Public locations to change a car engine
Public locations to change a car engine
Author
Discussion

alone wolf

Original Poster:

4 posts

I've got a car with a goosed engine. The motor still starts and propels the car but I'd like to stick a new lump in it, the problem is I don't have any private driveway space to complete the job. Has anyone completed a similar job in a quiet public area?

Huntsman

9,017 posts

271 months

When I started messing about with cars in the 80's this was happening in every car park most weekends.

I did a Chevette and a TR7 in a car park.

I reckon these days someone woumd find cause to make a fuss.

brillomaster

1,641 posts

191 months

Got any friends with driveways you could use? Or maybe even a car park at work?

I've got a spare garage im lending to a mate to refurbish the engine in his classic mini - no light or power, but he's very appreciative of the space.

FilH

997 posts

165 months

Gotta factor in getting stuck with something not fitting roght and sanpping off and having to leave the job half finished, then left overnight.

Smint

2,729 posts

56 months

Back in the 70's i removed engines and gearboxes a few times on the road outside my house, no one said a thing (none of us were rich), so long as you tidy up after yourself and don't leave an oil slick on the road.

paradigital

1,066 posts

173 months

Replaced my friend s E34 525i engine on the road outside his house back in the early 2000s.

CSR Performance

143 posts

9 months

You need a nice quiet multistory at this time of year. Preferably an enclosed one to be out of the wind. Find a quiet corner of a level near the top. Drive in to the space so you're working away from the traffic and ideally get a friend with an SUV/MPV/van to park next to you. (I am not taking any further questions about any experience in this field.)

If you are very lucky one of those rent-a-ramp type places might be near you, but I think there's only about 3 left in the country now!

fooman

1,002 posts

85 months

I changed a wheel in a work carpark once, which involved leaving car on bricks for a couple of hours. Got a right roasting from security.

Foss62

1,635 posts

86 months

fooman said:
I changed a wheel in a work carpark once, which involved leaving car on bricks for a couple of hours. Got a right roasting from security.
The only thing that is remarkable about this, is that ‘security’ didn’t like it.

In the 21st century, a lack of spare wheels seems to have (fortunately) gone hand in hand with much greater tyre reliability.

Go back just a little bit further and you will find a whole generation who thought nothing of changing wheels at work, and in many other less satisfactory locations…

bobtail4x4

4,220 posts

130 months

I changed a escort mk3 cambelt and waterpump that had seized, in the middle of a forest, (where it went) in the dark once, for a workmate,
after word got about the office I was handy, I got asked once a month for flat tyres / battery etc for the girls,

GeniusOfLove

4,532 posts

33 months

I think it does need to be recognised that changing an engine 30 years ago was a very much simpler job that replacing one today!

People do get really pissy about you working on cars in public car parks or on the road now, busybody tossers can't stand anything different to their grey little lives of television and facebook, but I really like the multistory suggestion that's very crafty.

Wacky Racer

40,397 posts

268 months

alone wolf said:
I've got a car with a goosed engine. The motor still starts and propels the car but I'd like to stick a new lump in it, the problem is I don't have any private driveway space to complete the job. Has anyone completed a similar job in a quiet public area?

RotorRambler

712 posts

11 months

GeniusOfLove said:
I think it does need to be recognised that changing an engine 30 years ago was a very much simpler job that replacing one today!

People do get really pissy about you working on cars in public car parks or on the road now, busybody tossers can't stand anything different to their grey little lives of television and facebook, but I really like the multistory suggestion that's very crafty.
Indeed
Seeing someone washing their own car is a rarity!

StuntmanMike

12,860 posts

172 months

Where about in the country are you OP?

Rough location, see if anyone can help you out/suggest somewhere.

There was a place you could hire ramps near me, sadly the owner died and they are getting fewer.

vaud

57,296 posts

176 months

bobtail4x4 said:
I
after word got about the office I was handy, I got asked once a month for flat tyres / battery etc for the girls,
Why do they want flat tyres / batteries?

POIDH

2,573 posts

86 months

Any industrial places that would rent a space for a week?

Smint

2,729 posts

56 months

GeniusOfLove said:
I think it does need to be recognised that changing an engine 30 years ago was a very much simpler job that replacing one today!

People do get really pissy about you working on cars in public car parks or on the road now, busybody tossers can't stand anything different to their grey little lives of television and facebook, but I really like the multistory suggestion that's very crafty.
An Austin 2200 engine and box out wasn't a simple or light job, but yes back in RWD days it wasn't unreasonable to have an engine out in under an hour.

Just along the road 2 Polish blokes were renting, no driveway they often did work on their cars on the road outside, heard several derogatory comments, all from people who i've never seen even wash their cars let alone check the oil, the lads never made a mess always left the road clean afterwards, good luck to them was my answer.



vaud

57,296 posts

176 months

POIDH said:
Any industrial places that would rent a space for a week?
Who would want the risk for a week of rent?

Old Merc

3,770 posts

188 months

Where are you?
Is there a farm near, do the job in his barn.
You may even find a car repair workshop or engineering business with plenty of free space. You could rent a space and an engine lift.

SuperPav

1,242 posts

146 months

In the past I've done a bit of work on my cars in the road or in a public car park. Never an engine swap, but clutch jobs, rear axle replacements etc.

A few snooty looks from the high and mighty but never any bother. What I do remember vividly is being absolute chilled to the bone, and the feeling of gravel/asphalt chippings always getting stuck to me/everything. To be fair that also applies when I've done work on my car on my driveways!


One thing not mentioned above is those large laybys you get on A roads (some off single carriageways, some off dual carriageways). I mean the ones which are a good 8-9m wide, and probably 50m long. Not necessarily by choice, but I have in the past done work in those and found it really good. It's out of the way enough, flat enough, you can park two cars as required to get a safe space etc. I'd still hesitate to do an engine swap unless it was my old Mini A-Series. Definitely wouldn't want to start that kind of job if you can't finish it!

Multistorey is a great shout, esp. if their T&C's don't mention anything. Just claim it's broken down and you're carrying out a repair. I'd be tempted to wear a high viz jacket so it looks like a repair rather than you trying to steal something.

Also just a small point on multistories... if there's any chance of major oil or fuel spills, I'd avoid it. They can completely ruin the entire top surface of the carpark and sometimes require pretty major resurfacing.