If you were limited to just one car, what would you go for?
If you were limited to just one car, what would you go for?
Author
Discussion

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,070 posts

208 months

If I was limited to only being able to run one car, then I think I'd go for something like the Audi RS4 or RS6. They offer practicality for my family, and they offer performance too. Plus I've always fancied an X5M as well.

So what would you go for and why?

kambites

71,388 posts

249 months

I'd stick with my Elise. My wife has a four-seater and generally drives whenever we go anywhere as a family anyway.

Stu0302

58 posts

18 months

Honestly, and this seems a very odd one considering my dislike of EVs in the past, a BMW i5 M60.

They have enough range to be practical, enough power to be fun, looks great (IMO) and for someone like me with sensitive hearing; quiet / no exhaust drone usually associated with 500-600+ hp cars.

RustyNissanPrairie

731 posts

23 months

Id carry on with my 22year 2.0Hdi Peugeot Partner. It clacks about nicely, does 57mpg, cost peanuts to maintain, and does everything I ask of it.

Not very PH answer.

RandomCarChat

1,244 posts

75 months

Enjoying my FK8 Type R currently, does everything I need very well.

Money no object though? An M3 Touring.

griffsomething

400 posts

189 months

2 young kids and 2 dogs and not earning mega money = estate that won’t cost the earth to run and maintain.

Probably a BMW M340i in green over tan or wacky banana spec, individual Dakar Yellow over white!

Or with my more safety conscious hat on, a Volvo V60/V90 wagon comparable with what we already have now, but with added bonus of panoramic roof and blonde interior.

Liamjrhodes

488 posts

169 months

M3 touring in green

Every day a journey

3,056 posts

66 months



Practicality..... Pfft.

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,070 posts

208 months

Every day a journey said:


Practicality..... Pfft.
hehe

samoht

7,183 posts

174 months

The last time I had only one car, it was my RX-7. It was useable for two people to go away, could be parked on a muddy verge etc, but was light and special and therefore fun.

The main drawback was an inability to throw a bicycle in the back, but probably worth the hassle of a sucker system or something for that use-case. A definite possibility although I'd want to make sure it has working A/C and probably a single turbo setup for reliability.


The Ferrari FF always seems like a great option, really special car that also has folding rear seats. But a bit big, and thirsty.


The 3-series Touring is always the go-to and I see why.

ETA: Scooby Impreza WRX Wagon could be good, the original GC cars were light and a smooth-revving engine which can make plenty of power.


I honestly don't know if I could live with only an EV, but if so a Taycan ST ticks a lot of boxes. I think if it was one car only for say a year, I would, but if it was for the rest of my life, probably not.

Dusty964

7,287 posts

218 months

An Oak green Cayenne electric turbo.

baconsarney

12,396 posts

189 months

Volvo 850R or V70R (estate)

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,070 posts

208 months

RandomCarChat said:
Money no object though? An M3 Touring.
Liamjrhodes said:
M3 touring in green
They'd definitely make a great all rounder I agree. thumbup

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,070 posts

208 months

samoht said:
The Ferrari FF always seems like a great option, really special car that also has folding rear seats. But a bit big, and thirsty.
I'd definitely like one of those purely for the engine. cloud9

Pica-Pica

16,489 posts

112 months

samoht said:
... The 3-series Touring is always the go-to and I see why...
The 3 series saloon can swallow a helluva lot too, it has to have folding rear seats, of course.

cerb4.5lee

Original Poster:

44,070 posts

208 months

Stu0302 said:
Honestly, and this seems a very odd one considering my dislike of EVs in the past, a BMW i5 M60.

They have enough range to be practical, enough power to be fun, looks great (IMO) and for someone like me with sensitive hearing; quiet / no exhaust drone usually associated with 500-600+ hp cars.
They actually peaked my interest too a while back as well. Their performance really attracted me, and I'm not usually one to get excited about electric either, but I do like them though.

A lot of electric car owners do seem to appreciate the smoothness and the quietness as you allude to as well.

SuperPav

1,331 posts

153 months

In decreasing order of not GAF about ££ and running costs I'd have one of these:

1) RR Wraith
2) Ferrari FF
3) 911 Turbo
4) Taycan
5) Tesla S

Familymad

2,251 posts

245 months

Defender Octa. Small wheels with the AT tyres. No chopped carbon to be seen and the Faroe green but gloss not matte.

v8notbrave

568 posts

41 months

5 series estate with best engine in budget, maybe M5

Not an SUV, goes round corners, does long distance, tip runs, family duties, dog etc

alscar

9,457 posts

241 months

I posted this a couple of years ago.

My wife's RS4 is just coming up to 2 years old - if we" had " to only have one car this might well be it.
Fuel consumption varies from high teens to high twenties.
Hers has the RS Sports exhaust so even with the GPF's it can still sound pretty decent although clearly not going to sound as good as the V8 of the 6.
2 year service plan was just over £528 iirc.
We would both have preferred the 6 but the sheer size of it put her off.

She still has it and has no desire to change.