cheap family 4x4/suv/mpv ..Have a laugh at my expense
cheap family 4x4/suv/mpv ..Have a laugh at my expense
Author
Discussion

smallzoo

Original Poster:

345 posts

197 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Our old family 4x4 xtrail has bit the dust so here goes..

this is my wish list and I am looking for advice

- Two or three times a year will take 4 adults , luggage and 2 medium dogs in the boot to Cornwall and back ( 600miles round trip )
- Two or three times a week my 22 yr old daughter can drive it to manchester and back to uni ( 60 miles round trip )
- Practically indestrucitble or at least wont break down every 5 minutes and can get us where we want to go without a fuss
- We wouldnt want a mortage just to keep the car on the road
- Automatic
- less than 8k miles a year
- tax <£400, mpg 25+
- here's where the laughing starts.,.. preferably less than £5k

ok...lets see what laughs I get,,

Bob M

77 posts

252 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
MK 2 or 3 CRV perhaps or a Suzuki SX4? SX4 might be a little small though.

Bob M

77 posts

252 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Skoda yeti or Octavia Scout but they'll be diesel

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

200 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
smallzoo said:
Our old family 4x4 xtrail has bit the dust so here goes..

this is my wish list and I am looking for advice

- Two or three times a year will take 4 adults , luggage and 2 medium dogs in the boot to Cornwall and back ( 600miles round trip )
- Two or three times a week my 22 yr old daughter can drive it to manchester and back to uni ( 60 miles round trip )
- Practically indestrucitble or at least wont break down every 5 minutes and can get us where we want to go without a fuss
- We wouldnt want a mortage just to keep the car on the road
- Automatic
- less than 8k miles a year
- tax <£400, mpg 25+
- here's where the laughing starts.,.. preferably less than £5k

ok...lets see what laughs I get,,
With that budget you're into luck territory.

Pick the least rusty Japanese 4x4 you can find.

Think I'd be looking at the Lexus RX400h but I bet most have been neglected at the age/pricepoint.

Terzo123

4,711 posts

235 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Pre march 2006 Jeep GC?

Cheaper tax, will manage 30 mpg on the motorway, but generally about 25 mpg.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/2023081307...

James76G

366 posts

211 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Tidied this up for a friend recently, 110k miles, 2.0 petrol, auto (well, CVT). Not the most refined thing in the world but hasn't had been much trouble in the 10 years he's had it. Not 4 x 4 but meets all the other criteria I think.



He then advertised it on AT for a touch over £3k and ended up with just a load of timewasters and/or being ghosted so not sure what's happening with it at the moment.

Edited by James76G on Thursday 24th August 16:44

clockworks

7,435 posts

172 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
C3 Picasso. Very practical, loads of space for what is quite a small car. Comfy, easy to drive, economical.
£5k should get you a 2012/13/14 with reasonable miles.

Roger Irrelevant

3,371 posts

140 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
If it doesn't actually have to be 4x4 - and the OP doesn't say it does - then surely something like an S-Max or C4 Grand Picasso is the answer. They'll be better at carting people + dogs + stuff than the sort of smallish 4x4s that are being suggested. It's a pity that estates seem to be ruled out as that would bring things like Mondeos or Superbs into play, which will also do the job required.

ChocolateFrog

34,954 posts

200 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
clockworks said:
C3 Picasso. Very practical, loads of space for what is quite a small car. Comfy, easy to drive, economical.
£5k should get you a 2012/13/14 with reasonable miles.
600 mile round trips in a C3 4 up with luggage and 2 dogs.

Sounds grim.

Silvanus

6,910 posts

50 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Skoda Roomster

nd0000

262 posts

147 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
They are all a bit long in the tooth now, but how about trying to find the nicest Volvo XC70 D5 you can?

Stuckinthe80s

18 posts

88 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Buy a Subaru legacy 3.0 estate for £3k with plenty left over for petrol if you can’t keep it to >25mpg.
Pre Apr 2006 to get cheaper tax rate.

https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/15093031

Edited by Stuckinthe80s on Thursday 24th August 18:45

magpie215

5,002 posts

216 months

105.4

4,214 posts

98 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Terzo123 said:
Pre march 2006 Jeep GC?

Cheaper tax, will manage 30 mpg on the motorway, but generally about 25 mpg.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/2023081307...
I was just about to say the same thing.

My Wife is on her second WJ Grand Cherokee. The first was with the indestructible 4.0 straight six. Her second is a 4.7 V8. Both return similar fuel economy figures. Parts are dirt cheap.

Both are built like tanks. So much so that even my Wife hasn’t been able to kill them.

ZX10R NIN

30,390 posts

152 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
smallzoo said:
Our old family 4x4 xtrail has bit the dust so here goes..

this is my wish list and I am looking for advice

- Two or three times a year will take 4 adults , luggage and 2 medium dogs in the boot to Cornwall and back ( 600miles round trip )
- Two or three times a week my 22 yr old daughter can drive it to manchester and back to uni ( 60 miles round trip )
- Practically indestrucitble or at least wont break down every 5 minutes and can get us where we want to go without a fuss
- We wouldnt want a mortage just to keep the car on the road
- Automatic
- less than 8k miles a year
- tax <£400, mpg 25+
- here's where the laughing starts.,.. preferably less than £5k

ok...lets see what laughs I get,,
Mazda5 TS2:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202308150...

Laguna Dynamique TomTom 175, these are very reliable & would serve you well:

https://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/202307119...

smallzoo

Original Poster:

345 posts

197 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Terzo123 said:
Pre march 2006 Jeep GC?

Cheaper tax, will manage 30 mpg on the motorway, but generally about 25 mpg.

http://www.autotrader.co.uk/car-details/2023081307...
I presume you mean the petrol not the diesel models ?

smallzoo

Original Poster:

345 posts

197 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Roger Irrelevant said:
If it doesn't actually have to be 4x4 - and the OP doesn't say it does - then surely something like an S-Max or C4 Grand Picasso is the answer. They'll be better at carting people + dogs + stuff than the sort of smallish 4x4s that are being suggested. It's a pity that estates seem to be ruled out as that would bring things like Mondeos or Superbs into play, which will also do the job required.
I did wonder about MPV's. like the s-max or touran but not sure if at £5k they will have been abused

smallzoo

Original Poster:

345 posts

197 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Stuckinthe80s said:
Buy a Subaru legacy 3.0 estate for £3k with plenty left over for petrol if you can’t keep it to >25mpg.
Pre Apr 2006 to get cheaper tax rate.

https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/15093031

Edited by Stuckinthe80s on Thursday 24th August 18:45
Aren't subarus money pits if things go wrong ?

smallzoo

Original Poster:

345 posts

197 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
105.4 said:
I was just about to say the same thing.

My Wife is on her second WJ Grand Cherokee. The first was with the indestructible 4.0 straight six. Her second is a 4.7 V8. Both return similar fuel economy figures. Parts are dirt cheap.

Both are built like tanks. So much so that even my Wife hasn’t been able to kill them.
Just checked autotrader its say the 4.7 avg is 17 to the gallon !

JQ

6,695 posts

206 months

Thursday 24th August 2023
quotequote all
Volvo XC70 with the D5 engine.