeds to pay off the remaining balance IF you are not in negative equity. The issue is that for the first couple of years the value of the car drops faster than the rate you are paying off the loan, so you're unlikely to be in positive equity until the last year or so of the term.

Alternatively, once 50% of the balance is paid off you can terminate the agreement, hand the car back and walk away with no liabilities or assets.

It's not ideal planning to be able to end the agreement early before you've even entered it, afterall it is a depreciating asset so that's unlikely to work out the way you want.

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
The theory here is that it is not depreciating - much if anything at all to start off with,

Sheepshanks

40,480 posts

147 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
Dunno what I am doing wrong in there as it always tells me I am owing more than I borrowed by about 20 grand at 100% apr....
I got this, for if you settle at 12 months:




There's two "month" (actually one of them is 28 days days but I forget the details) things but basically you have to give a month notice of settlement and the max penalty they can charge is another month.

Mineral1

59 posts

78 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
The theory here is that it is not depreciating - much if anything at all to start off with,
Bold assumption.

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
Why? The demand is huge and the supply almost non-existent.

Mine will be one of the first UK cars to land.

omniflow

3,761 posts

179 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
I'd sell it (potentially back to the dealer). It is an extra car, new Emira. Landing before Christmas if they can make the stars align at Hethel.

I don't know if I will love it and keep it forever or spend some time in it and exit. I not bothered about trying to sell it / flip it for overs as some are trying to do, I have had 8 Lotus so a big fan of the brand. What I don't want to do is catch a massive cold on it if I decide that it is not for me after a few months. So far the short test drive (heavilg regulated by Lotus) has told me very little about the car.
AFAIK in the example you are stating above, the PCP angle is irrelevant. The guaranteed future value only comes into play at the end of the term. If you exit early then it's a question of "how much can you get for the car" - it might still be £80K - in which case you'll have your deposit and a teeny weeny amount extra, or it might be £55K - in which case it will cost you £3K or 4K to get out of the deal.

You're borrowing £60K, you're paying interest on that at x.x% apr - or possibly xx.x% apr. Your monthly payment is £670.64 which is both paying the interest on the full balance outstanding and paying the capital at an average of £283 / month (non-linear) over 48 months. Given that you're always paying interest on the balloon, the difference between the capital repayments at the beginning of the term c.f. the capital repayments at the end of the term is not as pronounced as it is with a mortgage, but it still needs to be considered.

So - ignore the PCP angle - you can sell the car to whoever you want - if they (or you) are prepared to clear the finance.



240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
yeah that makes sense

First few payments are paying off majority interest and a little bit of capital and then it gradually goes the other way until the end of the 48 months.

My logic is if I buy the car for 80K and sell for 75K in the first few months my worst case liablity is the £5K depreication + a little bit of the interest from the payments that I would have made between purchase and sale. If it sticks at £80K, tiny loss, if it goes slightly over, small profit.

Chamon_Lee

3,948 posts

175 months

Wednesday 14th December 2022
quotequote all
240Cup said:
yeah that makes sense

First few payments are paying off majority interest and a little bit of capital and then it gradually goes the other way until the end of the 48 months.

My logic is if I buy the car for 80K and sell for 75K in the first few months my worst case liablity is the £5K depreication + a little bit of the interest from the payments that I would have made between purchase and sale. If it sticks at £80K, tiny loss, if it goes slightly over, small profit.
Theoretically that’s correct.

240Cup

Original Poster:

728 posts

218 months

Thursday 15th December 2022
quotequote all
Thanks fellas.

Well I've fisted the kumquat and pick up next week so will report back when I do eventually part with it and see where I ended up..!!

Stallzy

168 posts

89 months

Friday 16th December 2022
quotequote all
I was trying to read into PCP myself and the exits, but from what I read, I seemed to believe that you can only exit once you've paid 50% off of the amount including balloon?

Seems pretty hard tbh, and in terms of exiting via selling the vehicle, don't you still have to find a way to pay it off before fully selling it. I.e. you pay the full amount back to the finance company but then you receive it back via sale. I could be wrong but it sounds like you aren't in a position to pay back 80k before selling the vehicle, or maybe you are?

Maybe someone can better educate me too if I'm misunderstanding. I was looking at PCP on something much cheaper than this for a second car after not driving for a few years after my last one was written off, but have been suggested just to get something cheap outright like 2k or 3k max. The whole car finance thing seems pretty confusing and messy, and would have preferred bank loan option, but being self employed with a lower income, despite not really having much in outgoings, means a personal loan is basically impossible according to some sites.

Sheepshanks

40,480 posts

147 months

Friday 16th December 2022
quotequote all
Stallzy said:
I was trying to read into PCP myself and the exits, but from what I read, I seemed to believe that you can only exit once you've paid 50% off of the amount including balloon?

Seems pretty hard tbh, and in terms of exiting via selling the vehicle, don't you still have to find a way to pay it off before fully selling it. I.e. you pay the full amount back to the finance company but then you receive it back via sale. I could be wrong but it sounds like you aren't in a position to pay back 80k before selling the vehicle, or maybe you are?
The 50% thing is if you want to hand it back and walk away.

Easiest thing to do is sell it to the trade, WBAC or whatever (or PX it) and they'll take care of settling the finance.

You can sell it privately and get the buyer to settle the finance directly before he takes the car away but not every buyer will be keen to do that.

Stallzy

168 posts

89 months

Friday 16th December 2022
quotequote all
Sheepshanks said:
The 50% thing is if you want to hand it back and walk away.

Easiest thing to do is sell it to the trade, WBAC or whatever (or PX it) and they'll take care of settling the finance.

You can sell it privately and get the buyer to settle the finance directly before he takes the car away but not every buyer will be keen to do that.
Hmm, interesting. Not sure how much the trade would be willing to offer if it means they have to clear the finance on top of paying you off for the car, but it's not something I know too much about

DSLiverpool

16,416 posts

230 months

Friday 16th December 2022
quotequote all
Stallzy said:
Sheepshanks said:
The 50% thing is if you want to hand it back and walk away.

Easiest thing to do is sell it to the trade, WBAC or whatever (or PX it) and they'll take care of settling the finance.

You can sell it privately and get the buyer to settle the finance directly before he takes the car away but not every buyer will be keen to do that.
Hmm, interesting. Not sure how much the trade would be willing to offer if it means they have to clear the finance on top of paying you off for the car, but it's not something I know too much about
Just to clarify for you, if the cars worth £50k to the trade and you owe £55k on finance then you pay £5k to sell them the car.

Sheepshanks

40,480 posts

147 months

Friday 16th December 2022
quotequote all
DSLiverpool said:
Stallzy said:
Sheepshanks said:
The 50% thing is if you want to hand it back and walk away.

Easiest thing to do is sell it to the trade, WBAC or whatever (or PX it) and they'll take care of settling the finance.

You can sell it privately and get the buyer to settle the finance directly before he takes the car away but not every buyer will be keen to do that.
Hmm, interesting. Not sure how much the trade would be willing to offer if it means they have to clear the finance on top of paying you off for the car, but it's not something I know too much about
Just to clarify for you, if the cars worth £50k to the trade and you owe £55k on finance then you pay £5k to sell them the car.
Sure. But he's using the figures the OP posted so after a year the settlement figure is going to be around £50K and the OP is hoping the car will be worth £70K. So absolutely no issues for a dealer who wants the car to give the OP £20K and send £50K to the finance company. For Stallzy: this is an entirely routine thing to do.