Shell petrol carbon offset programme
Shell petrol carbon offset programme
Author
Discussion

RemarkLima

Original Poster:

2,849 posts

242 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
In the Shell Go app you can pay at pump etc... But it has an option to offset the carbon emissions from the last fill up.

Obviously their blurb sounds great, but it smells of green washing? I assume it'd be better to donate to a dedicated cause than via Shell?

Fusion777

2,630 posts

78 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
Not sure what you’re getting at? You’ll buying and burning fossil fuels- it isn’t green (not having a go, I do it too).

Shell are by and large a company built on hydrocarbons. Offsetting is better than not offsetting. What more is there to it?

If you want to be greener, drive less or not at all, go electric, drive something more economical, so on and so on.

GolfDragon

301 posts

97 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
It's a load of nonsense in my opinion.

I think you pay an extra 0.5p or 1p per litre to offset the Carbon emissions you generate from burning the fuel you've purchased.

Shell aren't necessarily the cheapest for petrol, their reward scheme isn't very rewarding (£1 off after 10 visits) and I'm pretty sure they make a very healthy profit year on year.

Why can't they pay to offset my Carbon emissions for me, if it only costs me 1p per litre?

Fusion777

2,630 posts

78 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
GolfDragon said:
It's a load of nonsense in my opinion.

I think you pay an extra 0.5p or 1p per litre to offset the Carbon emissions you generate from burning the fuel you've purchased.

Shell aren't necessarily the cheapest for petrol, their reward scheme isn't very rewarding (£1 off after 10 visits) and I'm pretty sure they make a very healthy profit year on year.

Why can't they pay to offset my Carbon emissions for me, if it only costs me 1p per litre?
As you say- they make lots of money each year (generally). They aren’t going to do something that costs them more when it has no clear benefit to their bottom line or shareholders.

As Bernard Looney said, BP (and other oil companies) are still cash generating machines.

RemarkLima

Original Poster:

2,849 posts

242 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
Yes, my thinking too, another way to look good and not actually cost them anything.

Shell is the closest for 99 RON and over the road is a sainsburys, so they're pegged on price pretty much.

Fusion777 said:
Not sure what you’re getting at? You’ll buying and burning fossil fuels- it isn’t green (not having a go, I do it too).

Shell are by and large a company built on hydrocarbons. Offsetting is better than not offsetting. What more is there to it?

If you want to be greener, drive less or not at all, go electric, drive something more economical, so on and so on.
I do few petrol miles really, about 3k a year and the rest is either trains or our electric vehicle... Been that way for 7 years now! But anything to help us not stting on the planet can be a good thing.

Chamon_Lee

3,948 posts

177 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
Can’t believe people entertain this crap.
What a load of cobblers

Missy Charm

1,528 posts

58 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
How, pray, does money 'offset' tailpipe emissions? Unless the CEO of Shell wishes to attempt to waft my car's exhaust smoke into space by waving a ten pound note at it, then it doesn't help at all. Your 'offset' money will go to some sort of 'green fund' operated by Shell, which will then make investments in 'green partner organizations'. Shell staff will hold shares in said green partner organizations and will benefit financially from them. Thus, following the circle in a circle principle, your 'offset' money will end up in the pockets of someone who works at Shell.

This whole green offsetting and carbon trading business allows racketeering and corruption beyond the wildest dreams of any common criminal, and lots of people seem to think it's great.

cootuk

918 posts

153 months

Sunday 15th January 2023
quotequote all
It may be green washing, but the money does contribute in a small way to eco projects preserving natural environments and ecosystems. It's another way of donating to charity.
1p/litre isn't a lot in the scheme of things when E5 is approx 170p/litre