Lockerbie A Search for the Truth
Lockerbie A Search for the Truth
Author
Discussion

Janluke

Original Poster:

2,845 posts

174 months

Friday 3rd January
quotequote all
Not seen a thread for this but watched the first one last night and was very impressed.

Follows Dr Jim Swire(Colin Firth) and the aftermath of the Lockerbie Bombing.

It's not easy viewing but sensitively handled

the-norseman

14,460 posts

187 months

Friday 3rd January
quotequote all
Will be watching this myself soon.

Nickp82

3,625 posts

109 months

Friday 3rd January
quotequote all
I’m one episode in and it seems to be a quality production

BunkMoreland

2,312 posts

23 months

Friday 3rd January
quotequote all
This is so weird for Sky to have made this as drama.

When Mr Swire was actually featured in the Sky Documentary about Lockerbie not so long ago. And given free reign to voice his opinions. Which veer between pretty likely, to grieving father looking to blame someone. (I doubt anyone will ever fully admit to anything)

https://www.facebook.com/SkyTV/videos/official-tra...



daqinggregg

4,823 posts

145 months

Saturday 4th January
quotequote all
Watched the first episode, feels wrong to say this, but the dramatisation is really well executed, well worth viewing.


Janluke

Original Poster:

2,845 posts

174 months

Saturday 4th January
quotequote all
daqinggregg said:
Watched the first episode, feels wrong to say this, but the dramatisation is really well executed, well worth viewing.
Probably growing up on a diet of Hollywood plane disasters I've never really thought about the reality of some air crashes. The thought of random debris and bodies raining down on you out of the blue is quite frightening .



llewop

3,809 posts

227 months

Saturday 4th January
quotequote all
daqinggregg said:
Watched the first episode, feels wrong to say this, but the dramatisation is really well executed, well worth viewing.
Watched some of it last night and tend to agree it is a unsettling viewing, but seems well done. Hadn't realised until the comment above that the programme was focused around a particular path of investigation/interest.

I actually went to see the wreckage at Longtown where they were collecting it and analysing things, which was a surreal first trip out from the office after completing my time as a trainee. Although we did have quite a look round, the parts we were there for were at the opposite end of the aircraft to where the bomb was.

Squadrone Rosso

3,281 posts

163 months

Saturday 4th January
quotequote all
Could well be another Mr Bates v the Post Office.

BunkMoreland

2,312 posts

23 months

Saturday 4th January
quotequote all
Squadrone Rosso said:
Could well be another Mr Bates v the Post Office.
Doubtful. Post Office scandal was domestic to the UK.

PA103 involves Libyan bomb makers and a CIA that (allegedly) found out beforehand a bomb was likely so warned staff off Pan Am flights. Too many countries and separate interests to ever get definitive answer.


Accurate, and frankly horrible animation of the bomb.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j5naaWe3nLI

We think of bombs as huge explosions, but seems the 747 was peeled apart.

Edited by BunkMoreland on Saturday 4th January 21:11

Nezquick

1,653 posts

142 months

Monday 6th January
quotequote all
We finished this off last night.

I have no idea whether Megrahi was innocent or not, but it certainly seems that way. Whether he was just a small cog in a very large machine is something we'll probably never find out, but the whole thing stinks of being one giant political cover-up which the public will never find out the truth of.

S600BSB

6,669 posts

122 months

Thursday 9th January
quotequote all
Thought it was excellent.

Google [bot]

6,802 posts

197 months

Thursday 9th January
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
Thought it was excellent.
+1. I’ve been meaning to research the whole thing, but not got around to it. I’m going to assume this was fairly balanced and about as much truth as we’re likely to get.

Blue62

9,848 posts

168 months

Thursday 9th January
quotequote all
S600BSB said:
Thought it was excellent.
Me too, raises an awful lot of disturbing questions. I do often wonder how much truth is out there, this is another example, was it just useful to blame Libya?

daqinggregg

4,823 posts

145 months

Thursday 9th January
quotequote all
Another great production, I like the way it was not over dramatised, the UK are really good at making programmes like this. The make up department certainly earned their keep.

I’m not really into conspiracy theories, however, I think most people are aware that the tail gets pinned on the most ‘convenient donkey’ in situations like this.

Agent57

2,171 posts

170 months

Sunday 12th January
quotequote all
Seen all episodes now. A good watch.

Thought I knew the general story but there have been so many twists and turns over the decades it was hard to keep track.

The contrast between his quest for the truth and his wife's wish to get on with her her life was very well presented. Shows how people try and cope in different ways.

oobster

7,458 posts

227 months

Monday 13th January
quotequote all
We watched all the episodes last week, Colin Firth was very good in it, was also interesting to watch as some of it was filmed locally to me.

I remember being on a driving lesson when the news came over the car radio about the crash.

abzmike

10,506 posts

122 months

Wednesday 15th January
quotequote all
A very compelling and high quality production, with great performance from Colin Firth, and the rest of the cast. As noted, we will never know the truth, even though the Americans are about to try another guy for involvement.
Driving up the A74 the following evening and seeing the fires still smouldering is something I’ll never forget.

daqinggregg

4,823 posts

145 months

Wednesday 15th January
quotequote all
If you enjoyed (that sounds wrong) this, I recommend you watch ‘7/7 bombings BBC 2’ it’s not a dramatisation, but rather the recollections of those involved, responders, police, politicians and victims.

Its exceptionally well crafted and produced, there is little narration from the producers, letting those involved tell (no doubt under direction) their story, it’s brought together in cohesive manner.

There are some unexpected insights from those tasked with recovery of the deceased, the police as well as politicians.

Steve_W

1,550 posts

193 months

Wednesday 15th January
quotequote all
Seems not everyone's happy (not unexpected with something as raw emotionally as this must be for them)

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cn012g8xlyzo

Siko

2,061 posts

258 months

Wednesday 15th January
quotequote all
There was an article about this in the weekend papers aswell too (sorry forgot which one) which basically refuted the programme pretty much in entirety. It basically said this was a conspiracy theory of such astonishing circumstances and the original verdicts have been looked at several times and found to be legally sound.