RE: Mercedes previews Taycan-rivalling AMG.EA
RE: Mercedes previews Taycan-rivalling AMG.EA
Monday 18th March 2024

Mercedes previews Taycan-rivalling AMG.EA

Cold weather testing suggests that the new Turbo GT won't have things all its own way next year


Of all the cars that Mercedes-AMG currently sells, it might be the 4-door GT 63 that best evokes the firm’s old-school mentality. It has the brooding, prizefighter-in-an-Armani-suit looks and it has an absurdly powerful, hard-charging V8. That it is also actually a very decent car to drive and sit in is almost just the confetti; you buy one because it looks and sounds the business. Which does present something of a hurdle for the electric car eventually charged with replacing it. 

Obviously, Mercedes is well into its EV revolution elsewhere in the lineup, but AMG’s standalone model is very different from the comparatively staid, fast-in-a-straight-line stuff we’ve seen so far. Previewed by a Vision 2025 concept, the 4-door GT replacement gets a bespoke platform - the so-called AMG.EA - which has been designed from day one as a 'technological trailblazer' and has been lined up to receive a new generation of axial-flux electric motors from Yasa, a British startup acquired in 2021 specifically to work on the project. The manufacturer reckons they offer 'an unparalleled mix of power density, size, and weight.' 

If that prospect doesn’t immediately float your boat, it’s worth pointing out that this is the same firm (before it became a wholly-owned Mercedes subsidiary) that debuted its electric motors in the Koenigsegg Regera - and then announced Ferrari as its first volume OEM customer with the SF90. So it’s got some serious game, in other words. And while anything as specific as total output is mostly guesswork at this stage, it’s safe to assume that Mercedes-AMG has the 1,108hp produced by the Taycan Turbo GT in its gun sights. Or potentially as a dot in its rearview mirror. 

Either way, one look at the test mule confirms the Porsche as a key rival. The low-slung, prominently-spoiler’d car speaks not only to the AMG.EA platform underneath but also the bold design promises that were made with the concept. As ever, the visible details on a development model be taken with a hefty pinch of salt - although the fact that the incoming EV seems to have also adopted a very similar silhouette to its V8-powered predecessor must be taken as a good sign. We couldn’t stop staring at the GT 63; with nothing to listen to, the electrified follow-up will need to be at least as good-looking to exit from its shadow.


Author
Discussion

Julian Scott

Original Poster:

4,308 posts

53 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Good pedigree, great to see more entrants into this sector of the EV market - it's where the enthusiast interest will lay*



(* except for the 'rather cut my legs off' moaners that are due here any minute wink )

theicemario

1,575 posts

104 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Nice to see another saloon coming to market.

blueg33

46,460 posts

253 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Looks fat

J4CKO

46,838 posts

229 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?


GroundEffect

13,864 posts

185 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Discharge power of the battery, and the capability to draw on that power by the inverters/motors.


Rob-s5mok

137 posts

129 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Or more importantly, when will the madness end?

What use is 1000bhp on a road car? Except to a pub bore. Or a man with a really tiny winky.



Sisu9

306 posts

131 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Certainly looks better than those strange anteater-looking EV saloons they have been putting out of late.

Terminator X

20,632 posts

233 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Rob-s5mok said:
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Or more importantly, when will the madness end?

What use is 1000bhp on a road car? Except to a pub bore. Or a man with a really tiny winky.
They still seem to be £200k plus so I can't imagine too many from any manufacturer will be sold.

TX.

Gordon Hill

2,412 posts

44 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Rob-s5mok said:
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Or more importantly, when will the madness end?

What use is 1000bhp on a road car? Except to a pub bore. Or a man with a really tiny winky.
Our resident pub bore got in before you, never misses an opportunity to bore the t#ts off everybody.

Demonix

828 posts

241 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Competition at the top end of the market is good as the tech will gradually filter down, not so far as we all get 1000bhp monsters but more performance oriented models lower in the hierarchy should arrive and receive a trickle of the high end tech eventually.
The Merc EA AMG is an odd shape, looks more crossover than saloon to me.

