Gomorrah on sky
Author
Discussion

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,857 posts

173 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
After finishing The Soprano's for the 20th time, I still had a mafia itch so I gave Gomorrah a go

I've just started season 3 so no spoilers please.

Wow wow wow, what a show!

Just some observations

They have the worst car selection, I keep forgetting the first season is modern day 2014, These so called millionaire drug dealers getting driven around in early Touraegs

In season 2, one of the bosses, Scaniel gets 1 million euros however she is chauffered around in a GLA 200, sitting in the back all cramped

Could it be because of the presence of the real gang members in the area and potential theft or is it because the person in charge of the cars hasnt got a clue

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,857 posts

173 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
After finishing The Soprano's for the 20th time, I still had a mafia itch so I gave Gomorrah a go

I've just started season 3 so no spoilers please.

Wow wow wow, what a show!

Just some observations

They have the worst car selection, I keep forgetting the first season is modern day 2014, These so called millionaire drug dealers getting driven around in early Touraegs

In season 2, one of the bosses, Scaniel gets 1 million euros however she is chauffered around in a GLA 200, sitting in the back all cramped

Could it be because of the presence of the real gang members in the area and potential theft during production or is it because the person in charge of the cars hasnt got a clue

wyson

3,700 posts

120 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Its downhill from there. I figured Season 1 was based on Robert Saviano’s research. It was gritty and plausible. Season 2 wasn’t as good, but watchable. Season 3 was like a regular fictional drama, I lost interest at the end of that.

fourstardan

5,695 posts

160 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Im sure with the cars you need to be inconspicuous in Naples, both from rival gangs and Carabinieri!

I loved the first few series, fly on the wall stuff, the sounds and filming were brilliant and the theme tune is awesome.

It does get a bit fantasy land midway through, but you'll definitely have some more twists to keep you going and don't forget to watch the spin off films as well shot in between the seasons.

Sopranos was good but Gomorrah feels more realistic.

BTW Saviano books are completely hard work stick to the TV show!

The Gauge

5,160 posts

29 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
I loved Gomorrah, all of it. Possibly better than Breaking Bad and Better Call Saul, which is high praise.

Edited by The Gauge on Tuesday 3rd December 22:14

Gnevans

520 posts

138 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Try Suburra Blood On Rome

Romanzo Criminale

Both mafia series worth a watch.


Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,857 posts

173 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Are the Camora gangs like the mafia? There doesnt seem to be any 'made' members, are they seperate to the 'mafia' as we know it or is that exclusive to the La Cosa Nostra

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,857 posts

173 months

Tuesday 3rd December 2024
quotequote all
Gnevans said:
Try Suburra Blood On Rome

Romanzo Criminale

Both mafia series worth a watch.
Thank you, I'll get on that after Gomorrah

fourstardan

5,695 posts

160 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
Are the Camora gangs like the mafia? There doesnt seem to be any 'made' members, are they seperate to the 'mafia' as we know it or is that exclusive to the La Cosa Nostra
No hierarchy as such its all regionalised and territory based, you then have in Naples region multiple groups all vying for top dog spot.

The Surburba one mentioned I found too similar to Gomorrah.

Jungleland

136 posts

19 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
Are the Camora gangs like the mafia? There doesnt seem to be any 'made' members, are they seperate to the 'mafia' as we know it or is that exclusive to the La Cosa Nostra
Camorra are basically the Neapolitan mafia. La cosa nostra isn't an exclusive group, it's just a catch all for the mafia in general (translates as 'our thing' or 'this thing of ours').

I don't think modern mafia in Italy like this is as 'Godfather' in as much as defined made men etc

toon10

6,773 posts

173 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
One of my favourite shows. Up there with the usual BB, Sopranos, etc. It does get less realistic as it goes but it doesn't detract from the entertainment. Gritty and violent. Suburra is also decent but not as good. Still worth watching.

Scarletpimpofnel

1,205 posts

34 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
I'm an antiques roadshow / coronation street kind of guy BUT Gomorrah gripped me. Probably because it portrays lifestyles as diametrically opposed to mine as it is possible to be. Loved it.

Deckert

640 posts

206 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
In my top 5 shows I think. I can't think of one dud episode in all of the seasons.

Honourable Dead Snark

587 posts

35 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
Got fed up of Gomorrah quite quickly and never bothered finishing it, but didn’t know why I felt that way. Looking back on it I think it was relentlessly gritty and bleak in a way which ultimately makes it too unrealistic. That and there is no reason to care about any of the characters.

