car pulling to left , solved by swapping left and right, why
car pulling to left , solved by swapping left and right, why
Author
Discussion

sunnyb13

Original Poster:

1,139 posts

56 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
car pulling to left and needing a lot of steering input to keep straight at higher speeds.

Swapped my front left and front right wheels and it seems to have resolved. Any ideas what would have caused it?

GeniusOfLove

4,129 posts

30 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Crap/knackered tyre or less likely but damaged wheel.

Or badly fitted wheel originally and now resolved, some crap on the hub stopping the wheel from fitting totally flush could cause mischief. Swap them back and see what happens!

sunnyb13

Original Poster:

1,139 posts

56 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
GeniusOfLove said:
Crap/knackered tyre or less likely but damaged wheel.

Or badly fitted wheel originally and now resolved, some crap on the hub stopping the wheel from fitting totally flush could cause mischief. Swap them back and see what happens!
Thanks, swapped back and issue is back. Assuming it’s a bad tyre and not a balancing issue?

s p a c e m a n

11,412 posts

166 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Are the tyres the same size? Wouldn't be the first time it's happened.

bennno

14,410 posts

287 months

Wednesday
quotequote all

Are the tyres directional ?

were they fitted on the wrong sides?

SlimJim16v

7,023 posts

161 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
What's the wear like across the tread?

dhutch

17,043 posts

215 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Seems odd if they are the same make/model/ageg of tyre, ie a fully match pair and correctly fitted
I would be having the tracking (and or full wheel alignment) checked. As well as making sure they havent got one on backwards.

If they are mismatched ditch finders, god knows!

Short Grain

3,318 posts

238 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
No help to the op I'm afraid, but years ago my then director bought an old mini, with a Honda Vtec engine shoehorned in! Upgraded brakes, suspension etc. The thing f*ckin flew! But, above 60 he'd get an annoying vibration, which got worse the faster he went!
Took it to a couple of places near him who checked the wheels, tyres, bearings, balancing, everything they could think of, no better. Must've cost him a fortune! Finally he was told to take it to the so called Guru of these cars up North, he was in Essex. Think it was Batley or near there, but it was over 20yrs ago. He drove it up, under 60 all the way, so up the A1. He was knackered by the time he got to Hull, where I am.
Anyway, drove to the expert next morning, dropped off the mini, and I took him round a few customers while the expert 'tinkered'. He got a call a couple of hours later, "Cars done, come and pick it up when you're ready!"
Turned out it was a minute flat spot, on one of the front tyres I think, that wasn't easy to see. 1 New'ish tyre later, job done. Hi Andy, if you're reading this . wavey



BunkMoreland

2,609 posts

25 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
sunnyb13 said:
car pulling to left and needing a lot of steering input to keep straight at higher speeds.

Swapped my front left and front right wheels and it seems to have resolved. Any ideas what would have caused it?
Your alignment is out.
Your old tyres are worn as a result of that.

When you swapped the tyres side to side. The wear on the tyres is cancelling out the mis alignment of the suspension/steering components

So if you imagine that the left front has positive camber. And the right front has negative camber

Exaggerated, but you get the idea


The most wear on those tyres will be where the red stars are.

When you swapped the tyres side to side. You are then going to wear the tyres in a different area. The blue stars, the part of the tyre that is nowhere near as worn out



However, if you dont sort the alignment, in due course you'll knacker the tyres again and be back to the same bad handling

Make sense?

sunnyb13

Original Poster:

1,139 posts

56 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I had Hunter 4 wheel alignment done multiple times

E-bmw

11,417 posts

170 months

Thursday
quotequote all
BunkMoreland said:
sunnyb13 said:
car pulling to left and needing a lot of steering input to keep straight at higher speeds.

Swapped my front left and front right wheels and it seems to have resolved. Any ideas what would have caused it?
Your alignment is out.
Your old tyres are worn as a result of that.


The most wear on those tyres will be where the red stars are.

When you swapped the tyres side to side. You are then going to wear the tyres in a different area. The blue stars, the part of the tyre that is nowhere near as worn out



However, if you dont sort the alignment, in due course you'll knacker the tyres again and be back to the same bad handling

Make sense?
I think you need to take another look at your pic.

When you swap the wheels side to side the wear is still in EXACTLY the same place.

TwinKam

3,358 posts

113 months

Thursday
quotequote all
E-bmw said:
BunkMoreland said:
sunnyb13 said:
car pulling to left and needing a lot of steering input to keep straight at higher speeds.

Swapped my front left and front right wheels and it seems to have resolved. Any ideas what would have caused it?
Your alignment is out.
Your old tyres are worn as a result of that.


The most wear on those tyres will be where the red stars are.

When you swapped the tyres side to side. You are then going to wear the tyres in a different area. The blue stars, the part of the tyre that is nowhere near as worn out



However, if you dont sort the alignment, in due course you'll knacker the tyres again and be back to the same bad handling

Make sense?
I think you need to take another look at your pic.

When you swap the wheels side to side the wear is still in EXACTLY the same place.
Not at all. The outside edge is worn on the NS tyre and the inner edge on the OS tyre.
Swap the wheels side-to-side and what do you have?....

E-bmw

11,417 posts

170 months

Thursday
quotequote all
TwinKam said:
E-bmw said:
BunkMoreland said:
sunnyb13 said:
car pulling to left and needing a lot of steering input to keep straight at higher speeds.

Swapped my front left and front right wheels and it seems to have resolved. Any ideas what would have caused it?
Your alignment is out.
Your old tyres are worn as a result of that.


The most wear on those tyres will be where the red stars are.

When you swapped the tyres side to side. You are then going to wear the tyres in a different area. The blue stars, the part of the tyre that is nowhere near as worn out



However, if you dont sort the alignment, in due course you'll knacker the tyres again and be back to the same bad handling

Make sense?
I think you need to take another look at your pic.

When you swap the wheels side to side the wear is still in EXACTLY the same place.
Not at all. The outside edge is worn on the NS tyre and the inner edge on the OS tyre.
Swap the wheels side-to-side and what do you have?....
Sorry, my bad, it is early!