Is this allowed from BT?
Author
Discussion

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Just received the following email - whilst clearly marketing is it a) correct and b) allowed ?

You'll lose your service if you don't take action

Hello,

We have some important news regarding your BT home phone service.


The existing landline has become outdated and is being replaced with a digital service that works over a broadband con

We have some important news regarding your BT home phone service.


The existing landline has become outdated and is being replaced with a digital service that works over a broadband connection. This is happening as part of a UK-wide digital upgrade that phone providers are carrying out to enhance the quality and reliability of your landline services.

As a result of this change, you can no longer take broadband and a landline from different providers. This means that you ll need to switch to BT Broadband in order to keep your BT home phone service.

Edited by alscar on Thursday 23 July 12:03

craig1912

4,602 posts

139 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Yep correct but if you do change your BB provider, with some you can keep your number. We switched to Sky but kept our landline number even though it now goes through our BB router rather than a copper line.

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Thanks for both replies - still fairly aggressive marketing though.
I guess my options are therefore just ditch the landline when BT say and continue with the existing bb supplier and forget about having a landline or switch to say Sky or Talk Talk for both or indeed do what the email suggests and keep both the existing landline with BT but switch BB supplier ?

craig1912

4,602 posts

139 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Depends who you are with at the moment for BB. You might be able to transfer your number to them.

You can also transfer your number to an Independent VoiP which then means it doesn’t matter which BB provider you are with.

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
craig1912 said:
Depends who you are with at the moment for BB. You might be able to transfer your number to them.

You can also transfer your number to an Independent VoiP which then means it doesn t matter which BB provider you are with.
Yes the first I stupidly forgot about !
I guess its just really what becomes the easiest and most cost efficient transaction.


wiggy001

7,262 posts

298 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Consider whether you actually need a land line? I officially ditched mine earlier this year after not having a landline phone plugged in for the past few years. I can't think of a single time it would have been useful.

In fact, I've lived here since 2009 and never even knew what my landline number was! Can still remember my childhood phone number though...

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
wiggy001 said:
Consider whether you actually need a land line? I officially ditched mine earlier this year after not having a landline phone plugged in for the past few years. I can't think of a single time it would have been useful.

In fact, I've lived here since 2009 and never even knew what my landline number was! Can still remember my childhood phone number though...
smile
Very fair point - would certainly stop those scam calls.
I guess we probably only use for emergencies or when there is a power cut and poor mobile reception - village isn't brilliant.
My mother would probably really be the only one that calls me but since she sadly developed Alzheimer's not so much.

595Heaven

3,251 posts

105 months

Thursday
quotequote all
alscar said:
I guess we probably only use for emergencies or when there is a power cut and poor mobile reception - village isn't brilliant.
Once the line changes a power cut will kill the landline anyway. BT are rolling out a home phone with a built in SIM card and battery backup to get around this. My mum has one - The mobile reception seems ok (better than a mobile phone at the same location)

E-bmw

13,101 posts

179 months

Thursday
quotequote all
[quote=alscar]Thanks for both replies - still fairly aggressive marketing though.[quote]

Although it isn't actually marketing, they are just pointing out that "landlines" are becoming obsolete and telling you your options.

This has been "on the cards" and actively talked about by my last 2 BB suppliers (at least 3 years now) that I know of.

Dave Hedgehog

16,240 posts

231 months

Thursday
quotequote all
got rid of my landline 7 years ago, handnt used it for at least 10 years

LeoSayer

7,777 posts

271 months

Thursday
quotequote all
I take that to mean that you can use a provider other than BT as long as they do both phone and broadband.

In any case, I second the idea of losing the landline which I did two years ago with no regrets. If your smartphone supports WiFi calling then mobile signal isn't an issue.

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
E-bmw]lscar]Thanks for both replies - still fairly aggressive marketing though.[quote said:
Although it isn't actually marketing, they are just pointing out that "landlines" are becoming obsolete and telling you your options.

