Young Sherlock from Guy Ritchie
Young Sherlock from Guy Ritchie
Author
Discussion

SpeedBash

Original Poster:

2,624 posts

212 months

Wednesday 24th December 2025
quotequote all

dukeboy749r

3,270 posts

235 months

Wednesday 24th December 2025
quotequote all
Is the lack of other comments, telling?

I was really taken with Endeavour more than Morse but this feels as though it is Guy doing what Guy knows best - and that might not really work for this character.

JoshSm

3,887 posts

62 months

Wednesday 24th December 2025
quotequote all
I'm not sure if there was a demand for this, and some Guy Ritchie stuff has been utterly terrible.

I have no feelings on this one way or the other.

But who or whatever did the 'poster' image did a terrible job of throwing it together, was it AI or the intern?

SpeedBash

Original Poster:

2,624 posts

212 months

Thursday 5th February
quotequote all

SpeedBash

Original Poster:

2,624 posts

212 months

TheAngryDog

12,915 posts

234 months

Saturday 7th March
quotequote all
4 episodes in and I'm quite enjoying it.

absolutely zero canon, but I am ok with that. Also really like the dynamic between Sherlock and Moriarty. I like Moriarty as a character in this as well.

biggbn

30,771 posts

245 months

Saturday 7th March
quotequote all
Yup, enjoyable nonsense without reinventing the character completely. Liking it.

Blib

47,347 posts

222 months

Saturday 7th March
quotequote all
Me too.

Young Irons is the spit of his dad.

C69

1,149 posts

37 months

Saturday 7th March
quotequote all
I've watched a couple of episodes. It's entertaining and it doesn't take itself too seriously. I shall be watching more.

Countdown

47,916 posts

221 months

Tuesday 10th March
quotequote all
C69 said:
I've watched a couple of episodes. It's entertaining and it doesn't take itself too seriously. I shall be watching more.
Same here.

Liking the "Mind Palace" expositions but slightly disappointed that he's not doing much Sherlock-type deducing.

page3

5,154 posts

276 months

Tuesday 10th March
quotequote all
I'm quite enjoying it.... although it's not as good as Dead Boy Detectives which had a similar vibe, and was cancelled after one series.

dukeboy749r

3,270 posts

235 months

Friday 13th March
quotequote all
Having been a sceptic, now having watched it, I am convert.

Love the references and a great way to introduce those characters we know from the books but also some other Holmes 'hooks'.

Edited by dukeboy749r on Monday 23 March 17:46

Countdown

47,916 posts

221 months

Sunday 22nd March
quotequote all
Still ploughing through this smile

Well worth watching, up to Ep6 at the moment and hoping there’s a second season.

dukeboy749r

3,270 posts

235 months

Monday 23rd March
quotequote all
I'm finding the characters ability to be somewhere 'new' in moments, coupled with their perfectly tailored (and suitable) wardrobe, a little grating.

Some flaws in how immaculate folk all look, having to do 'ordinary' things (go to the bank to get local money or an advance on funds, you know, the stuff that helps tell a real story (for which I'm thankful to one particular English teacher, who pointed out [whilst we at first laughed] that in "The Old Man and the Sea", the fisherman did actually, at one stage, have to have a piss).

All this is missing and it's a little (dare I say) too slick.

Mycroft as a character, is nowhere near the equivalent of Sherlock mentally, which is not the impression I got from the original stories. However, the portrayal of James Moriarty is brilliantly done - so far, at least.

Countdown

47,916 posts

221 months

Monday 23rd March
quotequote all
dukeboy749r said:
Mycroft as a character, is nowhere near the equivalent of Sherlock mentally, which is not the impression I got from the original stories. However, the portrayal of James Moriarty is brilliantly done - so far, at least.
Completely agree. IIRC Mycroft was supposed to be cleverer than Holmes but let down by the fact that he was a bit of a lazyarse

Moriarty seems to be a far more interesting character than Sherlock biggrin

and may the good Lord forgive me for having insalubrious thoughts about Mrs Holmes biggrin