Help me decide
Author
Discussion

ssjwootton

Original Poster:

1 posts

18 months

Friday 4th October 2024
quotequote all
Hello all, this is my first post on the forum. I've been debating getting a new car for about 12 months now, and I have managed to narrow it down to two very different cars. For context, I am a 29-year-old single male, and I currently drive a 118i. I've enjoyed it, as it's rear-wheel drive, but I'm after something a bit more fun. I barely have any passengers, so practicality doesn't matter to me at all.

I can't decide between a BMW Thundernight Purple 230i (I can't afford a 240i)

Or a Performance Blue Hyundai i30N with DCT. Both are very different cars, I know, however, I like both for many reasons and just can't decide what to go with.

I was wondering what you all thought?

Time4another

481 posts

27 months

Friday 4th October 2024
quotequote all
230i all day long. Much better looking beasty.

axel1990chp

1,265 posts

127 months

Friday 4th October 2024
quotequote all
Welcome,

I30N all the way.

I loved mine, fantastic car! I'd get the manual personally!

Only note id say: personal preference the blue is hideous, black or white looks much better and will probably look better in 5 years time too!

I had all the red faff painted black on mine, looked fantastic!

Whatever you decide, i'm sure youll enjoy it!

ZX10R NIN

30,072 posts

149 months

Friday 4th October 2024
quotequote all
Hi if you want a fun entertaining steer then the i30N is the hands down winner out of those two.

jaydeeuk1

716 posts

84 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Time4another said:
230i all day long. Much better looking beasty.
The hyundai is a better car by most other metrics, even though it's a bit bland looking.

Personally I don't get why what a car looks like being top of peoples priorities, they're either sat in it driving it so cant see, or it's parked outside where they can't see. Unless it's purely for validation from strangers. In which case, CBT might help.

Rob 131 Sport

4,443 posts

76 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
It just has to be the BMW as it looks so much better and will hold it’s appeal for many years to come.

Neil1323bolts

1,256 posts

130 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Hyundai for me , but then I have absolutely no love for the BMW and I own an i20N, excellent car like it’s bigger brother the i30N

Silvanus

6,904 posts

47 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Hyundai every day of the week

Chamon_Lee

3,948 posts

171 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
jaydeeuk1 said:
Time4another said:
230i all day long. Much better looking beasty.
The hyundai is a better car by most other metrics, even though it's a bit bland looking.

Personally I don't get why what a car looks like being top of peoples priorities, they're either sat in it driving it so cant see, or it's parked outside where they can't see. Unless it's purely for validation from strangers. In which case, CBT might help.
mind bending for me to think the appearance of a car is not top of peoples priority when buying a car.

AnhBanhBao

296 posts

71 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Have no history with either brand, but Hyundai seems to be more fun if that’s your brief, and plenty of time after the Hyundai to get into another BMW if you still wish to.

Rich 3

23 posts

109 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Beemer for me - 230i is a great choice

Mr Tidy

29,705 posts

151 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
I'd chose the BMW because Thundernight is such a great colour!

But I'm sure I'd find a way to make it a 240i somehow.

Resolutionary

1,480 posts

195 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
jaydeeuk1 said:
Time4another said:
230i all day long. Much better looking beasty.
The hyundai is a better car by most other metrics, even though it's a bit bland looking.

Personally I don't get why what a car looks like being top of peoples priorities, they're either sat in it driving it so cant see, or it's parked outside where they can't see. Unless it's purely for validation from strangers. In which case, CBT might help.
Do you like the clothes you wear?

Captain Smerc

3,277 posts

140 months

Saturday 5th October 2024
quotequote all
Dude seriously, buy the purple car.

spikeyhead

19,779 posts

221 months

Sunday 6th October 2024
quotequote all
When faced with a dilemma then chose the third option.

As you rarely carry passengers, and want something sport and RWD, buy a Caterham 7

CG2020UK

2,882 posts

64 months

Sunday 6th October 2024
quotequote all
Used M2

cayman-black

13,251 posts

240 months

Sunday 6th October 2024
quotequote all
I,m sure the Hyundai is better but that BMW in that colour looks great.

Tarmack

48 posts

20 months

Sunday 6th October 2024
quotequote all
Surely you could go for an older car and get into a 240i?

a311

6,201 posts

201 months

Sunday 6th October 2024
quotequote all
If you're prioritising premium feel, RWD dynamics, and a unique look, the BMW 230i is the way to go. But if you're after raw fun, excitement, and don't mind switching to FWD with a bit more of a "hot hatch" vibe, the i30N will definitely satisfy. Like others have said I'd go older and get a 240i though.

LightningBlue

613 posts

65 months

Wednesday 9th October 2024
quotequote all
I’d prefer to have a coupe so the BMW for me but don’t forget about the fastback version of the i30N - these look pretty good