Trying many bikes
Author
Discussion

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Sunday 9th August
quotequote all
Hello. Is there anywhere these days that brings multiple brands together under one roof?

Mrs SM and I would like to get some hybrid e-bikes to do some weekend touring on and off road, but want to ensure we find comfort to last. Decathlon, Specialised, Giant, Ribble etc. all have their own shops and LBSes seem to stock a small number of preferred manufacturers. Is there anywhere one can go to plonk a bum into many seats these days?

ian in lancs

3,853 posts

229 months

Sunday 9th August
quotequote all
Wheelbase, Staveley nr Kendal. M6 J36 and BikeTreks about two miles away. BikeTreks also has a rental base in Grizedale Forest.

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Sunday 9th August
quotequote all
Thanks Ian. However, as usual, I’ve missed a critical piece of info from my opening post (sorry!): I’m based in Wiltshire and can travel to Bath, Bristol, Cirencester, Cheltenham, Swindon, North Somerset, Reading, London (Canada Water area).

WPA

14,881 posts

145 months

Monday 10th August
quotequote all
If your in the South West try: https://www.bicyclechain.co.uk/

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Monday 10th August
quotequote all
Fab, thank you.

Daveyraveygravey

2,116 posts

215 months

Monday 10th August
quotequote all
Is there an Evans near you? Sound like they do exactly the thing you are looking for.

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Monday 10th August
quotequote all
Daveyraveygravey said:
Is there an Evans near you? Sound like they do exactly the thing you are looking for.
Looks like in the centre of Bristol. I thought they'd gone under!

Daveyraveygravey

2,116 posts

215 months

Monday 10th August
quotequote all
Still Mulling said:
Looks like in the centre of Bristol. I thought they'd gone under!
The HQ near Gatwick is trading under the Balfe's name, maybe they bought some or all of the co?

Gin and Ultrasonic

349 posts

70 months

Thursday 13th August
quotequote all
Evans used to be great, but I've found it pretty poor since it was taken over by the Mike Ashley empire.

Decathlon have a decent selection of bikes for all budgets up to Tour De France pro spec, as do Halfords who sell some decent bikes if you can get past the reputation (can be hit and miss).

Also, there are sometimes open days at race tracks (car ones!) where different manufacturers / bike shops come along and let you try their bikes. Not sure if there are any in your area, but it's a good chance to look.

Other than that it's a chance to visit local bike shops and see what they have to offer.

Nigel_O

3,901 posts

250 months

Thursday 13th August
quotequote all
Leisure Lakes Bikes do demo weekends every now and then.

£50 to get in, but there are dozens of bikes to try out and the cost is partly donated to charity and fully refunded if you buy a bike.

Here's a link to their last event - there was also one at Cannock Chase earlier in the year

https://www.leisurelakesbikes.com/blog/demo-weeken...

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Morning All. Been shopping around and doing some research; please can I have some more guidance?

Boardman 8.8 and 8.9...barring the mechanical discs on the 8.8 and the slightly increased complexity of the 2x front groupset on the 8.9, why would somebody looking to traipse around gently not go for one of these, given their price points?



Edited by Still Mulling on Saturday 7th November 10:19

PomBstard

7,947 posts

273 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Based on that table alone, I’d say the ADV8.9 is a bargain - hydraulic brakes are def worth the extra and experience with a GRX 2x set up (2x11 on a gravel bike in my case) has been v positive over the last 3 years.

If it fits and you like it, that would be my pick.

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Thanks, PB. The Trek has also just gone on sale: £1,150!

The only thing I’m split on now is 1x vs 2x gearing. The mental and maintenance simplicity of 1x is appealing, but I understand 2x will give greater fidelity and cadence control. Any thoughts? We’ll be pottering around canal paths and lanes, with and without older children in tow.

PomBstard

7,947 posts

273 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
I think you’re overthinking the 1x or 2x thing - yes it’s an extra component, but in terms of maintenance my experience of a 2x set-up has always been set and forget, even with mtbs. When we were all running 3x set ups for mtb, it was different, but 2x is a non issue, IME

petrolbloke

522 posts

188 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
I bought a Boardman ADV 8.9 in the summer and it's a great bike for the money. The bits on it where costs have been saved are the cranks (not GRX) and the wheels which feel comparatively heavy but have held up fine to some fairly hard riding. But both of those are quite easily upgradable if needed.

I took a while weighing up the 1x/2x choice and went for 2x for speed on the road. If you're not bothered about being faster than about 15mph on the road then I'd probably go 1x, though also consider the ratio of the lowest gear for getting up steep hills which might be better on a 2x bike. The lowest gear on mine is 30/34.

Uncle boshy

552 posts

100 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Still Mulling said:
Thanks, PB. The Trek has also just gone on sale: £1,150!

The only thing I m split on now is 1x vs 2x gearing. The mental and maintenance simplicity of 1x is appealing, but I understand 2x will give greater fidelity and cadence control. Any thoughts? We ll be pottering around canal paths and lanes, with and without older children in tow.
If your anywhere near reading these guys are worth talking to

https://www.pedalon.co.uk/ will give you some good advice

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Thank you. Possibly a bit far, but will suggest to Mrs SM.

We’re down to trying to figure out 2 things now.

  1. Frame geometry - we want a slightly more upright, relaxed frame. Bike Radar reviews indicate Both the Boardman and Trek are towards this endurance-end rather than race-end, and there’s little in it when I compare the measurements.
  1. 1x vs 2x - my mind like the idea of the simplicity of using and maintaining a 1x, but most advice seems to be that a modern 2x (particularly with a clutch like the Boardman) should prove reliable and not need constant adjustment.

PomBstard

7,947 posts

273 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Still Mulling said:


  1. 1x vs 2x - my mind like the idea of the simplicity of using and maintaining a 1x, but most advice seems to be that a modern 2x (particularly with a clutch like the Boardman) should prove reliable and not need constant adjustment.
I’m not sure what you’ve experienced for you to think a 2x set up might need constant adjustment. Yes, a 1x set up is simpler, but the difference in maintenance is negligible.

My own experience over the past 10 years has been on 2 gravel bikes, both with a 2x set up, that led very hard lives, taking on some gnarly singletrack and being hooned around some of the local roadie circuits, with lots of climbing/descending.

The first had 2x11 Shimano 105, and the second (current) bike is 2x11 GRX. I don’t think I’ve touched either front mech in those 10 years, other than for cleaning/lube. Set-and-forget. I’ve only ever touched the rear mechs to change the cable.

Maybe I’ve just been lucky?

I certainly wouldn’t pass up a bike I wanted because it was 2x

Still Mulling

Original Poster:

16,932 posts

208 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Thanks PB. My experience is vicarious, through the reviews of Bike Radar and Cycling Weekly etc. Good to know you’ve not come across issues smile

HenryV1415

1,368 posts

251 months

Monday 9th November
quotequote all
Have you been to a shop yet?

Best advice is to see some decent bikes in the flesh, sit on some of various sizes. Then have a quick ride to get some basic ideas about what you like.
The worse advice I can give you is to use a spreadsheet to add up Spec, then ask unknown people on the internet what they think.

Go to a shop, go to another shop, speak to people who sell bikes for a living. They will do their best to understand your requirements and to get you on the best bike they can for your budget.