Choice of EV's
Author
Discussion

Steve6371

Original Poster:

29 posts

62 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
I need some help to make a decision on which EV to have as my company car. Options Tesla 3 or BYD Seal. What's everyone's thoughts?

Bobtherallyfan

1,476 posts

102 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
With one, you are supporting Trump…with the other, you are just buying more Chinese crap with no support structure.

Steve6371

Original Poster:

29 posts

62 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
Bobtherallyfan said:
With one, you are supporting Trump…with the other, you are just buying more Chinese crap with no support structure.
So are you saying the best option is to support trump.

bennno

14,953 posts

293 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all

Ionic 5

Steve6371

Original Poster:

29 posts

62 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
bennno said:
Ionic 5
Unfortunately that wasn't in my choices

Tye Green

956 posts

133 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
bennno said:
Ionic 5
actually it's Ioniq 5 and yes, I can recommend smile

quinny100

1,001 posts

210 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
If it’s your first EV, go for the Tesla.

There is nothing significantly better about the Seal as a car. Yes, the AWD is very quick at under 4 seconds to 60 but has a lower top speed and the Tesla isn’t exactly a slouch. The boot on the Seal is quite small.

The Tesla is more efficient so will go further despite a smaller battery, especially at motorway speeds and the Tesla also charges faster.

Whilst Tesla service isn’t perfect, it’s far more established than BYD. I’d be more confident getting a part for a Model 3 than a Seal.

The supercharger network is still a major benefit - the ability to just rock up and plug in without faffing with an app and be confident you’ll get a quick charge is not to be underestimated. Yes, many sites have been opened up but the motorway ones remain largely Tesla only. The integration between the car and the charging network just makes things so much easier - just put your round trip in the nav and it’ll tell you where to charge based on live availability data from the charging stations. It’s very clever and it just works.

jonathan_roberts

556 posts

32 months

Friday 19th July 2024
quotequote all
Model 3 every day of the week.

Steve6371

Original Poster:

29 posts

62 months

Saturday 20th July 2024
quotequote all
quinny100 said:
If it’s your first EV, go for the Tesla.

There is nothing significantly better about the Seal as a car. Yes, the AWD is very quick at under 4 seconds to 60 but has a lower top speed and the Tesla isn’t exactly a slouch. The boot on the Seal is quite small.

The Tesla is more efficient so will go further despite a smaller battery, especially at motorway speeds and the Tesla also charges faster.

Whilst Tesla service isn’t perfect, it’s far more established than BYD. I’d be more confident getting a part for a Model 3 than a Seal.

The supercharger network is still a major benefit - the ability to just rock up and plug in without faffing with an app and be confident you’ll get a quick charge is not to be underestimated. Yes, many sites have been opened up but the motorway ones remain largely Tesla only. The integration between the car and the charging network just makes things so much easier - just put your round trip in the nav and it’ll tell you where to charge based on live availability data from the charging stations. It’s very clever and it just works.
Tesla it is then