This has been "on the cards" and actively talked about by my last 2 BB suppliers (at least 3 years now) that I know of.
Indeed - marketing not the right word you're right although various consumer groups are also unhappy at the way in which the communication's have been issued apparently.
As you also say not exactly an unknown issue although its the first such correspondence from BT I've received.

wiggy001

7,262 posts

298 months

Thursday
quotequote all
595Heaven said:
Once the line changes a power cut will kill the landline anyway.
Good point!

595Heaven said:
BT are rolling out a home phone with a built in SIM card and battery backup to get around this.
Isn't this just a... er... mobile phone?

Mr Pointy

13,278 posts

186 months

Thursday
quotequote all
If you do decide to keep your landline then be careful, particularly if you want to keep the same number. if you move either on their own then you will lose the other unless the new provider takes steps to make sure it doesn't happen. BT can provide you with a Digital Voice line (keeping your number) as can Zen - also DV.

alangla

6,619 posts

208 months

Thursday
quotequote all
wiggy001 said:
595Heaven said:
Once the line changes a power cut will kill the landline anyway.
Good point!

595Heaven said:
BT are rolling out a home phone with a built in SIM card and battery backup to get around this.
Isn't this just a... er... mobile phone?
Yeah but….

I’ve noticed these being used as the classic taxi courtesy phone in supermarkets over the last few years. Instead of being plugged into a phone line it’s plugged into a power supply and has an aerial sticking out the top. Looks like a normal landline phone but presumably uses a SIM card to make calls.

Obviously you could build one yourself by just leaving a mobile permanently on charge at home but I can see why something that looks and functions like a landline would be attractive to some users.

JoshSm

4,523 posts

64 months

Thursday
quotequote all
The SIM backed phones supplied by BT for vulnerable custoners have an IoT SIM (should connect to any network) and a battery pack like a DECT handset, that way they can survive power cuts and loss of the line.

The SIM mode works on its own number and is meant for minimal outgoing calls only, you cant manage it and it doesn't have a lot of credit. Usually it just uses the landline.

It's very much meant as an emergency option.

If you're using a BT/EE hub the much better option is to use one of their lithium BBUs (you can find them cheap on Ebay) which give you 4 or 5 hours of runtime, and one of the BT (EE) Digital cordless handsets paired direct to the hub (£20 or so on Amazon). That will survive power cuts for a while.

Note that anything relying on the line is useless if the broadband packs up - it's not unknown for it to have sync to the backend but not actually be working beyond that. Which nukes the VOIP line.

At least in that case lights should be flashing but doesnt help you make a call!

Edited by JoshSm on Thursday 23 July 15:05

alscar

Original Poster:

9,099 posts

240 months

Thursday
quotequote all
Luckily we are neither particularly elderly or vulnerable so i think its more about making that first decision of whether we actually need or even want a landline of any description and then whether we can secure a better deal on the existing BB whilst keeping things as pain free as possible.
Thanks again for all the replies.




Davie

6,107 posts

242 months

Thursday
quotequote all
alscar said:
smile
Very fair point - would certainly stop those scam calls.
I guess we probably only use for emergencies or when there is a power cut and poor mobile reception - village isn't brilliant.
My mother would probably really be the only one that calls me but since she sadly developed Alzheimer's not so much.
Power cuts... with landlines moving to VOIP, they need an internet connection to work so in basic terms, your router needs to be on. You can get battery back up options for the router and the ONT (if you're on FTTP) but these days, very few people have an old analogue telephone handset plugged directly into the copper sockets, so if you have a digital / LCD / plugged into the mains power landline handset, it won't work in a power cut anyway.

FlossyThePig

4,143 posts

270 months

About 4 years ago Openreach strung a fibre optic cable along our country lane. Before then our broadband was about 0.1Mb, and now it is capable of being more than we need.

Losing the landline was not an issue as we rarely used it, mobile phone use had replaced it.