RE: Modern classic convertibles | Six of the Best
RE: Modern classic convertibles | Six of the Best
Today

Modern classic convertibles | Six of the Best

Big engines, bigger skies, middling spend...


Aston Martin Vantage, 2008, 31k, £35,490

There was a story doing the rounds a couple of years ago that suggested UK’s love affair with the convertible was coming to an end. Fat chance. Open-top motoring promises to combine three preoccupations of the British enthusiast: the fruity sound of a petrol engine, the fluttering kiss of wind in your hair, and an abiding fascination with weather conditions. The fact that you can have the whole lot parcelled up into a new breed of modern classic (i.e. the sort of cars being built 15 to 20 years ago), only makes the daydream more appealing. Case in point? The thought of owning a V8-powered Vantage for the used hot hatch money. Granted, old Aston ownership is not without significant peril - but the pay-off, when the sun is out and all is well, is one of those experiences that makes life worth living. 

See the original advert

Porsche 911 Carrera, 2005, 59k, PH Auction

If you prefer your convertible to come with Germanic reputation for build quality, then naturally you’ll need to look no further than Porsche. If you prefer the mid-engined niceties of the Boxster, then we totally get that, but we’ve gone for the slightly more senior prospect of the 911 Carrera - precisely the car Aston failed to knock off its pedestal. Later, much pricier iterations of the 997 are held up as some of the finest sports cars ever made, but even the entry-level 325hp convertible has it all going on; the sound and fury of the naturally aspirated flat-six is almost worth the price of admission on its own. This one, due for auction on Sunday, has seen its fair share of owners, but the service history is comprehensive and the MOT history spotless. It’s as good a time as any to see what all the fuss is about. 

See the original advert

Jaguar XKR-S, 2011, 34k, £56,995

By rights - and certainly for the asking price - you would probably be better off buying an F-Type than its gnarly predecessor. But there is something about the XK that Jaguar didn’t quite recapture in its better-looking follow-up. Of course, it helps if old-school charm comes with some new-school moves, and the 5.0-litre supercharged V8, in its 550hp flavour certainly brought that. This being the XKR-S, you can expect a full-throated sound, of the sort that no manufacturer today would get away with. Still looks the part, too, especially in red. This one has been sparingly used and while its MOT expired last month, it seems to have been sailing through them up that point. An outlier now in the grand scheme of things - though if it’s heads you’re hoping to turn, look no further. 

See the original advert

Alfa Romeo 4C, 2016, 19k, £42,995

Though almost a decade newer than some cars here, the Alfa Romeo 4C had classic written over it almost from the day of conception. It carried that badge, for starters, plus it was going to be carbon tubbed, stripped out, and beautiful to look at. The ‘Mini McLaren’ headlines were written before anyone was behind the strange little steering wheel. Alas, the 4C wasn’t the greatest roadster in the world to drive, it being hard work and unpredictable, though that contributed to the mystique. It was characterful, it was raw, it was - if nothing else - not a car you’d forget in a hurry. Now, with suspension, geometry and powertrain upgrades available from the aftermarket, the 4C’s potential can be fulfilled. With that gorgeous styling untouched. Alfa won’t make anything like it again, and few were produced in the first place, so residuals are fairly strong - this one is almost a decade old and still commanding more than £40k.  

See the original advert

Maserati GranCabrio, 2010, 18k, £27,995

For those who prefer their Italian roadsters a little less highly strung though still beautiful, the Maserati GranCabrio presents a very strong case for itself. Even a decade and a half from its introduction, it’s hard to think of many better-looking four-seat cabrios than the original drop-top GranTurismo. It was elegant, refined and debonair, just the kind of cabriolet you’d imagine Maserati should make. As the GranCabrio arrived later than the hardtop, too, there’s no need to avoid the lower-powered V8 - because it wasn’t available. All have the 4.7 and at least 440hp, meaning the sort of performance to really do the drop-dead styling justice. Don’t forget the spectacular sound, a truly operatic V8 howl that’ll be all the better for no roof. This one has been mollycoddled by three owners since 2010, so much so that it basically presents as new. With tan leather and silver wheels, it’s as stylish as ever - and now new Polo money… 

See the original advert

BMW Z4 M Roadster, 2007, 70k, £18,450

If the Z4 M Coupe always suffered for comparisons with the M3, there are no such concerns for the Roadster. Because if it’s a drop-top M car you’re after, who could really look past this handsome hot rod for a 3 Series convertible? Your friends can make their own way - you’d want to be seen, and you’d want to be driving, the only Z4 M Roadster ever made. And now we know, thanks to BMW’s announcement this week, the only Z4 M that’ll ever exist. Not that it needed any help in the modern classic cool stakes, with that engine, a standard manual, and a design that’s looking better with each passing year. Especially this one, in a Ferrari-esque Imola Red over Champagne leather. The condition is lovely, the service file ‘huge’ and the MOT history impeccable - it’s really been loved for 18 years. We believed for a while that a BMW like this wouldn’t exist again, and now it’s been confirmed. If not now, when? 

See the original advert

Author
Discussion

wistec1

Original Poster:

695 posts

60 months

Alfa 4C for my money but it would have to have the muzzled handling upgrades so it didn't bite me.

My ownership experience with my Aston DBS and their dealerships has poisoned my mind to never revisit the maker ever again. Having said that the V12 Vantage manual is the one to have.

Which leaves the Porsche as the second choice for no other reason except I've never driven or owned one yet.



