Dianne Abbott - Suspended - Again

Dianne Abbott - Suspended - Again

Author
Discussion

Who_Goes_Blue

Original Poster:

1,300 posts

186 months

Thursday
quotequote all
For the same thing as last time. State of it

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c4g8v33g1dgo

CambsBill

2,238 posts

193 months

Thursday
quotequote all
She can go & join Jezzers new party now. Maybe be appointed Shadow Shadow Chancellor

Timothy Bucktu

16,173 posts

215 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Dianne being a bit racist you say?? Whatever next rofl

brake fader

1,833 posts

50 months

Thursday
quotequote all
It seems all this racist talk has her in the speech gulag, funny how things backfire on certain folk.

Derek Smith

47,519 posts

263 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Lost the whip and the plot.

ChocolateFrog

31,959 posts

188 months

Thursday
quotequote all
She can't help herself.

BOR

5,010 posts

270 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Who_Goes_Blue said:
For the same thing as last time. State of it
Would you be so kind as to explain what she said and what was wrong, but in your own words, not what it says in the piece?

DrDeAtH

3,650 posts

247 months

Thursday
quotequote all
She lost the plot 10.years ago....

TheLurker

1,500 posts

211 months

Thursday
quotequote all
I can't believe I'm saying this, but I can't actually get too upset by her comments.

God, I feel dirty now!

John D.

19,278 posts

224 months

Thursday
quotequote all
ChocolateFrog said:
She can't help herself.
She does seem a bit thick.

Or it's deliberate so she can join Corbyn and Sultana.

NDA

23,195 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
The 16 year olds will vote for her. Innit.

Who_Goes_Blue

Original Poster:

1,300 posts

186 months

Thursday
quotequote all
BOR said:
Who_Goes_Blue said:
For the same thing as last time. State of it
Would you be so kind as to explain what she said and what was wrong, but in your own words, not what it says in the piece?
I would not - it would be a waste of my time going by your past posts

Clockwork Cupcake

78,003 posts

287 months

Yesterday (02:40)
quotequote all
So, wait, she said antisemitism is different from racism, and that the abuse travellers experience is different from racism, but said that it is all bad including dissing on gingers, and somehow this is bad?

Is the issue that she in some ways diminished the rest? I think antisemitism is doing pretty well in standing up for itself, personally, and even has its own word.

Also, Diane Abbot has been the butt of too many jokes about her political gaffes that are thinly disguised racism and misogyny. To then accuse her of some sort of racism thing feels like the "crowning turd on the cowpat" as Blackadder put it.

KingNothing

3,238 posts

168 months

Yesterday (07:18)
quotequote all
Surprised she hasn't already joined Jezbollah.

768

16,717 posts

111 months

Yesterday (07:34)
quotequote all
The left eats itself, again.

DJC76

13,160 posts

140 months

Yesterday (07:44)
quotequote all
Clockwork Cupcake said:
So, wait, she said antisemitism is different from racism, and that the abuse travellers experience is different from racism, but said that it is all bad including dissing on gingers, and somehow this is bad?

Is the issue that she in some ways diminished the rest? I think antisemitism is doing pretty well in standing up for itself, personally, and even has its own word.

Also, Diane Abbot has been the butt of too many jokes about her political gaffes that are thinly disguised racism and misogyny. To then accuse her of some sort of racism thing feels like the "crowning turd on the cowpat" as Blackadder put it.
Yeah the idea she has trivialised or minimised the experiences of certain groups by pointing out that they experience racism in a different way is clumsy and in some cases plain wrong but is it racist or egregious? Not to me. She does seem to open her mouth before choosing the words that are going to come out so my sympathies are limited but I can’t stand faux outrage.

768

16,717 posts

111 months

Yesterday (07:45)
quotequote all
DJC76 said:
Yeah the idea she has trivialised or minimised the experiences of certain groups by pointing out that they experience racism in a different way is clumsy and in some cases plain wrong but is it racist...
Yes.

Who_Goes_Blue

Original Poster:

1,300 posts

186 months

Yesterday (07:52)
quotequote all
Can Dianne explain how it is different and present her league table of racism?

I`m obviously naive and believe racism is racism and its all just as bad

alock

4,391 posts

226 months

Yesterday (07:54)
quotequote all
Surely no one has taken her seriously since:

"I suppose some people will judge that on balance Mao did more good than harm"

Gecko1978

11,420 posts

172 months

Yesterday (07:56)
quotequote all
Clockwork Cupcake said:
So, wait, she said antisemitism is different from racism, and that the abuse travellers experience is different from racism, but said that it is all bad including dissing on gingers, and somehow this is bad?

Is the issue that she in some ways diminished the rest? I think antisemitism is doing pretty well in standing up for itself, personally, and even has its own word.
So the second paragraph you kind of what agree with her hmmmmm.

Look all discrimination based of protected characteristics is bad. Racism is bad not just because it's unpleasant but because over 1000s of years it's been at the heart of war an conflict.

To dimish one ethnic groups issues v another is bad.

I would say the slave trade in the 1800s was horrific but I would also argue the events of Oct 7th were equally horrific and then more recent events where the other side were killed getting aid also horrific. All 3 are driven by racism. It's much easier i suspect to shoot an unarmed civilian getting food aid if you don't value them as an equal. Much like it was easier to buy a human being to engage in forced labour if you did not see them as equal.

Diane Abbot maybe unwell but she also may well be a vile racisit