AMR59 - manual gearbox
AMR59 - manual gearbox
Author
Discussion

Wayne95

Original Poster:

464 posts

277 months

Friday 6th November
quotequote all
Hi,
Looking at changing my current ride for a 2019 vantage .

I’ve had a 430 , V12 and V8 in the past, but now looking at the newer models. Thing is I really want a manual having done the DCT/ auto thing in a couple of others (Ferrari, Porsche).

This limits my choice, but a 59 has popped up and sounds interesting. I remember at the time reviews of the manual were not great, but a few years on and as used buys, is the gearbox usable and desirable ?

I can arrange a test drive , but these tend to be short drives and not enough time to learn the box and develop a sense of how it works once you understand them.

Any owners on here with honest feedback ?

Thanks

roughrider

1,001 posts

217 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Its a fully automatic ZF 8 speed gearbox in the 2019 Vantage, so don't worry.....

Minglar

1,953 posts

154 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
roughrider said:
Its a fully automatic ZF 8 speed gearbox in the 2019 Vantage, so don't worry.....
But the car the OP is talking about is one of the AMR59 cars which was fitted with the seven speed dog leg manual gearbox from the last run of Gaydon manual V12VS cars. If memory serves me right, there have been posts here suggesting the seven speed box connected to an AMG V8 is not a match made in heaven. OP, if you search the AM forum here you will find the comments you need. Personally I’d avoid it, as the automatic gearbox suits the car much better, and that’s the reason why the manual option was quietly dropped, despite APs commitment to producing a manual version of that era Vantage. BRM.

roughrider

1,001 posts

217 months

Saturday 7th November
quotequote all
Ahh, ok, if its the 7 speed manual, just use it as a 6 speed, you only need 1st if setting off uphill. Plus, it should have AM shift, rev matching.

Edited by roughrider on Saturday 7th November 22:38

Wayne95

Original Poster:

464 posts

277 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Minglar said:
But the car the OP is talking about is one of the AMR59 cars which was fitted with the seven speed dog leg manual gearbox from the last run of Gaydon manual V12VS cars. If memory serves me right, there have been posts here suggesting the seven speed box connected to an AMG V8 is not a match made in heaven. OP, if you search the AM forum here you will find the comments you need. Personally I d avoid it, as the automatic gearbox suits the car much better, and that s the reason why the manual option was quietly dropped, despite APs commitment to producing a manual version of that era Vantage. BRM.
I have looked through the old posts which are not that positive, but wondered if anyone on here had lived with one for some time and found a way to like it. many SSII/III posts are negative, but some find it works very well once you learn it - not something that comes through on a short drive or a day with a reviewer.

I really do want a manual car, but it looks like a 911 is becoming the only choice unless I go for older models, many of which are showing their age for daily driving.

Maybe Aston Pangborne will lend it to me for a few weeks to see how I get on smile


Minglar

1,953 posts

154 months

Sunday 8th November
quotequote all
Wayne95 said:
Minglar said:
But the car the OP is talking about is one of the AMR59 cars which was fitted with the seven speed dog leg manual gearbox from the last run of Gaydon manual V12VS cars. If memory serves me right, there have been posts here suggesting the seven speed box connected to an AMG V8 is not a match made in heaven. OP, if you search the AM forum here you will find the comments you need. Personally I d avoid it, as the automatic gearbox suits the car much better, and that s the reason why the manual option was quietly dropped, despite APs commitment to producing a manual version of that era Vantage. BRM.
I have looked through the old posts which are not that positive, but wondered if anyone on here had lived with one for some time and found a way to like it. many SSII/III posts are negative, but some find it works very well once you learn it - not something that comes through on a short drive or a day with a reviewer.

I really do want a manual car, but it looks like a 911 is becoming the only choice unless I go for older models, many of which are showing their age for daily driving.

Maybe Aston Pangborne will lend it to me for a few weeks to see how I get on smile
Well I guess you can always ask. You never know, they might let you have it for a couple of days at least. I did trawl through some of the older threads after I posted yesterday and the problems seem to be very specific to the fitment of the gearbox in relation to the AMG V8, and also the reduced torque figure. There are historic posts from owners who had problems and there were also one or two from well connected people who said the factory wasn’t entirely happy with the end product. I don’t recall seeing any more recent posts mainly because the manual cars are rare and as I said the option quietly disappeared, probably due to low sales figures and the afore mentioned issues. The gearbox itself seems well matched to the previous V12VS, and I always found it strange that AML decided to carry it over in to the “new Vantage” cars, especially as MB AMG never offered a manual option on any of their AMG V8 vehicles (happy to be corrected if that’s wrong though). I’ve seen the Pangbourne car on their website and it does look good, but it seems to be offered at strong money. If you definitely want a relatively new manual I think I’d look elsewhere and possibly go for a 911 Carrera T instead? Be interested to hear how you get on though. Good luck with your search. BRM.