If you could, would you have a gun ?
If you could, would you have a gun ?
Author
Discussion

J4CKO

Original Poster:

46,629 posts

228 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
For UK folk, and yes I know you can have a shotgun and various other calibres for specific purposes under strict conditions.

But, would you, if a new government got in and introduced US style gun "laws", i.e. do whatever you want as per some states, would you have a firearm, and what type, would you routinely carry one ?

Personally its a no, I expect I would have shot several people already this year, am joking of course but I dont think humans are, on average stable enough, enough of the time to be entrusted with lethal weapons.


Lefty

20,808 posts

230 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Do you mean handguns?

I have shotguns and an FAC with a slot for a high capacity shotgun. I could easily get slots for rifles but have no real need or want.

Would i want a handgun? Hmmm, probably. Would i carry it in my car or on my person? No.

If i lived in the USA would I carry one in the car? No probably not. Even in New Mexico where i visit quite often, it's really common there but i'm not sure i would feel the need.

K87

4,246 posts

127 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
No, I would shoot people.

I like wet shaving, but for the same reason I wouldn't have a cut throat razor.

_Rodders_

3,321 posts

47 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Nah, I've got it out of my system and if I'm ever invited to shoot I just borrow one.

All the fun, none of the hassle.

TV200

231 posts

98 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I wouldn’t want to and am glad we don’t have guns like the Americans, but if I was there I would have one for security only as there would be a real risk any intruders would be armed. I’m sure it’d end worse than if everyone was unarmed.

Jonmx

2,912 posts

241 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I used to shoot competitively, both full bore and small bore. I very much enjoyed shooting during my time in the military and I maintain an interest in firearms, particularly historic ones.
However, I was diagnosed with Bipolar 10 years ago and I refuse to touch a firearm or shotgun as a consequence. So in answer to the question, no I wouldn't have one.
I do however feel the firearms laws in this country are far too draconian and and are punitive to an overwhelmingly law abiding section of society.
I know folks who suggest we ban all privately owned firearms; I point out that Mexico did that years ago, and ask them if there's any gun crime there.....

vixen1700

28,732 posts

298 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Had a couple of shotguns for clay shooting, a semi-automatic Franchi Affinity and a lovely old mid '60s Nikko Shadow over and under. Used to love taking the Nikko apart and cleaning it.

After 2020 it all got rather expensive and I got rid of them both.

Don't think I'd have a hand gun if the laws in the UK changed to be honest.


CSR Performance

611 posts

16 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Nope. I have an anger management problem wink

Funk

27,543 posts

237 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Nope. Look how well it's going for the US...!

bigandclever

14,324 posts

266 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
If it was only me that could have a gun, no.

If *anyone* else could have one then yes. Have you met people? They're unhinged!

Last Visit

3,636 posts

216 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Currently no and long may that continue. Thankfully no need.

If however it was legal, and my neighbour loony Larry, the craziest guy in the neighbourhood was 'tooled up' to the max with an arsenal of weaponry, the likes of which you could invade a small country with then I may reconsider that position.

LunarOne

7,269 posts

165 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I would but only if the laws changed so that you could use it when defending yourself, your home and family. Otherwise it could only be for target shooting. And then we'd need outdoor gun ranges and training organisations to make sure people are safe.

Having said that I have several shotguns of varying types and I only use those for clay target shooting.

I don't know what kind I would have but the choices are basically revolver-style or magazine style. Probably 9mm.

Even though I would have one or more handguns if allowed, I don't think we should be allowed. Things are fine the way they are.

mac96

6,245 posts

171 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I have always fancied a Winchester 66. Comes of watching too many Westerns

Serious answer is that there has been one occasion when had I had a gun to hand I would probably have shot someone. Once is all it takes, so I wouldn't have one. And you don't need a rifle for protection against bears in Cheshire .

BrabusMog

21,713 posts

214 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Absolutely not. Would be quite cool to say I own a .45 but it would serve no purpose, so absolutely not.

Landlubber

1,018 posts

77 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
Oh yes, im a big fan of revolvers, I'd have a replica Smith and Wesson for fun and a .38 for edc. Perhaps a Glock 9mm for targets at the range. But we're not in America so it's never going to happen.

southendpier

6,186 posts

257 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
If it was only me that could have a gun, no.

If *anyone* else could have one then yes. Have you met people? They're unhinged!
i think this will be the fear and then reaction of many people.

Pit Pony

11,091 posts

149 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
bigandclever said:
If it was only me that could have a gun, no.

If *anyone* else could have one then yes. Have you met people? They're unhinged!
You've pretty much described the US problem.


Anyway. Even if everyone had guns I wouldn't have one.

Same reason I don't carry a knife around.

simon_harris

3,005 posts

62 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
I'd have a room full of every type imaginable, full auto, 50 cal sniper rifles the lot.

Not sure I'd bother with an EDC but I wouldn't not either.

DannyScene

8,019 posts

183 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
For target shooting I'm quite happy with my various air rifles, would I ever EDC a real firearm no absolutely not

5s Alive

2,789 posts

62 months

Wednesday
quotequote all
J4CKO said:
Personally its a no, I expect I would have shot several people already this year, am joking of course but I dont think humans are, on average stable enough, enough of the time to be entrusted with lethal weapons.
Wouldn't trust myself with one and suspect I'm one of the more amenable people around who has in the past attempted to listen and to de-escalate confrontations. Ignoring criminal actions, there are far too many deaths involving 'good guy' shootings and accidental discharges, especially amongst children.

However I say this living in a country where threats to my wellbeing are few and far between - and usually self inflicted! In certain parts of the world though ...