Best and Worst Tribute Bands You've Seen
Best and Worst Tribute Bands You've Seen
Author
Discussion

Pitre

Original Poster:

5,758 posts

257 months

Saturday 10th June 2023
quotequote all
I've seen some great ones and one or two appalling ones....

Great = Aussie Pink Floyd - just wonderful, a great show and note for note perfection

Poor = Kast Off Kinks - even though they had two ex-Kinks playing I thought they were dreadful, like a bad pub band playing Kinks songs.


Polly Grigora

11,209 posts

132 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Never seen one

Sorry

Lotobear

8,640 posts

151 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
There's a band called (humorously) Nearly Dan who, obviously, do a Steely Dan show. They don't try to look or act like them and they are all session musicians in their own right. I've seen them many times and they really are superb, even have the horn section and lady backing singers.

There's also a band fronted by a chap called Martin Turner who do Wishbone Ash stuff, and they are even better that than the real thing!

arfur

4,008 posts

237 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Pitre said:
I've seen some great ones and one or two appalling ones....

Great = Aussie Pink Floyd - just wonderful, a great show and note for note perfection

Poor = Kast Off Kinks - even though they had two ex-Kinks playing I thought they were dreadful, like a bad pub band playing Kinks songs.
Saw a couple of Blues Brothers ones years ago - were both ok

Other than that just Aussie Pink Floyd, who as the OP says were brilliant and note perfect - totally recommended

PinkTornado

1,898 posts

85 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Saw Aussie Floyd in 2005, before the big split that gave rise to the rival Brit Floyd- neither band has been as good since.

'Rumours of Fleetwood Mac' are very, very good.

marcosgt

11,434 posts

199 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
I used to be very sniffy about tribute acts, but I went to see the Illegal Eagles and they were excellent. No pretending to be specific band members, just Eagles songs played brilliantly.

After that I went to see the Vox Beatles, obviously a Beatles tribute (one of many). They did pretend to be John or Paul, etc, which was mildly irritating at first, but they didn't take it too seriously and they played the songs pretty well, especially the guy being George.

Since then I've also seen London Calling, a Clash tribute. Not as good, but enjoyable enough for an evening out and how else will you hear a Clash set live?

Got tickets for Bootleg Blondie at the end of the month, as they're playing my local venue, so why not.

I still prefer going to see new acts or older acts with some of the original lineup, but a cheapish, local ticket for a tribute act is of interest now.


langtounlad

795 posts

194 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Saw Bootleg Blondie a last month - you are in for an enjoyable evening.

R6tty

730 posts

38 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Lotobear said:
There's a band called (humorously) Nearly Dan who, obviously, do a Steely Dan show. They don't try to look or act like them and they are all session musicians in their own right. I've seen them many times and they really are superb, even have the horn section and lady backing singers.

There's also a band fronted by a chap called Martin Turner who do Wishbone Ash stuff, and they are even better that than the real thing!
Appearing in Suffolk/Norfolk we have Steamy Dan. I think there are nine of them and quite stunning.

V8covin

9,348 posts

216 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Best The Scopyons who if you don't know are a tribute Scorpions band.If you don't know who The Scorpions are I don't care biggrin
The singer even talks in a fake German accent smile

Weso

475 posts

227 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
I took my lad to see Elvana - a Nirvana tribute band but fronted by an Elvis tribute.
Sounds bizarre but it was a great night out.

Cotty

41,881 posts

307 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
PinkTornado said:
Saw Aussie Floyd in 2005, before the big split that gave rise to the rival Brit Floyd- neither band has been as good since.
I saw them in 2013 in the O2 and they were very good. However half the seats were empty, they don't have the pull to fill a venue that size.
Would like to see them again but the nearest venue this year is SOUTHEND CLIFFS PAVILION
https://www.aussiefloyd.com/tour-dates

TeaNoSugar

1,415 posts

188 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Weso said:
I took my lad to see Elvana - a Nirvana tribute band but fronted by an Elvis tribute.
Sounds bizarre but it was a great night out.
Saw them last year at a festival. Very good. Again, not taking themselves at all seriously, but they performed the Nirvana stuff very well, along with some Elvis/Nirvana “mash-up” tracks. Would see them again at one of their own gigs.

Bradgate

3,152 posts

170 months

Sunday 11th June 2023
quotequote all
Best : Aussie Floyd, without question. Just ridiculously, unbelievably good.

Worst : Some Queen tribute at a small festival in a field. The musicians were ok, but the singer was poor. Impersonating Freddie is a pretty tough job, obviously, but this guy wasn’t convincing anyone.

Dan_The_Man

1,148 posts

262 months

Monday 12th June 2023
quotequote all
Dirty DC and the Guns & Roses experience are both excellent, would see them again !

Wacky Racer

40,647 posts

270 months

Monday 12th June 2023
quotequote all
Seen the Australian Pink Floyd five times in venues as diverse as Malta and Oswaltwistle biggrin

Also seen a few others, Darkside, The Floyd effect, all pretty good but TAPF are by far the best.

Also seen about Six Led Zeppelin tributes, couple of Deep Purple and Limehouse Lizzy.

Mr Jimmy is superb as Jimmy Page.



craigjm

20,469 posts

223 months

Monday 12th June 2023
quotequote all
The clone roses were pretty good as was Stipe. Saw the bohemians and that was very average but as above Freddie is hard to match.

cobra kid

5,499 posts

263 months

Monday 12th June 2023
quotequote all
Only seen one - Livewire. Small venue in Sheffield and were better than ACDC at Wembley the following year.

Pitre

Original Poster:

5,758 posts

257 months

Tuesday 13th June 2023
quotequote all
Bootleg Beatles were good (years ago) and Rumours of Fleetwood Mac were excellent too...

cobra kid

5,499 posts

263 months

Wednesday 14th June 2023
quotequote all
TeaNoSugar said:
Saw them last year at a festival. Very good. Again, not taking themselves at all seriously, but they performed the Nirvana stuff very well, along with some Elvis/Nirvana “mash-up” tracks. Would see them again at one of their own gigs.
Tramlines? I was there for that. Fantastic entertainment!

anonymous-user

77 months

Friday 23rd June 2023
quotequote all
langtounlad said:
Saw Bootleg Blondie a last month - you are in for an enjoyable evening.
Saw them last night, on a whim. Very good; more Debbie than Debbie herself.