Do, don't I, and if so what?
Do, don't I, and if so what?
Author
Discussion

A500leroy

8,154 posts

145 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
How about a short term lease/long term rental?

Work out how much money you would loose if brought outright and sold at a certain point and see how close you get with a lease.

Pando99

130 posts

86 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
I am in the same boat as you - having just got rid of my RS 4 after 9 years of ownership I dont know what to get.

We replaced it with a Tiguan, but will be losing the small runabout to my lad once he passes his test, so there will be a blank space in the garage that can be replaced with something.

I am fed up of the expensive car issue of looking after it etc

I am tempted by a older Boxster that is for sale locally and appears to be a tidy example or trying to get a good golf gti mk 7 / 7.5.

Seen quite a few performance models so time for a bit of hunting and maybe a few drives to see what we fancy

TwigtheWonderkid

48,641 posts

177 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Not very PH, but if you have spare cash, at 42, don't forget to absolutely max out your pension contributions.

ziggy328

1,374 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Personally, I'd go Lotus. Cheap to run/maintain and you'd probably get your money back on an Elise/Exige/Evora.

I've had my Evora just over 2 years - still love it. First time I've ever kept a car this long.

OutInTheShed

13,968 posts

53 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Motorbike?

I'd be tempted to look at 90s cars which are not too hard to work on.

Some people's idea of a toy car for the weekend is drivng a Morgan or 7 or ..... 20 miles to the pub and back, others would be thinking of weekends to nice roads in Wales or similar, so want civilised motorway cruising.

Monkeylegend

28,872 posts

258 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all

PositronicRay

28,843 posts

210 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Buy sensibly and you'll always be able to dispose of it easily, because of this cars are great itches to scratch.

Muzzer79

12,855 posts

214 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
But you realise that the social and economic factors that led to that situation are highly unlikely to be repeated for decades, if ever?

Turn7

25,539 posts

248 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Buy an Elise and add the exige roof and side scoops, if you buy the supercharged Elise, even better.......

bearman68

4,929 posts

159 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
It would be an Elise for me, or possibly a 'modern classic'.

Pick something like (for example) a Mk1 MR2, and not too much bad can happen. Even if the engine blows up, it's hardly the most terrible job to remove and replace or repair.

There's plenty of interesting metal out there for a few grand. Buy sensibly, and if you don't like it, sell it and move on.

I've been buying stuff that I like for years, and while non of it is particular PH worthy, it keeps things interesting, and I enjoy swapping and changing, and buying and selling. I suppose it's cost me a few grand over the years, but it's small money, and lots of fun.

Let's be fair, the excitement of a new car wears off pretty quickly, and then you start finding all the design niggles and irritations with it. Mind you, I do like the car to drive properly, and I do enjoy the spanners, so there's usually a bit of tinkering that both helps me bond to the car, and increases value a little.

Also, who wants or needs the worry and hassle of keeping a car in the 100% perfection mode. I don't for sure. Life is too short, and I want to be doing other things, rather than cleaning a car, and fretting about whether the wheels are original, or the mats are the right colour. Who cares? Not me that's for sure.

TL:DR. Go and buy something older and funner, and cheaper, and if you don't like it, sell it.

Belle427

11,685 posts

260 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
Id stretch to the GTR if you can afford it but a lot of your other choices are also interesting.
Really depends what you like driving, the VX and Elise/Exige can be a very raw experience and not for everyone, im thinking of moving mine on after only a year as although its a very capable car the driving experience on the roads is a little too uncomfortable for my liking.
Values do hold up well though if thats a concern.

ziggy328

1,374 posts

241 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
They also feel faster than they are. If you can stretch to a 400 they are a bit of a leap over the older ones. Supercharger makes the car imo. Doesn’t cost any more to service than a big standard saloon. Parts are cheap too.

Turn7

25,539 posts

248 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all

okgo

41,878 posts

225 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Errr, it and other factors were the entire reason, nothing you did hehe

I think the problem is when looking on a budget, there’s always that newer model. Personally would choose something that is a little more timeless - 911 of some sort.

Fiisch

278 posts

155 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
I could have written this post myself - in a very similar scenario.

I'm holding off for now as my crystal ball has used ICE prices slumping, so I'm waiting to see what the market does. A lot of the cars you listed are on my shortlist, as are an old Japanese car from my younger days (I have a hankering for (another) Subaru Impreza).

The problem I have is I alternate between:

1. Fast and useable daily. Pros: It will get driven; I can justify the purchase; I will actually get to enjoy the car. Cons: I'll be precious about the car getting damaged in a soft play car park, the "boring" daily mileage I do will cost me more, and I can't really enjoy the car with the family in it.

2. Fast and silly weekend car. Pros: Cheaper; Something just for me that I can fawn over in the garage. Cons: It'll never get used, and I'll feel guilty for buying something for me when I could have spent it on holidays/mortgage/something for the family.

I'd certainly forget the loan if you're thinking weekend car - ideally, you'd want to buy outright and buy something that will hold its value well.

Sorry, I haven't answered the question, but you're not alone in your thinking. I'm off to get some vicarious enjoyment browsing the classifieds....

Mr Tidy

30,638 posts

154 months

Sunday 11th February 2024
quotequote all
That's such a random list of potential purchases OP!

I think you need to work out what you really want on the scale between a wafty barge and a full-on 2 seater.

keo

2,905 posts

197 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
Very bias opinion here… Buy a lotus. Pretty much the best driving experience. Still half practical for weekends away/ you have a roof and proper doors! Cheap to run and maintain. Values are pretty good so shouldn’t lose much on depreciation.

I have an Exige 410 now. It’s an awesome piece of kit. However I think my old Elise 111R was possibly more fun. Could thrash it more on the road without going silly speeds.
If you can push into a v6 car though they are great fun. You wouldn’t think it was “only” a Toyota engine making the noise it does!

V6 is definitely better on the motorway for longer journeys with the Mrs though. If the exhaust is closed!

Belle427

11,685 posts

260 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
One of the only cars i actually regret selling was a Mk 1 Mx5 that i paid £900 for with no Abs, traction, airbags etc.
It was a non running project i got back on the road and it already had Meister R coilovers fitted and was just a lovely thing to drive.
Dog slow but you kind of enjoyed ringing its neck more and the gearchange was sublime, it was a nice comfortable place to be too.
Im considering another in the future but would love to do a Supercharged conversion, a lot of money to do it though.
Id go as far to say i enjoyed it more than my current Elise as i wasnt precious about it at all.

Turn7

25,539 posts

248 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
Yes, whine is present.

IIRC, it’s a roots type blower just behind your head, in the exige at least

fflump

3,297 posts

65 months

Monday 12th February 2024
quotequote all
anonymous said:
[redacted]
997.2 is the sweet spot agewise.
Try RWD and AWD as they are pretty different driving experiences