BBC Planet Earth III
Author
Discussion

SpeedBash

Original Poster:

2,586 posts

209 months

Tuesday 3rd October 2023
quotequote all

Randy Winkman

20,360 posts

211 months

Sunday 5th November 2023
quotequote all
I watch loads of natural history stuff on TV and end up a bit blase about the amazing things animals can do. But the leopard jumping from a tree onto antelope really did take me by surprise in tonight's programme (episode 3). The first one was from a fair height but the second one was from even more. Attenborough said 9 meters. Fair made me wince and I doubt the antelope was that happy either.

30 mins into the programme.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episode/m001s6xf/pla...

Defcon5

6,459 posts

213 months

Sunday 5th November 2023
quotequote all
Is it possible to watch this in UHD from iPlayer?


595Heaven

3,080 posts

100 months

Sunday 5th November 2023
quotequote all
Defcon5 said:
Is it possible to watch this in UHD from iPlayer?
Yep. Looks spectacular

outnumbered

4,760 posts

256 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all

The pictures in these are amazing, but the fake sound in these programmes puts me off. E.g. you have a shrimp or something swimming along to the sound of "watery noises" off the BBC sound effects LP.

Randy Winkman

20,360 posts

211 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all
outnumbered said:
The pictures in these are amazing, but the fake sound in these programmes puts me off. E.g. you have a shrimp or something swimming along to the sound of "watery noises" off the BBC sound effects LP.
I agree. The sound effects are OTT.

Eric Mc

124,664 posts

287 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all
I've given up on the "nature" spectaculars - too much gartuitous slow-mo for me.

Watching the original 1979 "Life on Earth" is always preferable. But even back then, people complained about aspects of "Life on Earth". In particular, there was a lot of anger about the loudness of the background music.

dukeboy749r

3,117 posts

232 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all
These are amazing programmes, I am just becoming a little tired of the 'life on the edge' nature of the commentary.

In this third program, for example, in talking about the dust storms - they are now bigger than ever, travel at over 70 mph and can overwhelm cities 'in an instant' anywhere on Earth.

Well, blatantly they don't and who is to say that they have not occurred (and worse) in history?

Seeing as (in the same programme) Sir David states that 'it takes millennia for life to adapt to these (desert/harsh conditions)', so if we accept that, then we must also accept that life has been facing equally challenging circumstances for millennia, too.

Becoming a little jaded by the national treasure that is Sir David Attenborough.


Se7enheaven

1,926 posts

186 months

Monday 6th November 2023
quotequote all
For me the more ingenious and inventive the photography becomes , the less interesting it is. Give me back the old no nonsense filming please. And yes , sorry, but Sir David gets right on my tits now. Please just give the scaremongering a rest.

anonymous-user

76 months

Sunday 26th November 2023
quotequote all
Se7enheaven said:
For me the more ingenious and inventive the photography becomes , the less interesting it is. Give me back the old no nonsense filming please. And yes , sorry, but Sir David gets right on my tits now. Please just give the scaremongering a rest.
I agree. I used to enjoy this but everytime he says under threat, its always followed by change of climate. It's getting boring as well as annoying. And he lost my respect when he lied about the walruses jumping to death because "of the change of climate"

Randy Winkman

20,360 posts

211 months

Sunday 26th November 2023
quotequote all
I think that stuff should be kept to a minimum.

Shame if it puts people off because again last week, I saw things I genuinely didn't know about. Like the hornbill holed-up in a tree and the noises that the dhole dogs could make. Brilliant stuff.

LimmerickLad

5,876 posts

37 months

Sunday 26th November 2023
quotequote all
pocketspring said:
I agree. I used to enjoy this but everytime he says under threat, its always followed by change of climate. It's getting boring as well as annoying. And he lost my respect when he lied about the walruses jumping to death because "of the change of climate"
I would watch absolutely everything he did at one time but everything now relates to " climate change" and as you say it's getting boring as well as annoying...I had a quick flick over tonight and saw wolves chasing a musk ox, then all of a sudden we have a dead one that died of disease "becoming more common because of climate change" apparantly!!