Junior SIPP is the 20% added any use?
Junior SIPP is the 20% added any use?
Author
Discussion

CoolHands

Original Poster:

22,473 posts

219 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
Alright so you can add up to 2880 to child pension and gov too Uk to 3600 but is there any point if at the other end your child will be taxed 20%?

Is the only benefit that the 25% tax free part will be a genuine 20% better off? As it had 20% added but won’t have it removed

Mr Pointy

12,913 posts

183 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
Well you don't know if it will be taxed - it depends on their marginal tax rate when they take the money. As you say 25% won't be taxed anyway (if the current rules stay in place) but the big winner is 40/50/60 years of compound interest on the free 20%.

Tim330

1,310 posts

236 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
If they retire prior to state pension age then they could use the SIPP for tax free income up to the 20% band.

fat80b

3,191 posts

245 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
CoolHands said:
Alright so you can add up to 2880 to child pension and gov too Uk to 3600 but is there any point if at the other end your child will be taxed 20%?

Is the only benefit that the 25% tax free part will be a genuine 20% better off? As it had 20% added but won’t have it removed
Isn't the benefit that you get the additional bit *now*, and then get to invest it for the next 60 years. i.e. it's the compound interest on the additional bit that is the real benefit not the tax saving at either end?

i.e. if you shove the two amounts into a compound interest calculator assuming 7% growth which is historically about right (US). - Then in 60 years time, you get:
  • 2880 now = 189727
vs
  • 3600 now = 237159
Sounds pretty good to me for a small investment and some time....

B9

532 posts

119 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
20% tax on that 237k is 47k, so you end up with the same.

That said, £12.5k per year tax free and the first 25% also tax free. Worth doing

CoolHands

Original Poster:

22,473 posts

219 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
Ok but if you’re already getting 12.5 tax free (as will have other pensions by then) then are we just back to the 25% tax free lump again?!

B9

532 posts

119 months

Tuesday 30th April 2024
quotequote all
Yes, and sheltered from inheritance tax

I’ve set my kids up with a starting amount and will contribute for a while longer. It will serve as a reference point of what impact compound interest can have (on debt and savings).

Arguably it would make sense to put into your own pension, and then when you draw from your pension (25% of which being tax free) you recycle it into theirs..!

oldaudi

1,565 posts

182 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
Ive have a SIPP for as long as I can remember and my two children have a SIPP that I setup for them in 2008. I actually had my photo taken that was used in the HL investment times and interviewed as to why on earth someone would setup a SIPP for a 2 year old.

For me the tax reasons were beneficial, I’d max out my ISA, contribute to my work pension and then put as much as I could into my SIPP. I’m not wealthy enough to hit the maximum numbers but to see the extra being topped up by the government automatically and then doing a tax return to get the rest at 40% felt like free money. The fact that the government will give the first 20% to a non tax paying child seems like a good idea to me.

I’ve not really thought far ahead enough to consider the tax issues when my children want to get access to their SIPP. I’m certain the rules will changes, I’m certain tax levels will change, but to get a 50 year head start on savings in an uncertain future , I think, is a good idea. They’ve already had over a decade of compounded dividend reinvested income on their SIPP and their Child Trust Funds, one CTF actually matures in July when my first born hits 18 years old. Seeing an almost monthly income from UK and USA shares with high yields has bumped up the value of the accounts.

I believe the basic pension will either be stopped or reduced in the future, we’ve already seen reductions in NI % dropped twice this year and at least one UK party mentioned removing it all together. How on earth will the state pension be funded? Lots of variables and rules change to come but as my children enter the work force they’ll have enough issues affording housing, food, travel etc never mind contributing to a pension so I simply wanted to give them a head start.

There are other reasons why I started a SIPP.


Edited by oldaudi on Wednesday 1st May 07:21

CoolHands

Original Poster:

22,473 posts

219 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
Thanks oldaudi are you saying that if you’re a normal job paye 40% tax payer, you can also start doing a self assessment and get 20% returned to you? (So 20% gets added by the gov to the contribution and the giver gets 20% back by self assessment?)

oldaudi

1,565 posts

182 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
Exactly. But You cannot claim for the children that’s capped at 20% and Its automatically added by your broker (normally).

But if you’re in a different tax bracket you can claim more on your tax return for your SIPP

Over the years they’ve either adjusted my tax code so you can earn more before you get taxed or they simply pay it as a lump sum.


https://www.hl.co.uk/pensions/tax-relief/calculato...


Edited by oldaudi on Wednesday 1st May 07:48

chip*

1,672 posts

252 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
I opened a SIPP for both my kids when they were born and took advantge of the £720 annual top up, plus some smaller top ups on later years. The total investment isn't life changing right now, but with +50 years of compounded growth, my kids will have a decent amount to play with. However, I have ceased all contribution as life is too unpredictable, and since divorce is quite a common event, I can't be sure I am contributing just for my daughter..

Mr Whippy

32,337 posts

265 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
Tim330 said:
If they retire prior to state pension age then they could use the SIPP for tax free income up to the 20% band.
But isn’t “retirement age” also regulated wrt taking any pension wrapper investments?

Ie, in 40yrs retirement age might be nudged up to a much less attractive level?

Mr Whippy

32,337 posts

265 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
B9 said:
Yes, and sheltered from inheritance tax
Today yes, but this may well change as it’s clearly used by many as a tax avoidance measure for large estates at death.

Tim330

1,310 posts

236 months

Wednesday 1st May 2024
quotequote all
Mr Whippy said:
Tim330 said:
If they retire prior to state pension age then they could use the SIPP for tax free income up to the 20% band.
But isn’t “retirement age” also regulated wrt taking any pension wrapper investments?

Ie, in 40yrs retirement age might be nudged up to a much less attractive level?
It could be but at the moment you can access your sipp 10 years earlier than state pension age.