Combi boiler- running a cold tap knocks the heating off?
Combi boiler- running a cold tap knocks the heating off?
Author
Discussion

TT86

Original Poster:

197 posts

43 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Afternoon folks

We have a fairly recent Worcester Bosch combi boiler. I've noticed that when the central heating is switched on any use of a cold tap knocks it off and it takes at least a minute to kick back in again.

When the washing machine was filling earlier the boiler took forever to finally kick back in and start heating again.

Is this normal? I know the hot tap would over ride the heating but it's a right pain if the cold does the same!

Lincsls1

3,856 posts

160 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
No, that is not normal.

ianrb

1,620 posts

160 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Running the cold water tap could be causing the pressure at the boiler inlet to drop & thus tripping the boiler. Would need to be crap plumbing though. Is it an old house?

Lincsls1

3,856 posts

160 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
ianrb said:
Running the cold water tap could be causing the pressure at the boiler inlet to drop & thus tripping the boiler. Would need to be crap plumbing though. Is it an old house?
Eh? That has nothing to do with the heating control.

TT86

Original Poster:

197 posts

43 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Thanks folks. The house is 1905 so it wouldn't surprise me if the plumbing was ropey!

I just tested it again once the boiler has been running for an hour and it didn't happen that time. Seems to be when the temperature is lower on initial start up.

Trustmeimadoctor

14,247 posts

175 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Are you sure your not calling for hot water?

littleredrooster

6,066 posts

216 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Lincsls1 said:
Eh? That has nothing to do with the heating control.
Yes, I think it does. Our W-B combi used to do exactly the same. I suspect there is a pressure sensor in the DHW side of the boiler and if it drops below the cutoff level, it shuts the flame down for protection even if DHW isn't being used.

With ours, also, the bigger mystery was why the CH pressure gauge would fluctuate when the cold water tap was turned on suddenly. I never understood how the sealed loop side of the CH could react like this.

Lincsls1

3,856 posts

160 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Nope, there is no 'pressure' sensor on the HW circuit. Just a flow sensor.
Many WB boilers don't even have system pressure sensors, and will run with '0' on the pressure happily enough.
The latest ones do though, like the Lifestyle range for example, but again this has nothing to do with the HW circuit.
It is a mystery. I'm just wondering if somehow when a cold tap is run, or moreover turned off, the 'back lash' through pipework might just trigger the hot water flow switch, very briefly, causing the boiler to stop the heating, which triggers an anti-cycle type timer before the heating kicks in again.
I wonder if a surge arrester would cure it.

TT86

Original Poster:

197 posts

43 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Trustmeimadoctor said:
Are you sure your not calling for hot water?
No definitely not. Both the washing machine filling and the cold tap had the same effect

TT86

Original Poster:

197 posts

43 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Lincsls1 said:
Nope, there is no 'pressure' sensor on the HW circuit. Just a flow sensor.
Many WB boilers don't even have system pressure sensors, and will run with '0' on the pressure happily enough.
The latest ones do though, like the Lifestyle range for example, but again this has nothing to do with the HW circuit.
It is a mystery. I'm just wondering if somehow when a cold tap is run, or moreover turned off, the 'back lash' through pipework might just trigger the hot water flow switch, very briefly, causing the boiler to stop the heating, which triggers an anti-cycle type timer before the heating kicks in again.
I wonder if a surge arrester would cure it.
That's an interesting idea thanks. Due a service in the new year so I'll get the plumber to investigate and see if this could be a solution.

Most frustrating as it makes heating up a cold Edwardian house pretty slow unless you ban the family from touching the taps for the first hour!

Crumpet

4,849 posts

200 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Could you try closing off the cold feed to the boiler and then run a cold tap to see whether it still cuts the heating?

TT86

Original Poster:

197 posts

43 months

Wednesday 26th November
quotequote all
Crumpet said:
Could you try closing off the cold feed to the boiler and then run a cold tap to see whether it still cuts the heating?
That's a good shout thanks! Will give that a go in the morning.

GasEngineer

1,890 posts

82 months

Thursday 27th November
quotequote all
Another check is to turn a cold tap on/off when the heating is not on. You will probably hear the boiler fan kick in.

As mentioned above it is sensing a pressure blip on the hot side which is what triggers the boiler to fire in hot water mode. If the heating is on it shuts off the heating and switches to hot water. If you run a bath the heating won't be on until the bath is filled and there is no longer a hot water demand.

You can usually cure it by installing a shock arrester in the supply pipework, It's good practice anyway to fit one with a new combi.

https://www.screwfix.com/p/flomasta-vessel-shock-a...

andy43

12,262 posts

274 months

Thursday 27th November
quotequote all
TT86 said:
Lincsls1 said:
Nope, there is no 'pressure' sensor on the HW circuit. Just a flow sensor.
Many WB boilers don't even have system pressure sensors, and will run with '0' on the pressure happily enough.
The latest ones do though, like the Lifestyle range for example, but again this has nothing to do with the HW circuit.
It is a mystery. I'm just wondering if somehow when a cold tap is run, or moreover turned off, the 'back lash' through pipework might just trigger the hot water flow switch, very briefly, causing the boiler to stop the heating, which triggers an anti-cycle type timer before the heating kicks in again.
I wonder if a surge arrester would cure it.
That's an interesting idea thanks. Due a service in the new year so I'll get the plumber to investigate and see if this could be a solution.

Most frustrating as it makes heating up a cold Edwardian house pretty slow unless you ban the family from touching the taps for the first hour!
I’ve seen an Ideal boiler fire up momentarily when the cold tap near it is closed suddenly as the shock trips the HW demand flow switch into thinking a hot tap has been opened so as an amateur I’d guess at this too.

Philvrs

683 posts

117 months

Thursday 27th November
quotequote all
I had that with a new compact wb combi replacing a system boiler, luckily i noticed on the night after installation and the heating engineer was due back the next day, he fit a check valve inline ( i cant remember which pipe, cold water feed i think) to fix it. Said it was something to do with a new water meter? Didn’t believe him but it worked, that was approx 15 years ago.
New boiler this year in a different house has a surge arrestor fitted from the start.