S600BSB

8,385 posts

135 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
That looks exciting..

whp1983

1,379 posts

168 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Demonix said:
Competition at the top end of the market is good as the tech will gradually filter down, not so far as we all get 1000bhp monsters but more performance oriented models lower in the hierarchy should arrive and receive a trickle of the high end tech eventually.
The Merc EA AMG is an odd shape, looks more crossover than saloon to me.
Be interested to see if it does….. good old days of how much can you get out of a small engine or turbo …. Now it’s just big slab of battery… bigger the slab and motor more power. I’m looking forward to when more thought goes into it.

sidesauce

2,967 posts

247 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
The British company behind these new motors Mercedes is coming out with have some genuinely interesting engineering ideas as things like power density in these new gen motors are rapidly scaling up whilst their size and weight is dropping down considerably. The CEO is a very affable, self-effacing chap and it's well worth watching the videos below with him talking about some of the tech:-





Maccmike8

1,607 posts

83 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Wait until the special editions. EA Sport. Its in the game biggrin

romac

608 posts

175 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
whp1983 said:
Demonix said:
Competition at the top end of the market is good as the tech will gradually filter down, not so far as we all get 1000bhp monsters but more performance oriented models lower in the hierarchy should arrive and receive a trickle of the high end tech eventually.
The Merc EA AMG is an odd shape, looks more crossover than saloon to me.
Be interested to see if it does….. good old days of how much can you get out of a small engine or turbo …. Now it’s just big slab of battery… bigger the slab and motor more power. I’m looking forward to when more thought goes into it.
Quite a lot of thought has gone into the Lucid Air!

I think we are where we are because of technology limitations, plus the oddity that the larger the battery (in principle) the faster it can charge and discharge. And further, that an empty battery weighs the same as a full one, so there's no "low fuel = less weight = performance boost". Imagine if ICE performance was so wildly affected by the size of the fuel tank and the pipe coming from it!

fantheman80

2,614 posts

78 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
6000 SUX vibes! Clarence is going to love it

GT9

9,015 posts

201 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Rob-s5mok said:
What use is 1000bhp on a road car?
The same usefulness as having 800 miles of range in an ICE.

Hardly ever gets used, a nice to have for the odd occasion, doesn't cost that much to add into the car.

J4CKO

46,838 posts

229 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
Gordon Hill said:
Rob-s5mok said:
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Or more importantly, when will the madness end?

What use is 1000bhp on a road car? Except to a pub bore. Or a man with a really tiny winky.
Our resident pub bore got in before you, never misses an opportunity to bore the t#ts off everybody.
Who are you referring to there ?

TinpotTintop

147 posts

60 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Ultimately, it will come down to traction, or lack thereof. Tyre manufacturers are struggling to keep up. Battery and powertrain performance will progress as power density, heat management etc get better

GT9

9,015 posts

201 months

Monday 18th March 2024
quotequote all
TinpotTintop said:
J4CKO said:
Its kind of weird that four figure bhp numbers are becoming relatively common in EV land with the Tesla Plaid, new Taycan and this, plus the Rimac.

Can only think of the modern Bugatti models in terms of factory 1000 bhp plus ICE models, maybe some kind of Hellcat ?

Wonder how far it will go ? What limits the power outputs of EV's ?
Ultimately, it will come down to traction, or lack thereof. Tyre manufacturers are struggling to keep up. Battery and powertrain performance will progress as power density, heat management etc get better
Traction limits are more about wheel torque than power.

EVs don't have gearboxes, other than a few 2-speed ones.


ICEs develop higher wheel torques at low road speed simply because the total ratio of first and usually second gear multiplied by the final drive ratio are bigger numbers than the fixed final drive in the EV motors.

In other words, the power in an EV is dished out according to road speed, it is simply not available at low speed when it would break traction.

This is entirely intentional and a 'perfect' engineering solution, because the power required to accelerate any given car at a fixed g increases linearly with road speed (plus a little bit more for drag as the speed gets high).

Comparing headline power outputs between ICEs and EVs is a bit apples and oranges.

ETA: adding 4WD to significantly increase traction limits is a bit easier in an EV than an ICE.

Edited by GT9 on Monday 18th March 21:13