Knife Crime
Author
Discussion

Saleen836

Original Poster:

12,530 posts

240 months

Friday 21st August
quotequote all
I know there is a thread on the above somewhere but search wasn't being helpful.

There was a stabbing in Chippenham back in January where a 16yo lad was stabbed in the heart and the trial of the then 15yo has just ended...
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/c1l162yy2ejo

If you want to send out the wrong message to knife carrying youths then this is surely the way rolleyes

anonymous-user

85 months

Friday 21st August
quotequote all
The pattern is interesting...

xx99xx

3,085 posts

104 months

Friday 21st August
quotequote all
'pattern'? 'interesting'?

OutInTheShed

14,975 posts

57 months

Friday 21st August
quotequote all
Drug dealer stabbed.
st happens.

anonymous-user

85 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
xx99xx said:
'pattern'? 'interesting'?
Yes, the pattern. You either identify patterns, or you don't.

Ridgemont

9,723 posts

162 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
I have to be honest the discussion around Jury Trial abolition worried me: the jury system is there for a good reason.

However this, and the example of the Manchester Airport attacks, makes me wonder as it now seems to be the case that juries are landing on utterly bizarre verdicts on what seem to be blatantly prejudiced principles.

The guy stabbed a drug dealer (no loss) and his plea was he didn’t think stabbing him would be life threatening. Which might reduce his culpability from murder to manslaughter but the jury exonerated him of that as well apparently.

????

irc

9,909 posts

167 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
To some extent areas and communities get the crime they deserve. If jurys don't convict killers they get more killers.

I don't live anywhere nearby so their problem not mine.

I wonder if the system matters? In England a majority of 10-2 at least is required to convict so 3 jurors can prevent a conviction. In Scotland a simple 8-7 majority is enough for a conviction so perhaps a verdict like this is less likely.


I don't know the law in England but in Scotland an intent to kill is not required.

I can certainly recall a similar case in Glasow where a drug dealer stabbed a guy once in the buttock as a frightener for non payment. Hit an artery and his victim bled to death. Regardless of an intention to kill it was held that it was an act so reckless that it was murder. Convicted.


" murder happens when a person takes the life of another with intent or with reckless disregard for that person s life."

https://westcourts.co.uk/criminal-defence/murder-c...

butchstewie

68,603 posts

241 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
Ridgemont said:
I have to be honest the discussion around Jury Trial abolition worried me: the jury system is there for a good reason.

However this, and the example of the Manchester Airport attacks, makes me wonder as it now seems to be the case that juries are landing on utterly bizarre verdicts on what seem to be blatantly prejudiced principles.

The guy stabbed a drug dealer (no loss) and his plea was he didn t think stabbing him would be life threatening. Which might reduce his culpability from murder to manslaughter but the jury exonerated him of that as well apparently.

????
It's a very strange one isn't it.

Almost reads as if he's just got away with the whole episode.

xx99xx

3,085 posts

104 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
tele_lover said:
Yes, the pattern. You either identify patterns, or you don't.
But that article only mentions one particular case/incident? For patterns to emerge you need several of a similar thing.

So what is the pattern and what's so special about it that makes it 'interesting'? Surely knife crime is pretty generic. Is getting away with it the interesting pattern as that doesn't sound too common?

Chimune

4,380 posts

254 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
tele_lover said:
xx99xx said:
'pattern'? 'interesting'?
Yes, the pattern. You either identify patterns, or you don't.
Like in astrology?
Are you an astrologist Tele ? It would confirm a few of the patterns i noticed about you tbh.

ATG

23,878 posts

303 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
I don't think this sends any message at all. I doubt you'll find many 15 year olds who are at risk of getting involved in county lines drug dealing carefully reading court transcripts.

When judges and juries make decisions that seem odd when reported in the press it almost invariably means there is something specific in the case that is crucial to the decision that hasn't been reported clearly by the press. If you read the reporting carefully you can usually see past the journalist's obfuscation to the actual basis of the decisions and they are almost always entirely reasonable.

When you hear someone saying judges and juries are daft or out of touch with the real world, you can be pretty confident that you are listening to someone who is daft and divorced from reality.

MrBogSmith

7,048 posts

65 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
xx99xx said:
tele_lover said:
Yes, the pattern. You either identify patterns, or you don't.
But that article only mentions one particular case/incident? For patterns to emerge you need several of a similar thing.

So what is the pattern and what's so special about it that makes it 'interesting'? Surely knife crime is pretty generic. Is getting away with it the interesting pattern as that doesn't sound too common?
He means young black men / teens being involved disproportionally with knife crime, but he’s not brave enough to say it. So he hides behind “patterns”.

I like how he says “identify”, as if it’s not well known.


CMTMB

2,262 posts

26 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
Knife crime is disproportionately high among young black males. And that includes them being victims of it.

I don't think we should be afraid to discuss statistics and facts.

It's a problem and rather than avoiding it in the interests of "equality", or at the opposite end of the spectrum just shouting "usual suspects" on social media, I think more should be done to understand the root cause and what can be done to change it.


98elise

32,896 posts

192 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
Ridgemont said:
I have to be honest the discussion around Jury Trial abolition worried me: the jury system is there for a good reason.

However this, and the example of the Manchester Airport attacks, makes me wonder as it now seems to be the case that juries are landing on utterly bizarre verdicts on what seem to be blatantly prejudiced principles.

The guy stabbed a drug dealer (no loss) and his plea was he didn t think stabbing him would be life threatening. Which might reduce his culpability from murder to manslaughter but the jury exonerated him of that as well apparently.

????
I've always found it hard to believe that someone can stab another person believing it won't be life threatening, especially if you move in circles where carrying a knife is routine.




mac96

6,670 posts

174 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
Seems like the worst possible outcome.

I can't agree that the dead lad was 'no loss'. He had decades ahead of him to change his ways and in any case he is obviously a loss to his family.

And the lad who killed him, by being found not guilty, has lost an opportunity to get out of the drug trade too - the paradox is that he will now be left to do what he likes just when guidance would have been useful.

System has failed both of them.

7mike

3,216 posts

224 months

Saturday 22nd August
quotequote all
Don't these country lines gangs rely on vulnerable kids to sell their drugs? Could it be some level of diminished reponsibility on the part of the killer? Presumably, the jury are privy to more information that has been reported, learning difficulties, something like that?