PETROL OR HYBRID
Author
Discussion

geek84

Original Poster:

620 posts

109 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Hi Folks

I'm thinking of buying a new car, but can't decide whether to go for a petrol or hybrid car.

Any suggestions greatly appreciated

Thank You

Luke.

11,809 posts

273 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Too many variables that you've not mentioned.

Budget?
Mileage?
Use case?
etc etc...

geek84

Original Poster:

620 posts

109 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Hi

I have a budget of around 20K and will only use is for visiting friends etc

Yahonza

3,440 posts

53 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Most or many petrols are at least petrol hybrids nowadays to get around emissions. Do you mean PHEV or MHEV?
I wouldn't bother with PHEV not great at all IMO. All those extra batteries also add extra cost too.

White-Noise

5,500 posts

271 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
geek84 said:
Hi

I have a budget of around 20K and will only use is for visiting friends etc
Do you mean new new or new to you?

You could get a chimaerasmile

BoomerPride

4,097 posts

280 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
I bought a Volvo v60 PHEV and it's great for my largely local trips. A lovely, economical motorway cruiser too.

I get to the golf club and back, 12 miles away, for 90p.

Edited by BoomerPride on Monday 7th April 21:10

Composite Guru

2,440 posts

226 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
I swapped to a Hybrid 2 1/2 years ago and not looking back.
Absolutely no interest with full EV as things stand at the moment so the hybrid fits my personal circumstances perfectly.
2.0l Corolla GR Sport HB. Get 60mpg out of it when driven correctly and maximising on energy harvesting.
£20k will buy you a fairly new example and will still fall into the 10 year warranty if you use Toyota servicing.
I have 3 Toyotas and they have all been fantastic cars.


geek84

Original Poster:

620 posts

109 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Thanks folks

ideally I am looking for a used car which is less than 36 months old

Evanivitch

25,854 posts

145 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
£20k gets you a lot of EV these days. Model 3 Performance, Polestar2 and iPace if you're feeling brave. MG4 XPower is a couple grand more.

ChrisH72

2,801 posts

75 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
I'd choose the car rather than how it's powered.

Personally I feel that hybrids are just a stop gap until everything is fully electric. I've always preferred a manual gearbox so for now a petrol or mild hybrid is my choice. If there was a car I really liked and it was a proper hybrid I'd give it a look but they still need petrol to run them which to me makes little sense. Also they seem to command a premium with people hedging their bets. With used EVs now being much more affordable I'd go down that route instead.

Muzzer79

12,674 posts

210 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
geek84 said:
Thanks folks

ideally I am looking for a used car which is less than 36 months old
How far away are the friends that this car will only be used to visit?

What are your priorities? Economy? Performance? Good handling?

What type of car do you want? Hatchback, MPV, SUV, saloon?

How long do you want to keep it for?

What brands do you want to look at?


You understand of course, that you’ve asked a very broad question…..

LightweightLouisDanvers

2,765 posts

66 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
Tell your friends to come and visit you?
No car required hehe

Gerradi

1,940 posts

143 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
A nice Lexus GS, will serve you well.

SkodaIan

937 posts

108 months

Monday 7th April 2025
quotequote all
A big factor would be whether the OP just wants transport, or a more interesting car.

As reliable and economical transport you wouldn't go far wrong with a Toyota of some sort (of which almost all models are now either hybrids or EVs). However if there are other factors which also come into play, such as driving enjoyment or having the right badge to impress the neighbours you might want to consider other manufacturers

It's also worth taking into account where the nearest dealer is, as if everything else is equal between two cars, having to go for a long trip each time a car needs servicing can be a bit tedious. In a big city you're likely to have all the mainstream manufacturers catered for, but in more provincial areas some makes can be much more hassle than others. For example, where I live the nearest Seat and Skoda dealer is about an hours drive away but other fairly equivalent makes such as Kia, Toyota and Peugeot have dealerships within 20 minutes.

brillomaster

1,704 posts

193 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
Ask a non specific question, get a non specific answer...

Get a petrol. Hybrids are st.

HTH.

Pan Pan Pan

10,725 posts

134 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
geek84 said:
Hi Folks

I'm thinking of buying a new car, but can't decide whether to go for a petrol or hybrid car.

Any suggestions greatly appreciated

Thank You
Be careful what you choose. I had a expensive high end hybrid SUV as a courtesy car for a week, and it proved to be the worst of both worlds.
It was almost useless as a pure EV because it had a pitiful range of not much more than 100 miles. It had diabolical performance and fuel consumption as an ICEV, because its petrol motor was struggling to move the near two ton weight, owing to its two (petrol and electric motors) its two fuel systems (Battery and petrol) and its large size, needed to contain its two drive trains two fuel systems and the passengers, and their luggage.
You need to consider what mode the vehicle will be used in most, Petrol or electric. and then choose the one that gives the best overall figures in `that' mode.

66HFM

798 posts

48 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
Composite Guru said:
I swapped to a Hybrid 2 1/2 years ago and not looking back.
Absolutely no interest with full EV as things stand at the moment so the hybrid fits my personal circumstances perfectly.
2.0l Corolla GR Sport HB. Get 60mpg out of it when driven correctly and maximising on energy harvesting.
£20k will buy you a fairly new example and will still fall into the 10 year warranty if you use Toyota servicing.
I have 3 Toyotas and they have all been fantastic cars.

My father-in-law has one of these although in white.
I've only been out in it once but I was very impressed, I also think its a great looking car and is kept garaged.
He's retired and only really makes a twice weekly trip to the golf club, I have my eyes on it for the future....

paul_c123

1,871 posts

16 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
A plug in hybrid is the best of both worlds, if its done well. I'd get one of them.

Evanivitch

25,854 posts

145 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
paul_c123 said:
A plug in hybrid is the best of both worlds, if its done well. I'd get one of them.
More often than not it's worst of both. Some exceptions.

Ankh87

1,113 posts

125 months

Tuesday 8th April 2025
quotequote all
Evanivitch said:
paul_c123 said:
A plug in hybrid is the best of both worlds, if its done well. I'd get one of them.
More often than not it's worst of both. Some exceptions.
That's due to people not using them correctly. A plug-in hybrid needs you to set the destination in the satnav so it can work out where and how to use the battery. So if you go from A to B only it will discharge the full battery accordingly. If you go A to B to A, then it will do the same. The point is you charge up when you stop. Most people don't do that so either run out of charge or never charge up.