Recruitment predicament
Author
Discussion

Toyoda

Original Poster:

1,567 posts

119 months

I've got an interview next week for a job (let's call it Job A) in my local council, but today another job (let's call it Job B) has been advertised with the same local council, in a completely different service but obviously it's the same employer and HR department etc. As is sods law, I'm more interested in the job that's just popped up today (plus the pay is better) than the one for which I have an interview next week. I fully intend to apply for Job B.

I know it's all hypothetical BUT if I get offered Job A next week how on earth do I play it with regards to the matter of my application for Job B? The fact it's the same organisation probably means I'd have to come clean with the manager of Job A and tell them I have an outstanding application elsewhere in the council but I'm not sure how well it would be received and if good faith would instantly be lost? For info, the interview for Job A is 11th Nov, the closing date for applications for Job B isn't until 19th Nov, then there's usually a few days gap while they shortlist, so I'd expect to hear if I've been invited to interview for Job B early w/c 24 Nov at the latest, then interviews for Job B are already scheduled for 3rd Dec.

I've googled this predicament and in every case the advice is for jobs across 2 different employers but my position is different in that it's the same employer. Any tactful suggestions welcomed! Many thanks.





Dynion Araf Uchaf

4,963 posts

242 months

Have you considered that they might interview you at the same time for both jobs. A decent recruiter doesn’t wait for deadlines to happen

Just be positive about both roles. Especially if you have e a job already and aren t desperate.

Also you might find the second job the manager is a bit of a throbber. Which will make it easier

fourstardan

5,909 posts

163 months

I'd speak to the HR department and explain and see what they think.

They work for the hiring manager at the end of the day so won't be too bothered to me.

Tim_D

309 posts

171 months

Yesterday (03:40)
quotequote all
Honestly, I think I’d just be upfront about it from the start. I'd position myself as motivated to work for the council regardless of Job A or Job B outlining suitability for both roles and use the interview process for both me and the council to determine the best fit. I wouldn’t express a firm preference upfront - especially not based on pay. Instead framing myself as motivated by fit, and where I can add the most value, if I pushed I would outline why my experience is better aligned to Job B but the interview process is a good opportunity to validate.

If they see you as good talent, they’ll be happy to have you in either role. I don’t think being open about your interest in both would do you any disservice - if anything, it shows commitment and genuine enthusiasm to the Council. There’s a chance it creates a bit of internal tug-of-war if both hiring managers want you, but that’s not a bad position to be in.