Think about the greatest shows of all time, many of them also centred around crime and gangs with serious or disturbing elements. Difference is, all of them: Breaking Bad, the Wire, Game of Thrones (most of it anyway), the Sopranos etc have comedic moments and characters cracking jokes. Because in real life that is actually what happens. Just because you’re a career criminal doesn’t mean you have to be miserable the entire time.

vixen1700

26,372 posts

286 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
One of my favourite series ever. smile

Chestrockwell

Original Poster:

2,857 posts

173 months

Wednesday 4th December 2024
quotequote all
Honourable Dead Snark said:
Got fed up of Gomorrah quite quickly and never bothered finishing it, but didn’t know why I felt that way. Looking back on it I think it was relentlessly gritty and bleak in a way which ultimately makes it too unrealistic. That and there is no reason to care about any of the characters.

Think about the greatest shows of all time, many of them also centred around crime and gangs with serious or disturbing elements. Difference is, all of them: Breaking Bad, the Wire, Game of Thrones (most of it anyway), the Sopranos etc have comedic moments and characters cracking jokes. Because in real life that is actually what happens. Just because you’re a career criminal doesn’t mean you have to be miserable the entire time.
I do agree it looks depressing, perhaps its a filter they used. Even the fancy homes of the bosses looked super depressing and the beach scenes look awful like its blackpool, the show does give me 90's midlands vibes sometimes when in reality its set in Naples.

In terms of how grim the mood is, I think its quite apt, theres no glamour to that lifestyle, especially with the way the hierarchy is set up. They all come from poverty dragged into a life of crime from when they were kids and not properly compensated. I mean its all made up but if I was going to take a guess, I dont think criminals actually enjoy their lives


DeejRC

7,834 posts

98 months

Thursday 5th December 2024
quotequote all
Chestrockwell said:
Honourable Dead Snark said:
Got fed up of Gomorrah quite quickly and never bothered finishing it, but didn’t know why I felt that way. Looking back on it I think it was relentlessly gritty and bleak in a way which ultimately makes it too unrealistic. That and there is no reason to care about any of the characters.

Think about the greatest shows of all time, many of them also centred around crime and gangs with serious or disturbing elements. Difference is, all of them: Breaking Bad, the Wire, Game of Thrones (most of it anyway), the Sopranos etc have comedic moments and characters cracking jokes. Because in real life that is actually what happens. Just because you’re a career criminal doesn’t mean you have to be miserable the entire time.
I do agree it looks depressing, perhaps its a filter they used. Even the fancy homes of the bosses looked super depressing and the beach scenes look awful like its blackpool, the show does give me 90's midlands vibes sometimes when in reality its set in Naples.

In terms of how grim the mood is, I think its quite apt, theres no glamour to that lifestyle, especially with the way the hierarchy is set up. They all come from poverty dragged into a life of crime from when they were kids and not properly compensated. I mean its all made up but if I was going to take a guess, I dont think criminals actually enjoy their lives
And this is your idea of entertainment is it?
Think I’d rather watch Hallmark.

KAgantua

4,748 posts

147 months

Thursday 5th December 2024
quotequote all
It drops off massively after end of season 2 sorry

Just another crime drama with 'New ally of the season who comes out of nowhere who gets betrayed' and 'New enemy of the season who gets kiilled by the last episode' for the main guy to deal with.

The first two seasons feel very gritty and authentic though.

toon10

6,773 posts

173 months

Thursday 5th December 2024
quotequote all
I think each season was strong and I liked that it didn't glamorise the life. It was intentionally gritty, dark, violent and depressing and all the better for it. The first two seasons were the best, but I loved Blueblood character arc and storylines in later seasons.

My only real issue with the show was the Ciro coming back from the dead story which was a stretch too far. It was a massive shock when he was killed on the boat. Both unexpected and powerful. The shock of what happened added to the brilliance of the show for me. The subsequent spin off film and then his reintroduction felt like a bit of a cop out. It was like the writers realised he was one of the most loved characters so instead of going with the more realistic version where he is killed (and had no chance of surviving), they wrote him back in. Other than that, I loved it.

Slop

503 posts

237 months

Thursday 5th December 2024
quotequote all

I loved it, thought it was great.

For me, not quite the Sopranos ( although undoubtedly grittier ), liked the fact that they moved around a bit ( Germany, London, Barcelona, Riga etc )

Would recommend

S