Edited by wistec1 on Saturday 29th November 04:55

blue al

1,222 posts

178 months

Jag feels expensive, when a nice f type V8 would be similar money

V8 astons seem to have been available in the low 30’s forever so feels a far safer place for your cash for a couple of summers or a retirement vehicle

Not seeing much value In the others but attractive cars a lower price points
( apart from the one comes with a trident feels too big for the b roads the others would enjoy )


Edited by blue al on Saturday 29th November 05:59

timberman

1,376 posts

234 months

Out of these it would be the 4c, none of the others interest me,

but, I think if I were in the market for a car to enjoy on summer days for similar money, I'd probably try and find a good 981 era Boxster gts instead.

Billy_Whizzzz

2,430 posts

162 months

You’d be mad buying the 911 without an 8-10k slush fund for bore score - sure it might not develop if you’re lucky but why would you risk it? I say this as a Porsche obsessive. If you want a 997 get a Gen 2. As many also say the Z4 M is rubbish in terms of its handling - never confidence inspiring when pressing on regardless of the set up. A Boxster is a revelation for keen drivers by comparison, despite the ubiquity.

stuart100

1,002 posts

76 months

wistec1 said:
Alfa 4C for my money but it would have to have the muzzled handling upgrades so it didn't bite me.

My ownership experience with my Aston DBS and their dealerships has poisoned my mind to never revisit the maker ever again. Having said that the V12 Vantage manual is the one to have.

Which leaves the Porsche as the second choice for no other reason except I've never driven or owned one yet.



Edited by wistec1 on Saturday 29th November 04:55
Did you have the 2008 era of DBS or the one they just stopped making? I am interested in getting the former.

Mark_Blanchard

1,005 posts

274 months

“Germanic reputation for build quality.” On a 997.1 with bore scoring and IMS failures, no thanks. I think the Aston engine is more reliable.

Kipsrs

617 posts

68 months

The GranCabrio looks great value at only 18,000 miles however, digging a bit deeper for some reason the tyre history isn’t great for a prestige sports car! On looking back through all of the histories the Porsche and Alfa look the safest bets. . Porsche for me!

edoverheels

520 posts

124 months

Great list, I love a convertible. I’d probably go for the Aston, especially with a manual.

Robertb

3,029 posts

257 months

Same money as the Jag buys this

https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/11437214

Or a bit less an earlier V10
https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/18987085

Edited by Robertb on Saturday 29th November 08:18

Chubbyross

4,803 posts

104 months

Billy_Whizzzz said:
You d be mad buying the 911 without an 8-10k slush fund for bore score - sure it might not develop if you re lucky but why would you risk it? I say this as a Porsche obsessive. If you want a 997 get a Gen 2. As many also say the Z4 M is rubbish in terms of its handling - never confidence inspiring when pressing on regardless of the set up. A Boxster is a revelation for keen drivers by comparison, despite the ubiquity.
I’ve always had a slush fund available when buying secondhand Porsches from this era. Not just for bore scoring but anything that can crop up during a service. I had a 997.2 Turbo that threw up a £4.5k bill one year for various bits and pieces. I’d want to do the same for the Aston too. Similar brand taxes as Porsche apply to spares and maintenance. These pages have been filled with buyers complaining when buying cheap, old Porsches and then confronted with ruinous bills. Do tons of research, buy from decent dealers and go into any purchases with your eyes wide open. And a healthy slush fund!

Laup99

210 posts

247 months

Had a dream garage of a 4C coupe and a Boxster for the sunny days.

Lost a space in the garage so now currently have a 4.7 Vanatge convertible to have the best of both worlds.

4C was sorted with the Alfa works blocks/upgrades and change of tyres. I miss it everyday and when things change will get another one. Thank god for the early reviews as think this helps keeps prices low at the moment becuase unless you drive a sorted one... people are put off.

If it was more practical would be the only car (took the Aston to France for a week in the summer ) love my Aston though..... 4C coupe along side would be the dream.

Its Just Adz

17,055 posts

228 months

Honestly, don't fancy any of those.

Robertb

3,029 posts

257 months

Its Just Adz said:
Honestly, don't fancy any of those.
I was disappointed not to see an Evoke or Tiguan cabriolet.

https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/19528155

robemcdonald

9,640 posts

215 months

I came to see what variety of Boxster was listed and instead saw a 911…

That’s bonkers.

Its Just Adz

17,055 posts

228 months

Robertb said:
I was disappointed not to see an Evoke or Tiguan cabriolet.

https://www.pistonheads.com/buy/listing/19528155
Brave choice!!

I'd probably go (boring choice I know) for a Boxster.

ducnick

2,106 posts

262 months

So close with the jag, but why go for a xkrs, when a nice xkr will cost 1/2 as much and deliver 99% of the enjoyment? I would also suggest that the xkr is better looking than the xkrs with fewer aero modifications… and better looking than the f type!

Lockhouse

296 posts

218 months

Bentley W12 GTC please.

robemcdonald

9,640 posts

215 months

Also. Why no F Type? Too young? I’m that case why the 4C?

The more I look at the list the more questions I have. Maybe one left field choice would be good, but the list seems mostly left field.

Firebobby

885 posts

58 months

It'd have to be the Beemer for me. IMHO probably the safest option, boring I know but safe.

GreatScott2016

2,061 posts

107 months

Firebobby said:
It'd have to be the Beemer for me. IMHO probably the safest option, boring I know but safe.
If I was forced to pick, I’d go with the BMW for the same reason, but as I’m generally not a fan of convertibles, it’s academic really smile